3 ms·
> Men are larger and stronger than women, women are flooded with hormones during pregnancy that force a bond between them and their children. Strength/size is
by shkkmo 11y ago
> Men are larger and stronger than women, women are flooded with hormones during pregnancy that force a bond between them and their children.
Strength/size is a physical trait, not a gender role. Hormone release is a physical process, not a gender role.
>"A liberal swing in culture is trying to encourage people to abandon their traditional gender roles"
If you think that gender roles haven't changed repeatedly undergone significant change multiple times in the last several hundred year, you are living in a fantasy world.
> "people that do buck the traditional roles usually end up unhappy about it"
False. Please go do some research and re-evaluate your assumptions.
> "All I'm saying is that biology has a great influence on the roles people take up,"
No, you claimed that gender roles are baked into our DNA.
Biology has a great influence on everything, including people's choices of gender roles.
> "You have chosen your hypothesis and your conclusion and will ignore any evidence or train of thought that might lead you astray from it. "
Please provide said evidence, because it sounds like you are talking about yourself.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Strength/size is a physical trait, not a gender role. Hormone release is a physical process, not a gender role. Where do you think gender roles come from? The most common job in the US is truck driver. It's not software developer money but it pays better than you might expect. Truck drivers are overwhelming male and you might not see an obvious reason for that and want to blame "gender roles" or sexism. But truck drivers get paid by the mile. So after you drive your truck to a loading dock, you're then standing around not getting paid while 20,000 pounds of freight is loaded or unloaded. You want to get back on the road doing the thing that makes you money, so the truck driver helps with the loading and unloading (which is what everybody expects you to do), and suddenly the population of truck drivers skews toward people with more physical strength which skews heavily male. Then the truck driver is away from home all the time so the truck driver's spouse is the one who takes primary responsibility for the kids, and now we have gender roles even if society didn't start with them.
- shkkmo 11y ago...wow... Do you really believe the reason why fewer than 6% of truck drivers are female is because women are not physically strong enough for the job? Do you really believe this has nothing to do with the sexism of the industry and the perception of this industry by society?
- clevernickname 11y agoOnce again, you completely ignore the arguments of the person you are responding to, and your counterarguments scarcely amount to "it's 2016, come on!" Outside the just world of your delusions, where everyone is kind and good except the evil white males leeching off the world by the right of their "privilege", there are people that would kill you and take your property in a heartbeat. Truck drivers are trusted with transporting and protecting substantial sums of property with every trip they take. I would absolutely trust a big strong man to transport my cargo over any woman, for the same reason that I would not trust a young boy to do so. Thieves (who are mostly strong men themselves) aren't scared of women or boys.
- dang 11y agoPlease stop.
- throwaway160303 11y agoChill out. AnthonyMouse makes a perfectly valid and well-expressed point. Pulling a "wow" at someone else's "naive little worldview" is neither convincing nor constructive. I don't know about a 94%/6% breakdown, but I know that if truck drivers are paid as described, by-the-mile, the workforce must skew heavily male, since pay will be higher for physically stronger individuals. It is not that women are not physically strong enough - it is that stronger people are paid more for doing this job, and therefore the people most incentivized to pick truck driving will be those who are strongest, and the upper echelons of that measure are exclusively male. Not the entire top 3.5 million that it would take to fill every truck driver job in the US, and of course some strong people will choose to do other things, and some less-physically-gifted individuals of both sexes will choose to do it despite not being compensated as well as others with the same job. So. If 94/6 doesn't seem reasonable to you, what does?