4 ms·
IIRC, HN's yummyfajitas goes into a lot of details in his blog posts on HFT[1]. My own understanding is that it provides liquidity and reduces bid/ask spreads,
by kbenson 11y ago
IIRC, HN's yummyfajitas goes into a lot of details in his blog posts on HFT[1]. My own understanding is that it provides liquidity and reduces bid/ask spreads, resulting in a more accurate stock valuation. I'm not sure the negatives, but I'm not a trader nor do I follow such things all that closely.
1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3852341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3852341
- jobu 11y agoFrom that blog post: "Most HFTs run a market making strategy. What this means is they play both sides of the table - they take no position on whether a stock will go up or down. Instead, they try to offer securities both to buy and sell. If you want to buy, they will sell to you at $20.10. If you want to sell, they'll buy from you at $20. As long as their buys and sells match don't get too out of whack, the HFT will collect $0.10 = $20.10 - 20.00." That does provide more immediate trades for both the buyer and seller, which the pro-HFT camp calls liquidity. Unfortunately it's usually not needed - both the buyer and seller were already in the market and willing to trade, and now they both just had an additional $0.10/share sucked out of their trade by some HFT.
- arohner 11y agoIn the past, either the buyer and seller had to wait longer to find a mutually acceptable price, or pay a lot more than $0.10/share. HFT is actually an improvement for both sides, because they can either 1) buy/sell faster or 2) pay lower transaction costs (and probably both!).
- cdetrio 11y agoThat's why market makers are also called scalpers, because they skim the $0.10 spread. But in return for paying the spread, what traders get is immediacy. The problem is, how much immediacy do traders actually want? HFT provides immediacy in microseconds; its needed for continuous-time auctions because buyers sellers usually aren't in the market at the exact same microsecond interval (while the HFT is there at every interval). Frequent Batch Auctions[1], where orders are matched in batches with single-price clearing (call auction style) - just like the opening and closing sessions of NYSE, but much more frequently with shorter periods of say 30 seconds, 1 second, or even 100ms per batch. Their models show that frequent batch auctions will reduce spreads even further (because it eliminates mechanical/latency arbitrage rents). In theory, retail traders should get even better prices (because the spreads will be smaller) if they are willing to give up microsecond immediacy for 1 second order matching. http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/eric.budish/research/HFT-FrequentBatchAuctions-Slides.pdf http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/eric.budish/research/HFT-Fre...
- kasey_junk 11y agoCurrent continuous-time trading already provides you the ability to specify very precisely how much immediacy you are willing to pay for. Thats precisely what the market types are about. I don't particularly have an opinion about the Budish paper, other than it has some serious impacts to globally traded products and it is way more disruptive than people seem to suggest. I do worry that fundamentally altering the way the markets work, because some participants don't understand order types is particularly troublesome.
- cdetrio 11y agoSimplish order types (limit/market, good till cancel, immediate or cancel, etc.) can only do so much. When you place a limit order on a continuous-time market, you'll pay exactly your limit price; but on a batch market you'll pay the clearing price (which may be less than your limit price). The complicated types (hide-n-slide, NBBO pegs, and conditional pegs[1]) may help some players at the expense of others. The only players who wouldn't benefit from batch auctions (according to Budish et. al.) are latency arbitrageurs. 1. https://mechanicalmarkets.wordpress.com/2015/10/05/iex-peg-orders-last-look-for-equity-markets/ https://mechanicalmarkets.wordpress.com/2015/10/05/iex-peg-o...
- kasey_junk 11y ago> you'll pay exactly your limit price Thats not quite true. Price improvement happens all the time on limit orders, but I'll concede you'll pay close to it if it fills. > The complicated types (hide-n-slide, NBBO pegs, and conditional pegs[1]) may help some players at the expense of others. This is true of limit/market/stops as well. The Budish paper is very interesting. What we don't know is what it would do to the spread, which is very important especially given that it will be harder to predict the clearing price. It is also a major change to the markets, virtually impossible to implement and its not clear to me what that risk is buying us, especially given that I fully expect most participants to go through an intermediate first.
- 11y ago
- harryh 11y agoIn the given example if a buyer wanted to buy at $20 instead of $20.10 they could easily put in a limit order for that price and wait for a counter party. That would be taking a risk though that either: A) a counter-party never showed up B) a counter-party only showed up when the stock dropped so you end up buying on the way down. Taking this risk is a perfectly fine thing to do and many people do this. Others would prefer to pay the market maker a small fee for providing liquidity. That fee is not being sucked out by some HFT. It's a fee for providing a service. And BTW, thanks to automation and sophisticated trading algorithms that service is provided at EXTREMELY low cost these days. Bid/ask spreads are tiny.
- branchless 11y agoWe'd have liquidity without this endless war on getting closer to zero. They are adding nothing and soaking up qualified grads who could be building something useful. This is a great example of how the modern economy fails to link wealth created with wealth extracted.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's true, but it's true of a lot of other things (for instance: huge fractions of all the devs working at Google and Facebook). Meanwhile, trading tech is (IMO) much more fun to work on than a lot of the work Googlers do, lucrative, and not concentrated in the Bay Area. I'd rather we found a way to get everyone to work on drug discovery and civic engagement, but unfortunately, we don't generally put regulatory brakes on technologies simply because they attract developers that would otherwise be working on our pet issues.
- branchless 11y agoWe should put breaks on it because it's not creating wealth. If it's not creating wealth but people are becoming wealthy it's because money is being extracted via economic rent (due to monopoly). When firms make lots of money from trading platforms and then pay staff who go and consume real resources that is ultimately coming by transferring from wealth producers.
- tptacek 11y agoEconomic rent? Monopoly? That was far more true of the firms HFT preys on, and not true of HFT firms at all.
- branchless 11y agoThe big exchanges are showing a little leg to the HFT players in exchange for kick-backs via fees. EDIT: cannot reply due to HN rulz, hence inline... The exchanges compete. The more asymmetric you make the platform for HFT vs the rest the more business you get. Where would you trade? Somewhere you can win or not? Do I want a piece of that? I might let you know the incantations required if you pay me for the "service". In theory other liquidity might move away but many ECNs have a very dominant position. For example NYSE.
- alfalfasprout 11y agoIt's a mixed bag. On the one hand, we really do get a lot more liquidity thanks to having tons of fast market makers. You can get subsecond fills on most marketable or close-to-marketable (eg; limit orders within the spread) on most common stock listed on the NYSE/NASDAQ. But it's often not "real" liquidity. Let's say there's 100 shares available at $100.00, 200 at $100.50, etc. Such that there's a total of 5k shares on the book at this time at any price. But we want to buy 10k shares. The average fill price assuming no intervention and only marketable orders would be (100$100 + 200$100.50 + ...)/5000. An intervening HFT firm will only be adding useful liquidity if the average fill price drops somehow. Shittier algos will lose some money by lowering the average fill price so they match your order and get the liquidity rebate from the exchange. This adds true liquidity. But intelligent market makers generally will just add identical liquidity to what's already available but at 1 or 2 cents higher (and a few slots higher on the order book). As a result, you just end up paying more for the same quantity of shares. That's not true liquidity because it's really only triggered by your order, doesn't move the price significantly, and is limited to exactly the size of your order.
- kasey_junk 11y agoWait, that is still providing liquidity. Its just doing it at a different price, which is the rational thing to do in the face of a multi-level clear. Why wouldn't the sudden appearance of a big buyer that wanted more liquidity at near levels than is available indicate the price should go up? That's supply and demand. Am I missing something about your argument?