5 ms·
What I’ve learned so far from living in a Mars simulation dome
- stickfigure 11y agoOne thing I find consistently missing from these sorts of discussions: Sex. I get that we have a social taboo against talking about it. But really, can we isolate small groups of humans in faraway places and not expect that this will become a major issue? Do we only send couples? What happens when couples split or one member dies? Or does NASA think they can find a perfectly asexual team to send to Mars? Or is this subject simply being ignored completely?
- skriticos2 11y agoThey might send some porn and maybe give the crew some privacy.. but really, if they are focused on how not to die in the next 72 hours for the duration of the mission, this might not be as big a problem as you think.
- xyzzy123 11y agoBut then again, if you have a high probability of dying in the next 72 hours...
- mdcox 11y agoI can't help but feel we're all underestimating boredom in this scenario. Yeah, you have to survive, but eventually things will be stable enough for there to be SOME downtime, with very few options for entertainment. When sanity is involved, boredom is a massive problem and sex might be one of the easiest forms of entertainment to arrange depending on what constraints were involved when planning the mission.
- elorant 11y agoHere's a very good wrap-up of the issue: http://motherboard.vice.com/read/sex-in-space http://motherboard.vice.com/read/sex-in-space
- JBiserkov 11y agoAt least in The Martian book/movie there is something about the topic.
- mcmatterson 11y agoA close friend of mine was on a previous Hi-SEAS, and I can say that this was also one of the first questions we asked of them upon their return to Earth. According to my friend (who I'm not identifying out of respect for their privacy), the, uh, 'interpersonal relations' are in fact both manifest and juicy, and are a very substantial part of what they cover during the extensive surveys and debriefs that take place during and after the mission. It's a big part of what they're studying, even if they don't talk about it publicly.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoYou know, among the religious, there are still a few people out there who swear vows of chastity and go their whole life without sex. It's not really an irresistibly powerful human need like, say, oxygen. If there's a real good reason like SPACE I'm sure we could find a few qualified people who would be willing to abstain for the rest of their life; it's not a deal-breaker on the scales that the earliest space colonies will be recruiting from. Granted, long-term colonization with a permanent population is obviously going to need some (and it will probably be small-town awkward for a while, and having your family life be everyone's business because of population and resource planning may be an interesting step backwards for today's liberated culture) but we can worry about that after we have nonzero population on Mars.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoYes, we (I and many other people) know that religious groups use control over members sexual life as a method of wider population control. We also know that very often sexual relations form spontaneously in a small closed group. Based on this I find your comment irrelevant and bordering an insult.
- fennecfoxen 11y ago> I find your comment irrelevant this is a plausible finding > and bordering an insult. An insult? Is something in your sense of self or your psyche built around the proposition that sexual self-control is substantially impossible anywhere in the human population, such that any assertion contradicting it is insulting? Because that doesn't seem a very healthy way to relate to an idea. In fact, I'd say that if you are unable to entertain an opinion contrary to your own, that's the literal definition of bigotry, whether the opinion is valid or otherwise, and it is difficult or impossible to conduct rational discourse amidst such closed-mindedness.
- eveningcoffee 11y ago> An insult? You seem to be inferring that some people are superior than other people because of their religion. As you do not spell it out directly, then I consider that it is bordering an insult and not a direct insult. I hope this answers to your question. > Is something in your sense of self or your psyche built around the > proposition that sexual self-control is substantially impossible > anywhere in the human population, such that any assertion > contradicting it is insulting? I am actually not arguing about (see above) that certain individuals can not apply limited control over their bodies. What I am arguing is that it is common (and natural (1)) among humans to form sexual relationships and it would be also natural to discuss scientific issues (think about things floating around in microgravity for an example or conflict psychology, or the list would go on) and policies related to this aspect of human behaviour. While you seem to suggest that we do not discuss about the issue and should expect celibacy from every involved individual without any further discussion. This is not a scientific approach. (1) if you think that it is not common and not natural, then try to explain to yourself why there are religious rules (policies) about it. > In fact, I'd say that if you are unable to entertain an opinion > contrary to your own, that's the literal definition of bigotry, > whether the opinion is valid or otherwise, and it is difficult or > impossible to conduct rational discourse amidst such closed-mindedness. I hope that the above also answered to this question.
- autopov 11y agoThe psychological challenges are interesting. Psychiatrists and psychologists often need to vent to a peer to deal with being the person who counsels others. I imagine or hope that some cross training is performed in the sMARS mission so that one person who is incapacitated doesn't create a cascade of other problems (e.g., the French biologist can't attend to the life-sustaining Cyanobacteria). A crew member suffering a mental breakdown could doom the mission. Is her medical kit stocked with sedatives? Does increased radiation exposure alter brain structure? So many risks that we know of and some that we don't.