5 ms·
Proposition 13 is one of the worst failures of California's experiments with direct democracy. It was a bald-faced grab for cash; and it grossly distorted the
by epistasis 11y ago
Proposition 13 is one of the worst failures of California's experiments with direct democracy.
It was a bald-faced grab for cash; and it grossly distorted the housing market, been a huge handout to rentseekers and entrenched interests, starved public schools, hugely increased housing prices, prevented sensible house renovations (in order to preserve tax status), allowed an obstructionist ideological minority (33%) to stop any sort of sensible and economically beneficial tax reform, and above all increased inequality.
It's also a political third rail. It's time to change that. Prop 13 is bad, and those who support are making life and the market far worse for general society, for a much smaller tax break for themselves. It's greed, and it's bad.
- x0x0 11y agoI think we may be approaching enough frustration in CA to undo 13, but I'm not sure at all how we manage the transition. It's a giant mess.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dba7dba 11y agoI know someone who was in CA public school system when Prop 13 passed. He recalls how many programs were simply slashed the year after Prop 13 was passed. --Also I think it's time Supreme Court revisits these limits on laws that require more than 51% to pass/revoke a law. Doesn't seem democratic to me-- Edit: Sorry I wasn't clear earlier. This provision in Prop 13 seems undemocratic: 'two-thirds (2/3) majority in both legislative houses for future increases of any state tax rates or amounts of revenue collected, including income tax rates and sales tax rates' It effectively removes the ability for the tax law to be changed...
- GunboatDiplomat 11y agoSeems to me that since the Constitution itself requires more than 50% +1 for certain issues, it would be difficult for SCOTUS to rule that it's unconscionable to do so.
- dreamdu5t 11y agoAnd what about home owners that couldn't keep up with rising taxes after purchasing their home? Rising real estate prices were hurting families who saw their tax bills jump based on local housing sales, and it prevents people from being able to accurately budget long-term purchases like housing when they can't anticipate a stable tax rate
- epistasis 11y ago>And what about home owners that couldn't keep up with rising taxes after purchasing their home? So much wrong here. #1 they can sell their homes at huge profits (otherwise the taxes would not be hurting them). #2 they can support building enough housing so that prices aren't jumping so unafforably. #3 They could have set the maximum increase at 5%, or CPI + 2%, or really anything other than 2% which is clearly a hugely bad policy. Prop 13 is simply a way for people who got in early to prevent anybody else from enjoying California.
- prostoalex 11y agoMost people who buy their homes for long-term buy it to settle in their neighborhoods and have kids go to the same school, not speculate on price increases and profit from them. Leave alone the fact that when markets are over-heated, those huge profits can only be locked into huge base prices for any other property that's selling in this peak market. Unless the step 2 after hitting those huge profits involves packing up and moving to MidWest.
- epistasis 11y ago>Most people who buy their homes for long-term buy it to settle in their neighborhoods and have kids go to the same school, not speculate on price increases and profit from them. IF this is the true purpose of Proposition 13, then it would be written far differently. (Greater than 2%, no commercial real estate included, no passing on to children). People are also allowed to sell their home for more than the assessed tax value, precisely because people speculate on price increases of their homes. If that wasn't one of the primary reasons behind Proposition 13 then people would have been OK with only being able to sell their home at the assessed value. Really though the point of Proposition 13 was to just pay less taxes, "staying in your home" doesn't really come into play. Defending it along those lines is deceptive, and propagates a false narrative.
- prostoalex 11y agoConsidering California has a pretty robust real estate market with properties changing hands often, therefore resetting the price for Prop 13 purposes, how much actual revenue is lost? The biggest beneficiary of Prop 13 would be someone who bought his home in 1970s and never sold it since then. Does that describe a lot of the neighbors?
- _delirium 11y agoIn commercial real estate, it's become standard practice in California to never allow properties to legally change hands, in order to avoid the Prop-13 reset. Instead, commercial property is owned by holding companies, and ownership of the holding companies is bought and sold, but the property itself doesn't undergo an official real-estate sale.
- throwaway6497 11y agoIt doesn't make sense to allow commercial real-estate companies to take advantage of prop-13. I thought, the whole point of Prop-13 was to ensure that old folks don't get thrown out their homes.
- epicureanideal 11y agoTheoretically it could also be a 75 year old man in his 55 year old corner grocery store. Just playing devil's advocate here. I agree with you.
- maxerickson 11y agoIs this process well documented? This is like leaving the front door off the law, not like putting a back door into it, so I wonder if it is more of an internet rumor than an actual way to avoid change of ownership. Maybe people do it but it is fraud?
- _delirium 11y agoThere was at least one court case over it, in 2008, regarding Michael Dell buying a hotel in Santa Monica via a holding company, where he prevailed in court: http://www.santamonicadispatch.com/2013/05/prop-13-gives-edge-to-dell/ http://www.santamonicadispatch.com/2013/05/prop-13-gives-edg... It seems it's more complex than what I implied, though. The property needs to not only be owned by a holding company, but sales of the holding company have to be structured in such a way that overall ownership of the holding company isn't deemed to have changed. If the above article is correct, that's triggered when a new owner acquires a majority stake. So to avoid triggering a change in ownership in this case, Dell structured the sale so that he, his wife, and another business partner all bought interests in the company, split so that no single purchaser acquired more than 49%.
- bpodgursky 11y agoSan Jose budget: $3,190,187,604 Pop: 1,016,479 $3138/cap Dallas TX budget: $2,806,427,228 Pop: 1,281,047 $2190/cap Jacksonville FL budget: $2,166,068,795 Pop: 861,252 $2515/cap Closest cities I could find on wikipedia. San Jose gets plenty of money from its citizens. Like most of CA, it has fallen into a pension liability trap. Wringing more money out of people who have lived there for decades will only drag it on for a few more years until they have to stop making fully-funded pension promises they can not keep long-term.
- maxerickson 11y agoIn Holy Fire, Bruce Sterling had young people unable to get their hands on "old money" and thus frozen out of many interesting parts of the economy. I wonder if in reality we will have the reverse, where young people of the future refuse to live under bonds created in the past and old money just isn't worth anything.
- lsc 11y ago>I wonder if in reality we will have the reverse, where young people of the future refuse to live under bonds created in the past and old money just isn't worth anything. This is, in a nutshell, the basic populist argument in favor of inflation.
- epicureanideal 11y agoExcept inflation doesn't really help. If you own property, as I do, inflating money 2x just means my property goes up 2x in value.
- lsc 11y agowe were talking about bonds (or I guess annuities) in the previous message. Debt, essentially. If you owe money at a fixed interest rate, an increase in the rate of inflation helps you very directly, and hurts your creditors very directly, because you get to pay your debt back with cheaper dollars. If you really expect your real-estate to exactly follow the CPI, I expect you will be disappointed. (or maybe excited... for the last two decades, at least, real-estate has massively outpaced inflation.) Pensions, and really, most things are more complex, just 'cause there's usually something that attempts to compensate for inflation, but the point being that in general, inflation is good for debtors and bad for creditors. Most of the historical arguments in favor of inflation run along the lines of a partial repudiation of debt. Go read Bryan's "Cross of Gold" speech for an especially punchy example.
- pfarnsworth 11y agoThis is of course complete myth. First off, California property taxes are high already. Why is it that Vancouver, BC property taxes are 1/3 those of San Jose, with much higher property prices? And their schools are 100 times better, as are most services. It's government waste. From the deal with police officers in 2015: "The one-year pay agreement, tentatively reached earlier in the week, calls for 8 percent raises, plus a 5-percent, one-time "retention" bonus and return incentive for officers who have left the force for other jobs. The current police contract expires at the end of the year." 13 percent is pretty good for a city that is purportedly suffering from money problems for the last decade. Also, there are more than enough property sales in the last decade to equalize any "losses" from people who stayed in their houses, who are the far minority these days anyway. In my neighborhood, there is so much turnover and so many young couples moving in, it's crazy. And for those couples who have stayed in their house for a few decades, I'm glad they have prop 13 to protect them. There is no way that a retiree could afford to pay the $25k annual taxes that the rest of us do. They deserve to live in their houses until they deem fit to leave, not because they are priced out of the market.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- specialist 11y agoI'd be far more impressed by your analysis if you accounted for all forms of tax revenue (overall burden) balanced against societal expenses.
- lsc 11y ago>From the deal with police officers in 2015: "The one-year pay agreement, tentatively reached earlier in the week, calls for 8 percent raises, plus a 5-percent, one-time "retention" bonus and return incentive for officers who have left the force for other jobs. The current police contract expires at the end of the year." 13 percent is pretty good for a city that is purportedly suffering from money problems for the last decade. Just about everyone I know in the computer industry did better than that in terms of raises and bonuses last year. I think the labor market here might just be hot.
- 11y ago