6 ms·
I disagree. The FBI's job should be to pursue any and all opportunities at gathering evidence for its cases, within the bounds of the law. It is the job of the
by chongli 11y ago
I disagree. The FBI's job should be to pursue any and all opportunities at gathering evidence for its cases, within the bounds of the law. It is the job of the courts to sketch out those boundaries by interpretation and precedent. If everything is working properly, the courts will decide that the All Writs Act does not grant the Government this power. Then this matter will be settled and the FBI will have to find some other avenue.
Looking at it from the other angle, I think it's a bad precedent if the FBI were to refrain from pursuing an avenue which it believes it may have legal standing to pursue. At that point, it runs the risk of a downward spiral of second-guessing and apprehension.
- Zigurd 11y ago> FBI's job should be to pursue any and all opportunities at gathering evidence That's only true in a vacuum. In reality, every tinpot tyrant on the planet would like to have the US set a low bar so they can insist that US tech companies agree to their similar demands.
- mbreese 11y agoAnd because we have a three branches of government, it is up to the courts to make sure that the bar is set very high...
- Zigurd 11y agoTrue but irrelevant. It isn't inherently law enforcement's job to probe constitutionality. That's like saying law enforcement should probe just how much force they should use against you before they get sued by the DoJ. It's just as valid an argument to say they should be cautious about constitutionality and still get their job done.
- mbreese 11y agoIt's hardly irrelevant. The parent post said "every tinpot tyrant on the planet would like to have the US set a low bar". In this case, it's important to remember that the executive isn't the only branch of government to have an opinion here. No one said anything about probing constitutionality. There is a legitimate question about the limits of the All Writs Act. So they asked a court to issue the request. Law enforcement must work within the confines of the law, but when there is a question of what those confines are -- and in the legal sense, that is most definitely an unanswered question here -- they ask the courts to decide. Once the courts rule, I expect for the FBI/etc... to act in accordance with the ruling. And if you don't like the ruling, talk to Congress.
- revelation 11y agoThe FBI is part of the executive branch, as such we expect it to do the bidding of the government, which in turn we expect to the bidding of the populace. As such, no, of course the FBI should not pursue every legal opportunity when that would run counter to the governments intentions or beliefs.
- dredmorbius 11y agoConsider the Geneva Convention. It's every combatants' obligation to see that the Convention's requirements are upheld. Disobeying direct orders to the contrary is a requirement. This ... creates certain elements of friction and pressure.
- AnkhMorporkian 11y agoIn no world can the FBI be viewed as 'combatants.' They're a civilian law enforcement agency, and the Geneva convention definitely _does not_ apply to them. Ethically, yes, they shouldn't be doing this, but we can't pretend rules of war apply to a civilian agency with 0 role in combat.
- adventured 11y agoThe parent comment was not making that comparison. They were not trying to imply that the FBI is a combatant on a battlefield. It was meant to be an example of friction caused by multi-directional pressure (in the FBI's case, to strictly obey the law and yet to be aggressive in solving crimes by any means within the law).
- AnkhMorporkian 11y agoI guess I'm confused then, because that's precisely what the FBI is doing, and that's exactly what the grandparent comment is doing. The FBI didn't try to side-step the courts, it brought it to them directly and is indeed strictly following the law.
- matt_wulfeck 11y ago> it brought it to them directly and is indeed strictly following the law If this is your definition of "strictly following the law" imagine yourself in a scenario where the FBI brings a lawsuit against you: risk going to court, losing, and going to jail, or hiring a lawyer and fighting something with dubious constitution grounding. There are so many different ways to lose when the FBI plays this game against private companies or individual. They sue you because they want to put you in jail, not clarify the law. If you're a strongly opinionated CEO of a company with a war chest you fight it and at the very least stay out of jail. If you're the CEO of a small ISP/web hosting company you suck it up, do what they say, and follow the gag order.
- dclowd9901 11y agoI don't have a problem with the FBI making a request that is in accordance with their jobs. Let the courts sort it out. What I do have a problem with is this little fucking PR parade Comey's going on to try to lobby the public against Apple in particular, and privacy and cryptography in general. He's been completely rhetorical this whole time, ignoring the fact that what he's asked for is a huge fucking deal, and forcefeeding "terrorism", "public safety" and other trigger words to get the public to rally behind something they couldn't possibly understand. Make the request and shut your stupid mouth, Comey.