4 ms·
Also, let's not forget that there's a huge class of people who aren't old enough or wealthy enough to retire, but whose current jobs are going away quickly. Th
by timr 17y ago
Also, let's not forget that there's a huge class of people who aren't old enough or wealthy enough to retire, but whose current jobs are going away quickly. Those folks aren't going to be working as programmers at startups in the brave new world.
Creating "good" jobs then becomes something more like "creating good jobs that can can keep the current population employed". I don't hear many people talking in those terms anymore.
- philk 17y agoI suspect we'd be better off if we invested in education for these folks and retrained them to do something people actually want nowadays. They might not be working as programmers at startups but there's still a lot of worthwhile tasks we could get these people doing with the right preparation and support.
- timr 17y ago"I suspect we'd be better off if we invested in education for these folks and retrained them to do something people actually want nowadays." Problem is, evidence suggests that retraining doesn't work very well. Here's a heartbreaking series of stories about furniture workers who were laid off when their factory outsourced their jobs. The reporter followed them as they took a community college training program, and tried valiantly to get jobs at the Google data center opening nearby: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=121516133 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1215161... http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=121567306 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1215673... http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=121576791 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1215767... Unsurprisingly, virtually none of the people got jobs at Google, and the ones who didn't ended up doing things like working at WalMart at much lower wages. It's a myth to pretend that we can re-educate enough blue-collar workers to make a dent. We're going to have to find another way, and my suspicion is that it's going to involve a resurrection of trade barriers until older workers can retire.
- philk 17y agoThanks for the articles. I'm not sure, however, that the examples cited within them are entirely fair - they took middle aged furniture workers and tried to get them jobs at Google after a few years retraining. Of course a guy who's had six weeks of classes in Linux isn't going to get a job at one of the most technical companies in the world. What I was thinking was more along the line of retraining them to do useful blue collar jobs - for example HVAC maintenance - which can't be easily offshored and still is useful to society. It's a myth to pretend that we can re-educate enough blue-collar workers to make a dent. We're going to have to find another way, and my suspicion is that it's going to involve a resurrection of trade barriers until older workers can retire. I'd be reluctant to do this, as it's essentially a tax on everyone else to support them and essentially surrendering to the fact that we can get very little value out of these workers.
- timr 17y ago" Of course a guy who's had six weeks of classes in Linux isn't going to get a job at one of the most technical companies in the world. What I was thinking was more along the line of retraining them to do useful blue collar jobs - for example HVAC maintenance - which can't be easily offshored and still is useful to society." Well, yes...the story is tragic because they never had a chance. But I wouldn't be quick to assume that this is a story specific to Google. You'll note that a lot of these people end up doing menial work, even after their re-training program. One presumes that if it were possible to find better jobs, these people would have found them -- they certainly sound like dedicated workers. Instead, they're working double-shifts at WalMarts and prisons. "I'd be reluctant to do this, as it's essentially a tax on everyone else to support them and essentially surrendering to the fact that we can get very little value out of these workers." That's one way of looking at it. Another way of looking at it is that we've consistently exploited cheaper labor markets to undermine our own, without building non-US markets for our own products. Moreover, many of these foreign labor markets have been playing currency games to ensure that US workers can't possibly compete. It's a system that's rigged against US production, and taxing it is one way of reintroducing balance.
- 17y ago