20 ms·
I have two questions about HFT: - Is HFT a healthy or unhealthy part of the economy? Meaning does it help flatten out the highs/lows, or does it emphasise them
by Someone1234 11y ago
I have two questions about HFT:
- Is HFT a healthy or unhealthy part of the economy? Meaning does it help flatten out the highs/lows, or does it emphasise them?
- Aside from a micro-tax on trading (e.g. 1c/trade) is there any other mitigations/solutions to HFT?
- SeanLuke 11y agoI don't see why we couldn't put a time delay in. Something like this: when you commit to a trade, the actual trade delayed for some N minutes, where N is a randomly-chosen value from some distribution. Wouldn't this eliminate the incentive to do HFT?
- jgh 11y agoAnother disincentive might be the trade tax that Bernie Sanders has proposed since it would basically affect HFT way more than anyone else.
- cheald 11y agoNo, it would affect everyone - that's why it's so bad. HFT traders would just adjust their minimum spreads and continue on their merry way. Sanders' FTT doesn't attack the mechanisms of HFT, it attacks the markets as a whole - HFT would suffer, but so would everyone else. If you want to hit HFT specifically you need to hit the HFT-specific behaviors - either add a per-message charge (like Canada did) or add a tax to cancelled orders. It's worth noting that after the Canadian regulatory authorities added a per-message fee, bid-ask spreads rose, liquidity dropped, and it was retail traders who suffered the most. http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2014/04/a-study-of-limiting-hft.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2014/04/a-s...
- jgh 11y agoI understand that a trade tax would affect everyone, but for someone like me who makes maybe a handful of trades per month it wouldn't really do that much to dissuade me from making those trades. I also don't particularly care one way or the other what happens with HFT, I was just mentioning this as a thing people are thinking about.
- kasey_junk 11y agoMy big concern with the transaction tax is how it applies to indexed funds/etfs. Those trade all the time so the price impact can be significant for those. Further, depending on implementation, you could easily get taxed multiple times for that as there is a transaction to get in/out of the index, and the internal index transactions.
- harryh 11y agoNo, it would just raise the cost of trading for everyone else. If HFT's risk goes up they have to raise their prices.
- kbenson 11y agoIIRC, HN's yummyfajitas goes into a lot of details in his blog posts on HFT[1]. My own understanding is that it provides liquidity and reduces bid/ask spreads, resulting in a more accurate stock valuation. I'm not sure the negatives, but I'm not a trader nor do I follow such things all that closely. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3852341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3852341
- jobu 11y agoFrom that blog post: "Most HFTs run a market making strategy. What this means is they play both sides of the table - they take no position on whether a stock will go up or down. Instead, they try to offer securities both to buy and sell. If you want to buy, they will sell to you at $20.10. If you want to sell, they'll buy from you at $20. As long as their buys and sells match don't get too out of whack, the HFT will collect $0.10 = $20.10 - 20.00." That does provide more immediate trades for both the buyer and seller, which the pro-HFT camp calls liquidity. Unfortunately it's usually not needed - both the buyer and seller were already in the market and willing to trade, and now they both just had an additional $0.10/share sucked out of their trade by some HFT.
- arohner 11y agoIn the past, either the buyer and seller had to wait longer to find a mutually acceptable price, or pay a lot more than $0.10/share. HFT is actually an improvement for both sides, because they can either 1) buy/sell faster or 2) pay lower transaction costs (and probably both!).
- cdetrio 11y agoThat's why market makers are also called scalpers, because they skim the $0.10 spread. But in return for paying the spread, what traders get is immediacy. The problem is, how much immediacy do traders actually want? HFT provides immediacy in microseconds; its needed for continuous-time auctions because buyers sellers usually aren't in the market at the exact same microsecond interval (while the HFT is there at every interval). Frequent Batch Auctions[1], where orders are matched in batches with single-price clearing (call auction style) - just like the opening and closing sessions of NYSE, but much more frequently with shorter periods of say 30 seconds, 1 second, or even 100ms per batch. Their models show that frequent batch auctions will reduce spreads even further (because it eliminates mechanical/latency arbitrage rents). In theory, retail traders should get even better prices (because the spreads will be smaller) if they are willing to give up microsecond immediacy for 1 second order matching. http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/eric.budish/research/HFT-FrequentBatchAuctions-Slides.pdf http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/eric.budish/research/HFT-Fre...
- tptacek 11y agoYour first question asks whether HFT increases or decreases volatility. That's an open question, and the answer also depends on the time scale that you're looking at. But volatility isn't the only axis on which to measure the health of the markets. The advent of electronic automated market making is also tied to drastic reduction of spreads, which are a tax that anyone trading has to pay to the market for the privilege of buying at the market. A lot of people talk about spreads as if they were a meaningless abstraction, in sort of the same way as they talk about "liquidity". But in the 1990s, crooked human market makers (read: all market makers) rigged spreads to skim extra money off trades; look up the "odd eighths scandal". That doesn't happen anymore, and, more importantly, spreads (and their attendant cost to trading) are razor thin. That's not the only thing automated electronic trading does to improve the markets. For instance, in the 80s and 90s, simply placing an order with a broker was extremely expensive. Today, there are no-fee brokers. Why? Because automated trading systems purchase the rights to internalize orders from retail brokers; if you're an automated market maker, retail order flow is practically risk free revenue, and all you have to do to earn it is hook your trading system up to brokers.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoPeople who stand to benefit directly from High Frequency Trading will tell you it has benefits. Everyone else will tell you it doesn't. Given the choice, someone buying stocks directly would not choose to buy them from an exchange that allows high frequency trading. People will also dispute that, but you have to ask yourself, if HFT is so good for everyone, who is all their money coming from?
- tptacek 11y agoAccusations of shillage aren't allowed on HN; in fact, they're one of the very few examples of pathological message board behaviors that HN actually explicitly bans. You can't dodge that ban by saying "everyone who believes this is a shill" without naming people; I believe HFT has benefits, and I am not a shill. If your comment invites people to litigate whether I'm a shill, you're doing the one of the few things HN specifically asks you not to do. Please don't write comments like this.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoFirst of all, I didn't say shill, you did. I also didn't say anything about you in particular yet you seem to take it personally. Saying that people with different incentives will have different biases is observable in virtually every system that involves people. Second, I'll write whatever I want. You'll have to use your words here instead of playing the victim card.
- tptacek 11y agoThere is nothing magical about the word "shill". The prohibition isn't simply on using the word. https://hn.algolia.com/?query=author:dang%20shill&sort=byDate&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false https://hn.algolia.com/?query=author:dang%20shill&sort=byDat...
- CyberDildonics 11y agoAll I said was "People who stand to benefit directly from High Frequency Trading will tell you it has benefits." Then is a general statement, I didn't say anything about this site or you. Now you seem to be trying to pull a self righteous reframing of what I said to be against some rule set since you seem to be threatened and unable to confront legitimate criticisms. It had nothing to do with you yet somehow you've attached yourself to it along with the word 'shill' which you seem to be focusing on pretty heavily.