6 ms·
The Svbtle Promise
- colemannerd 11y agothis skips the entire point - it says within their power. Servers cost money. How is it going to be "within their power" if they have no money?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dcurtis 11y agoI'm working on a trust that will be created in the event of my death (or the company's death) that can keep the servers running for a very long time to come, even with no paying customers. Will make that public when it's finished.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- benaiah 11y agoPerhaps it would have been better not to make the promise until you had the backing for it. I think that's what's causing most of the negative reactions here.
- ceejayoz 11y agoHaving just seen Mandrill's "free forever!" tier turn into a $240/year minimum spend, color me a bit skeptical.
- hire_charts 11y agoIf you stop paying (e.g. if they increase prices on you), you lose the ability to publish new content. This is different than "free forever." Their "promise" is that existing content will, to the best of their ability, never disappear from the web.
- ceejayoz 11y agoI'm not sure how this is a response to my comment. Mandrill's free tier was "12k emails, free, forever". It didn't last forever. The use of "everything in our power" in this announcement makes it essentially meaningless.
- alexgaribay 11y agoWhich is why I'm moving to SendGrid.
- supster 11y agoSame here.
- vinceguidry 11y agoPardon my language, but fuck free. I don't want to rely on anything that's free. It's a perversion of market principles. I don't take any startup offering seriously that starts with free. Charge money and make the value proposition clear. Yes that means you can't compete with Amazon or the big boys on price. Differentiate with better service or find a better idea. Free is for entertainment.
- ceejayoz 11y agoFuck free, but fuck forever too. Neither one is realistic.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- thesimon 11y agoAnd it's not even $240/year, you need a paid MailChimp plan as well, so the total costs is at least $360/year. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11170713 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11170713 "free forever" -> $360/year in a matter of days. Not sure what they were thinking how this reflects on their brand.
- danneu 11y agoBitPay is an even more brazen example, using the "unlimited" and "forever" combo together in the same sentence. September 2015: https://web.archive.org/web/20150709093806/https://bitpay.com/pricing https://web.archive.org/web/20150709093806/https://bitpay.co... A free plan with unlimited processing, forever February 2016: https://bitpay.com/pricing https://bitpay.com/pricing FREE: 30 Transactions / Month, Up to $1,000 Daily
- sp332 11y agoMan, this is such a breath of fresh air after seeing the startup scene in general treating user data as trash when the service folds. That's not your data; your users just let you hold it for them.
- minimaxir 11y agoNote that not all user data (e.g settings, drafts, etc) is being saved; only the published content.
- dcurtis 11y agoActually, we do save all user data right now and don't plan to change that--but it's hard to promise to keep that stuff forever.
- minimaxir 11y agoThat's not immediately clear from the verbiage (both places about the promise only mention "content you publish"), so that might be something worth adding.
- dyladan 11y agoHe actually addressed that. He said its hard to promise to keep that stuff forever, implying that limiting the promise only to published content was an intentional decision in order to make it feasible to make the promise at all. Notice also that he did mention that they save that stuff right now, despite not promising. Better to promise to save what you can than to not save anything at all. I thought his response was quite adequate.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bsimpson 11y agoNobody starts a company going "and if we fail, fuck the users." The problem is that maintaining service takes resources that cease to be available when you fail. This "Promise" does very little to allay those concerns. What's your plan to maintain those links and user data if you get acquired/shut down?
- dcurtis 11y agoAs I mentioned elsewhere, there are certain things that can be done to keep the service running for at least your lifetime--I'm working on a trust that will be created in the event of my death (or the company's death) that can keep the servers running for a very long time to come, even with no paying customers. We will make that public when it's finished.
- michael_nielsen 11y agoGreat idea! Could the trust somehow have an arrangement with the Internet Archive to ensure all content is archived? It'd act almost as a last will and testament for a company.
- supster 11y agoWow that is some incredible commitment. Mad respect.
- sbierwagen 11y agoWe will make that public when it's finished. Well, why did you announce now, rather than when you actually had the legal agreements lined up that could lend real weight to a promise to keep the site up forever?
- dcurtis 11y agoBecause it's going to take months to work out the specifics and I wanted to make the promise now.
- DanBC 11y ago
- jakub_g 11y agoWhile I like both Svbtle and Medium, I'd still prefer to have the blog fully controlled by myself. I'm thinking about git(github pages)+jekyll because I don't want to pay for a server. Having said that, Svbtle's kudos are a nice thing. Is there any simple, trusted upvote-as-a-service thing out there so that I can embed it in my blog and don't have to maintain a server+DB myself? Everyone and their dog offers free advanced analytics, but I want a simple upvote button API :) Edit: nope, FB is not what I want.
- matt4077 11y agoWell, there's this startup called http://thefacebook.com http://thefacebook.com. Not sure if it'll go anywhere, though.
- benaiah 11y agoSadly, Facebook's Likes are probably the only version of this that has enough of a network to meaningfully make comparisons. It's essentially an upvote-AAS.
- drinchev 11y agoSince you are using "git" & "Jekyll" I would say you are a technical person, so you should just do it. A couple of days scripting, designing and configuring I managed to have a decent blog [1], without paying a dollar. I'm using a combination of metalsmith, Amazon s3 & gulp. 1: http://www.drinchev.com/blog http://www.drinchev.com/blog
- Fogest 11y agoIs your sidebar suppose to have a vertical and horizontal scroll bar on it?
- sbierwagen 11y agoWhile I like both Svbtle and Medium, I'd still prefer to have the blog fully controlled by myself. I'm thinking about git(github pages)+jekyll because I don't want to pay for a server. If you're not paying for a server, you don't "control it" in any meaningful way.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAny plans on using IPFS and Archive.org to accomplish this?
- dcurtis 11y agoNo, we want to do it ourselves. Only in the case of something horribly catastrophic would we resort to using an external service like Archive.org--but unlike other startups, we would work very closely with them to archive all data. And perhaps even give them the domain name.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bsg75 11y agoDoes a feature such as making account content a git clonable repo in the background ? Then all changes and revisions are easily maintained where ever a user wants.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThats essentially what IPFS is (content addressable by its hash). http://ipfs.io/ http://ipfs.io/
- Smudge 11y agoIn addition to keeping the permanent URLs live, why not pledge to release the source code? Seems to me that this would be the easiest way for users to take control of both the data and the platform, in the event the company becomes financially insolvent.
- dcurtis 11y agoGood idea--we'll add that.
- jaxomlotus 11y agoI'd also add to that - build in a simple way to export your data (maybe it already exists). That kind of trust and confidence in your product being so good that you give people the keys to leave at any time would remove any hesitation at all.
- benwerd 11y agoThis would actually be a brilliant solution. Pledge to release the source code in an installable form (code is useless unless you can run it) if the company becomes insolvent or otherwise stops trading. Ensure data can be migrated. Then, in the meantime, provide the best service possible.
- Mizza 11y agoI know it's usually frowned up to reply with media references here, but this is such a preposterous claim that I couldn't help but think of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yaTCXcvTGY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yaTCXcvTGY
- palakchokshi 11y agoThis feels a bit like a marketing gimmick, especially when you read the fine print. If forever means "till Svbtle becomes financially insolvent", that is no different from any other company that shuts down because they don't have money. The only thing that this promise promises is that if Svbtle gets acquired then as part of the purchase agreement the buyer will be required to keep Svbtle "alive". But what guarantees the buyer from selling again and not including that in that agreement and the new purchaser from shutting it down? And don't make a promise where your fine print says these policies are subject to change. That's not a promise that's a promise with your fingers crossed behind your back.
- dcurtis 11y agoIt's not a marketing gimmick--it's a promise. It's how I want my own blog to be treated. We announced this publicly so that you now know: if you write on Svbtle, your content is vastly more likely to survive for a long time than if you used your own server (probably) or if you used another publishing startup.
- palakchokshi 11y agoOk I understand your motivation, I really do. However announcing something publicly with fine print that says you can't be held liable for that announcement basically negates that announcement. Either you promise and stick to it (no fine print) or you announce something that catches someone's eye because they wish there was something out there that worked this way and you get them as a paying member but has a way for you to go back on your promise (thus making it a marketing gimmick).
- zimbatm 11y agoI think that you mean a pledge. Anyways, I think that it would have been more effective if there was an actual plan associated to it. For example explaining that all the static content is stored on S3 and there is money set aside to fund the static serving for 5 years. And that users can get a dump of their website for after that period.
- hotcool 11y ago
- mintplant 11y agoYou mention design customization in this post, and the Svbtle homepage claims "the best reading experience". Have you considered offering a toggleable dark mode to readers? The glaring white background of every Svbtle post, combined with the large amounts of blank space, agitates my eyes.
- softinio 11y agoWhat I read into this is that a lot of people have moved from Svbtle to medium.com so hence they are looking at giving reasons for people to stay. Guess a complement to how successful medium.com is becoming.
- pdog 11y agoThis looks similar to Posthaven's pledge[1] to "last forever". There was a similar discussion on establishing a non-profit trust or foundation[2] to carry out this objective. What happened? [1]: https://posthaven.com/our_pledge https://posthaven.com/our_pledge [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5230137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5230137
- dcurtis 11y agoGarry and I have the same goals and motivations (and we are good friends).
- pdog 11y agoGreat!
- garry 11y agoI've literally written Posthaven into my estate plan to make sure there is funding for it, if that helps. There's pretty considerable paperwork involved in a nonprofit and it's been trickier than I had hoped to get it there.
- pdog 11y agoAwesome!
- rmetzler 11y agoI was a little bit active on Posterous. I was a broke student when Posterous closed and so I never made the transition to Posthaven. So my little blog isn't on the internet anymore, but I hope I have a backup somewhere.
- sdegutis 11y agoYou know, there are a lot of blogging and micro-blogging sites popping up in the last 10 years (Wordpress, Blogger, Medium, Svbtle, Octopress, etc), but I can't help but feel that nobody cares what most people have to say. Twitter has devolved into this weird sort of micro-marketing medium, Medium and Svbtle have devolved into Wordpress, Facebook has devolved into Yahoo's old front page. Any given person's software blog is probably only used as knowledge-portfolios on resumes, and are almost always abandoned for anything else more worthy of that person's time. The whole social aspect of blogs and micro-blogs seems completely useless compared to more transient services like snapchat or whatever. I just keep wondering when all these tons of mass-communication services are going to go the way of our old geocities pages.
- duderific 11y agoI tend to agree, but with the following qualification: I don't really read any particular person's blog regularly, but I do end up reading a range of blog entries when they are linked from some sort of aggregator (HN, Twitter etc). Additionally, as a software developer I often find myself on the blog entry of another developer who has blogged a solution to just the exact problem I am facing, which is extraordinarily helpful. For those reasons I feel that these blogging sites should and will continue to exist in some shape or form.
- orf 11y agoThere's a lot of hate in these comments, and I think a bit unnecessary. The fineprint says of financial insolvency: "In the event that one of these extreme cases comes to fruition, the founder of Svbtle currently intends to take additional actions in order to continue honoring the above promises". Surely the meat behind Svbtle is the user accounts, the kudos, the database. That's expensive. If Svbtle were to shut down couldn't the owners just create a snapshot as a bunch of static files, wack it on a $10p/m VPS behind nginx and a free cloudflare plan? They could even release it for anyone to mirror. The idea is noble and seems great. Stop jumping to conclusions, this guarantee is still better than any other shaky blogging startup without one.
- deegles 11y agoThere's a lot of negativity and people poking holes in the promise in this thread. I'm glad that Svbtle is taking steps and thinking about the (really) long term. So kudos for that.
- kawsper 11y agoI am a paying Svbtle user. I like the interface, and I like that platform. I sent Svbtle some comments about their platform last year. I wanted links on the blogposts to use target="_blank", and a way to tweak which image gets shown when you share a post on social media. There was also a few issues with images you couldn't get back to thumbnail-mode after having click-zoomed in on it. I didn't hear back, but a "No we don't want to do that" or "We read the mail" would have been appreciated. But I guess my priorities aren't aligned with Svbtle, which is sad. I care less about how long my posts live in their infrastructure (and beyond), and more about how my data is consumed and shared today.
- baby 11y agoIf you want to customize tiny details like that, you should have made a blog yourself. It's really not that hard. For me the point of paying for a service like Svbtle is not having to care about these details and only on the content.
- zorpner 11y agoAnyone wondering how this is going to end up should read the story of TextDrive's "lifetime hosting": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TextDrive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TextDrive
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hooande 11y agoWhy not just open source the code and make the data easy to import/export? My thought is that Svbtle is two things: 1) a website 2) a company/brand. This promise seems to be mostly about the website. As long as I can export the data, keep the domain name and use the same code/design/theme options then it doesn't matter to me if my Svtble branded blog is hosted on their website or $2.99/mo shared hosting. It'll look the same to my readers and function the same to me as a writer. I don't need a promise, just let me export/import everything or at least pay someone to do that for me. What I think is more interesting is the question of what will happen to the brand and culture of Svbtle, and Posthaven as well. Would it even be the same company if it was run by the executor of the founder's will? And if so, then why not just hire an executor now? I've always been intrigued by the idea of Autonomous Corporations, and it seems like something kind of similar would be an interesting way to solve this problem. It really comes down to, can a brand and style be maintained into perpetuity without daily human effort and upkeep, or will it lose its haecceity over time? I guess we'll have to wait a long time to find out.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoIs it legally binding in some way? Is there a funded trust set aside with a charter and instructions on how to handle caretaking services once svbtle itself has shut down? No? Well then these are just words, which will be meaningless when the shit hits the fan. You can have all the best intentions in the world, when the walls close in and you need to think about your mortgage, paying the light bill, and keeping food in your stomach I can guarantee you that keeping someone else's blog running will be so far down the list of priorities it'll get trampled underfoot. This isn't rocket science, lots of human beings have figured out how to set up organizations and funds to continue doing work after they are long dead. Alfred Nobel died over a hundred years ago, for example. But it requires setting aside money now to make that guarantee, not just some nice sounding words on the internet.
- baby 11y agoThat is a bold promise that they will have to break at some point. Everything is ephemeral in this world, especially applications on internet. There is one thing they could have done: commit an amount on money in an official bank account, or with a contract, etc... that will serve as the back up plan to keep the content online if only they were to shut down. Keeping static text online is actually pretty cheap. But then if you want your content down one day you would have to have some sort of dynamic back end, maybe even a support if a bug comes around, etc... Another problem.
- mbrock 11y agoWhen I hear "forever," my ears perk up because... that's a long time. Will my content be on Svbtle for, say, 200 years? I'm very curious about how you can honestly promise that.