3 ms·
South Butt's legal response to North Face complaint
- grellas 17y agoPrior related thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1047500 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1047500. This answer is pretty unorthodox by the normally staid standards of federal court practice and seems aimed as much as anything at generating sensationalism for the defendants' side of the case. I also note that the background of the lead attorney defending South Butt, Albert S. Watkins, is varied and colorful but does not include any mention of trademark expertise (http://www.kwmwlaw.com/albert-watkins http://www.kwmwlaw.com/albert-watkins). A reading of this answer suggests that the defense case may be pretty thin, and I would therefore speculate that the main strategy is to try to force North Face through extraneous means (i.e., by generating unending bad publicity) into dropping or settling the suit.
- jrockway 17y agoIn addition to the strange style, I think it's interesting that they demand a jury trial. That seems to support your theory that this is aimed at generating a lot of bad publicity. I am confused by remarks like "although the client looks 14 and acts like he's 12 at times". "Hilarious", but I would keep remarks like that on my blog rather that in legal documents. Maybe I just have too much respect for the legal system... "Williams Pharmacy" is also listed as a defendant. Who is that?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tricky 17y agoHe started selling his shirts at a mom-and-pop pharmacy down the street from his house.
- andrewcooke 17y agoThere's a lot to read. The best bits are at the start and end: Interestingly, while North Face introduces its Complaint herein by referencing its founders, the present owner of the North Face brand, VF Corporation (formerly known as Vanity Fair Corporation, not to be confused with the Conde Naste publication of the same name), also is understood to own Jansport, Eastpak, Napajiri and Kipling (among others), generally but eroneously perceived by the marketplace as independent competitors of North Face. The original North face founders are understood to have stopped exploring the very brand they created. ... Plaintiff's (NF) products are marketed as products that are to be used in furtherance of an adventurous lifestyle full of exploring, climbing, hiking, skiiing and other outdoor activities. Plaintiff's (NF) products are generally perceived and actively marketed to be expensive items for the "exploring" consumer. Despite paragraph 3 and because of paragraph 4, Plaintiff's products are perceived as being largely consumed by those who have little to no interest in living an adventurous lifestyle, but, rather, are interested in acquiring Plaintiff's products for the status and/or notoriety they receive from being seen in Plaintiff's expensive apparel and accesories. Defendants recognise this bizarre phenomenon. Defendants, utilizing parody, are making a bona fide social commentary on the pervasive banality, frivolity, absurdity and comedic nature of the consumer culture and those who participate therein.
- johnbender 17y agoI believe it's "South Butte"