7 ms·
> what NYSE was doing probably didn't impact you at all. Then where does all the money HFT firms make come from?
by CyberDildonics 11y ago
> what NYSE was doing probably didn't impact you at all.
Then where does all the money HFT firms make come from?
- tptacek 11y agoFirst, HFT firms aren't especially lucrative compared to other finance specialties, so one answer to that question is "nowhere". Second, HFT firms compete with other finance firms, so what money they do make comes from bidding down the costs those firms were imposing on the rest of the market. If you're a retail trader, automated electronic traders make money off you by outbidding the markets to quote good prices to you for your dumb market orders, and then pocketing the spread --- in other words, they make money the same way market makers have always made money; they just make less of it at an instant, but at a far larger scale. The same is true of mutual funds, which is why Vanguard --- the firm most people would say is the most trustworthy in all of finance --- has repeatedly claimed that HFT has lowered their cost of trades.
- revelation 11y agoSomethings off. If all this is is market making, why all the trouble with the microsecond latencies? Microwave links? Shared colos? That seems like a lot of cost everyone could save on by simply having the exchange enforce some minimum timings.
- tptacek 11y agoBecause speed is an implicit and intrinsic "figure of merit" in automated market making: if you are faster than other market makers, you outcompete them. There are two straightforward problems with microsecond-speed electronic trading: * At very small timescales, possibly as a sort of inevitable consequence of the CAP theorem, correlations between instruments that should trade in lock step start to break down. Since you can make money correcting these mispricings, time and energy gets sunk into doing that, and that imposes costs on the rest of the market. It's uncertain how high those costs are, but they are small, and clearly a pittance compared to non-automated market making. * Electronic trading provides very nice paychecks for pretty interesting technical work, which means some talent gets attracted to the market that would otherwise get paid less money doing something with more social value. How big a deal this is to you depends a lot on your worldview. To me, neither of these issues seems worth the galactically high cost of restructuring all the markets in such a way that we'd reliably avoid these problems.
- revelation 11y agoThat's circular reasoning: right now speed is a figure of merit because that's how the game has been designed. I'm suggesting to change the game rules. I don't mean to get rid of automatic market making, I'm saying the exchange could just move to a system where it checkpoints every 10ms or whatever, still much faster than humans can blink, but no detriment to the algorithms. Then everyone has 10ms to come up with orders that make sense in the current market situation, instead of the ridiculous timing game.
- harryh 11y agoYou don't actually have 10ms to act in the scenario you describe. Because there is new information entering the world at all times, you would want to wait until the last possible microsecond before the end of the 10ms window before entering any bids. The window does nothing to remove the need for speed. The world is a continuous system. No matter how hard you try you can't force it to be discrete. (There are other problems in your proposed scenario to having to do with mismatched buy vs sell volume, but we'll ignore those for now.)
- true_religion 11y agoWhat new information? I think the above poster meant to imply that the 10ms delay would cover all market transactions, so if you put in an order now, then no one knows it till the next 10ms stop post. Essentially its buffering all the data then releasing it at once, so it's not a truly continuous system anymore.
- harryh 11y ago> What new information? Stuff that happens in the real world. The stuff that all security prices are eventually based on. It's not a closed system you know?
- true_religion 11y agoAh, that's why I wanted an example. Your answer is fairly obvious, but it's pretty absolute too so there's no way to ask questions like "is this information actually going to affect the bid size or price of a bidder?" or "is this event important but infrequent, like quarterly reporting?" For example, infrequent important events will result in a race for people to submit at the last microsecond, but because they're infrequent 99% of the time the 10ms buffering will effectively change the behaviour of market participants.
- kasey_junk 11y agoA couple of things: 1) It is a common fallacy that there is "the exchange" or "the market". The market is an aggregation of exchanges (and non-exchange traded instruments) across a wide variety of jurisdictions and localities. But even though there is no central coordination between all that jumble, the instruments are correlated. That is, the change in price, demand, or availability of one is a signal about the pice, demand and availability of the others. 2) The market is made up of participants who exist on a band of price/time sensitivity. That is, someone like a retail trader doesn't have extreme price sensitivity but may have time requirements. In trading that style of participant is known as "dumb" (oh traders, you so PC). 3) Market makers make all their money trading spread for time but thats not where the latency games come into play. The latency is because... 4) Smart money is price sensitive (or price informed) and they tend to be where market makers lose money. Smart money tends to be either prop traders with particular algos, large block hedge funds or other market makers. Those are the people who cause market makers to play latency games, because its a vector a market maker can control that keeps them smart. They will never be smarter than the hedge fund that knows its going to buy a bunch of shares and therefore drive up the price, but they can at least jump out of the way quicker than the other smart money.
- nanexllc 11y agoIt is a common fallacy that retail orders ever go to stock exchanges. This is a good way to determine someone telling the truth. Here's proof: http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4704.html http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4704.html
- usefulcat 11y agoIf you're doing market making, note that you're more likely to get a buy order filled when the market is going down, and more likely to get a sell order filled when the market is going up. This is the flip side of getting to "capture the spread". So in order to be successful, especially when your margins are razor thin (and they pretty much always are), you have to be very, very good at canceling your orders as quickly as possible any time it looks like the market is likely to move against you.
- samstave 11y agoCan you define "not especially lucrative"? I.E. how much money is a good HFT firm making at scale?
- tptacek 11y agoVirtu, one of the very largest HFT firms, had revenues of ~$750MM, with net income around $120mm, in 2014. Goldman Sachs made $34bn.
- kbenson 11y agoDoes that list include the HFT arms of the bigger traditional firms? Goldman bought into Perseus[1], so I assume if Perseus counts for them, but I imagine there may be some larger firms with HFT divisions that don't report separately. 1: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-21/goldman-sachs-buys-21-million-stake-in-hft-network-company http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-21/goldman-sa...
- pfarnsworth 11y agoYou are wrong. I'm sure you mean $750M, but they only have 200 employees, Goldman has 40,000. HFT is extremely lucrative.
- tptacek 11y agoThanks for correcting; yes, I meant that Virtu makes a small fraction of what Goldman makes. Goldman, of course, is not principally an HFT firm.
- kasey_junk 11y agohttp://ir.virtu.com/results.cfm http://ir.virtu.com/results.cfm Actual results for 2015. Your numbers are a fair bit off of those. What you can see from the results is that their revenue/profit numbers are small in real terms, but their margins are big compared to other businesses, even technology ones. Personally, I'm not offended by that and think that the entire conversation about HFT is funny given how little money is actually involved, but if you view profitability in any context as evil or rent seeking, then you have ammunition for that argument with Virtu. [edit] Another good one to look at is Knight (Getco) http://investors.kcg.com/phoenix.zhtml?c=105070&p=irol-SECText&TEXT=aHR0cDovL2FwaS50ZW5rd2l6YXJkLmNvbS9maWxpbmcueG1sP2lwYWdlPTEwNzgzNjY1JkRTRVE9MCZTRVE9MCZTUURFU0M9U0VDVElPTl9FTlRJUkUmc3Vic2lkPTU3 http://investors.kcg.com/phoenix.zhtml?c=105070&p=irol-SECTe.... Had a much better year last year vs the previous 2 and it still was a fundamentally little amount of money. [edit again] That Knight statement is very interesting because it shows that the vast amount of their profit came from execution services and that their market making business was very low margin. Now that could be because their market making business is taking the full shot of the infrastructure accounting that enables the execution services business, but its interesting none the less.
- CyberDildonics 11y ago> First, HFT firms aren't especially lucrative compared to other finance specialties, so one answer to that question is "nowhere". Total bullshit. If there was so little money to be made why is every exchange catering to high frequency traders? Why was the building across from the NYSE hollowed out to become a data center? Why are custom fiber optic cables being layed down specifically for it? > If you're a retail trader, automated electronic traders make money off you by outbidding the markets to quote good prices to you for your dumb market orders, and then pocketing the spread --- in other words, they make money the same way market makers have always made money; they just make less of it at an instant, but at a far larger scale. This seems to be typical of HFT apologists. They start to use terms that are defined in other terms that they've essentially made up, much like trying to get to the first principles of a religion. There are no 'market makers', there are people selling with a miminum price and people buying with a maximum price. They aren't outbidding the markets, they are front running by seeing an order, buying it, and then selling it to the original buyer. Everything else is there to obscure the truth. I've seen so many of these posts here and none of them has ever approached any sort of justification or validity.
- gd1 11y ago>They aren't outbidding the markets, they are front running by seeing an order, buying it, and then selling it to the original buyer. Please step me through this scenario. Exactly what do you think is happening, in what order and how?
- tptacek 11y agoFirst, let me gingerly remind you that strong arguments don't appear stronger when they include things like "total bullshit" and name-calling. Second: I didn't say HFT wasn't lucrative at all. I said it wasn't lucrative compared to other finance specialties. I would feel worse about this misunderstanding if the thread you were commenting on didn't include actual numbers backing this up. Third: the ultimate reason exchanges "cater" to "HFT" is that they get paid based on order volume. That's what it means to be an exchange. Exchanges compete with each other. If nobody trades on your exchange, you don't make much money with it. Exchanges would rather you do business with them than not. It's not complicated. Fourth: if you're in the normal demographic of HN (age 20-35 or so), you've never bought or sold a share of stock that went through a human market maker. Market-making is automated now and has been for something like two decades. Fifth: if you're an individual buying and selling stocks for your own account by clicking buttons in an online brokerage, you are placing market orders. There aren't "minimum" and "maximum" prices. There's a current best bid, and a current best offer, and a gap between those two prices. We have decades worth of research on what automated trading is doing to that gap: it is slashing it from dollars to pennies. Sixth: if you are placing limit orders, there is nothing an HFT or anyone else can do to "front-run" you to cheat on your order limit. Incoming orders are priced according to the price on the order resting on the book. When you place a limit order that doesn't immediately execute (in other words: when you place a limit order that is actually meaningful), that's the price your order is going to trade for, if it ever trades. If you disagree with any of this, it would be helpful if you could lay out a hypothetical sequence of events in which this "front-running" is actually occurring. I place a LIMIT SELL order for 1000 CSCO on BATS at $27.90. An HFT decides to front-run me. What exactly happens next?
- TheNanex 11y agoHe's right - if you weren't part of the group that was paying them over $100M/year in fees for "real-time" data and you weren't buying or selling stock in 2008, 2009, 2010 and 2011, it probably didn't impact you at all.
- Spooky23 11y agoThe people making money on the HFT stuff are the exchanges. The HFT people are making realtively easy money, but require vast bulk to do so.