10 ms·
Hacked Together 118 GB Floppy Disk
- AgentME 11y agoDrat, I was hoping it was like a cassette tape adapter and would work in unmodified disk drives. Do floppy disks advertise their own size, or do systems assume that they can only hold 1.44mb? You might need special driver support I guess, which takes some fun away.
- mintplant 11y agoI expected something like the 3.5mm-to-cassette adapters that exist for older cars with tape decks. http://www.amazon.com/Car-Cassette-Adapter-iPod-Sirius/dp/B000EU0880 http://www.amazon.com/Car-Cassette-Adapter-iPod-Sirius/dp/B0...
- kalleboo 11y agoOr SmartMedia flash cards that actually did work in a standard 3.5" floppy drive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SmartMedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SmartMedia edit: Didn't realize they even made MemoryStick and SD Card floppy adapters. So this already existed, sort of! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FlashPath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FlashPath
- digi_owl 11y agoYou can also get drives that can connect to a motherboard floppy port, and take SD cards. http://www.floppyemulator.com/ http://www.floppyemulator.com/ Note that i think you need to use special files that are read by the drive. I think they are meant as a life extension for older CNC machines and industrial looms.
- esaym 11y agoMan total flashback. I didn't even remember those existed, though I think I might have had one now that I think about it...
- Sanddancer 11y agoThey advertise their size. Back in the day, there were programs that let you reformat disks with tweaked parameters -- sectors per track, interleaving, etc -- so you could get a greater capacity. Windows 95 was shipped on a disk formatted for 1680k, for example [1]. Off the shelf disks were hit or miss as far as how big you could reformat them to, with some able to handle close to two megs, and others not able to handle much more than 1.44mb. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distribution_Media_Format https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distribution_Media_Format
- ars 11y ago> They advertise their size. Everything is under the control of the drive, not the media. They advertise their size as in: tell the drive what to expect. But the drive is in full control of where to write on the disk, and how densely.
- derefr 11y agoSort of yes, sort of no. Later drives were just black boxes with their own on-board logic that read metadata off the disk, sure. Early drives, though (of the 5.25" variety) relied on the first track of the disk to contain what was basically the disk controller firmware†. As such, you could actually teach an old drive new tricks by coming up with a firmware that used a better encoding scheme, and then encoding the rest of your disk with that scheme. † (though it ran on the CPU, rather than some microcontroller in the drive. "DOS" stands for Disk Operating System for a reason: a large part of it is a set of routines programs can call to make the CPU micromanage the read-head and stepping motor of the dumb disk-drive controller, with concepts like "files" being a mostly-optional thin wrapper above that, rather than some impenetrable abstraction layer.)
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"and others not able to handle much more than 1.44mb" My first experience installing Linux was using a bunch of disks which were unable to handle even 1.44MB (even though they were sold as 2HD). I couldn't tell, of course, and I had no idea why my install kept on failing or generating errors part way through the installation process :(
- ars 11y ago> Do floppy disks advertise their own size, or do systems assume that they can only hold 1.44mb? The second. With a better read/write head you could store more data on them (for example 2.88mb was available). But the physical media of the disk may or may not have the necessary resolution.
- huuu 11y agoWe used to drill holes in a 720K floppy so it would advertise itself as a 1.44MB drive. But in the end it's all about the density of the disk so I'm not sure if you could use a driver to store more data. Also you will need very accurate positioning of the head. So the drive is also a limiting factor. I think the largest floppies where 32MB.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> Drat, I was hoping it was like a cassette tape adapter and would work in unmodified disk drives. Oh, that exists! From 1998: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FlashPath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FlashPath A floppy disk drive-compatible SD card adapter. Needs special software, though.
- dcw303 11y agoIf he could get the drive eject button to unmount the SD card, this would actually be more functional that current tech. It bugs me that unmounting SD cards / USB drives and physically removing it are two seperate actions. It's a regression in usability after floppies and CD-ROMs.
- GigabyteCoin 11y agoWhat a great point. I am so paranoid now about removing USB drives after I accidentally removed one while it was still writing to the drive (which I had no idea because there was no LED on the drive) and it bricked the entire device. I generally wait until my computer has shutdown completely now before removing any important drives, just to be sure.
- ossreality 11y agolol, push eject, wait a few seconds for the notification, remove device. oh right, you're probably using windows.
- derefr 11y agoGenerally if I'm worried about completing a write, I'll just open a Terminal and type `sync` (with a `&& sudo purge` on OSX), and then, as soon as that returns, yank the drive. I don't even bother to unmount it; what would unmounting add, if the OS can recognize that the device is gone and clean up its mount tables? Is there some filesystem that waits until unmount to recalculate indexes or something? (Okay, sure, the OS could tell me the disk is in use because I've got an overlay filesystem mounted on top of it, and would I kindly wait forever for that to stop being the case. But screw you, OS, I need this USB. Just send the FUSE server or SMB daemon or whatever a SIGPIPE.)
- andrewaylett 11y agoFilesystems often have a 'dirty' flag which is cleared as the very last write when unmounting cleanly, to let the OS know whether the filesystem might need to be checked before mounting it next time. Also, unmounting helps you to be confident that nothing's started doing more IO since you ran sync.
- bradley_long 11y agoAlthough this is not a useful "innovation", I had fun while watching it.
- esaym 11y agoAh, disappointing. I was expecting some giant array of them all running in unison and making beautiful "music". Sorta like the radiohead hardware hobbyist video https://youtu.be/pmfHHLfbjNQ https://youtu.be/pmfHHLfbjNQ
- sdoering 11y agoWhy is it disappointing content, when only your subjective expectations were not met? What is it that makes this the OC's fault? Or am I not getting something here?
- jholman 11y agoWhat would you expect the word "disappointing" to mean, other than that the speaker was disappointed, i.e. that their expectations, which are necessarily subjective, were not met? That's the exact thing the word means! What is it about GP's comment that makes you think they assign blame?
- sdoering 11y agoWell OK, in Germany, telling others, that something was disappointing is most of the times not only a subjective statement, but also a negative rating/non-recommendation. So if you wanna say, that things were not what one expected, one must say so explicitly, to make it clear, that this is not generalizable. Maybe that does make it more clear?
- endgame 11y agoWell, it's only 4MB, but will this help? http://mac-guild.org/raid.html http://mac-guild.org/raid.html
- OneOneOneOne 11y agoThat would be about 80E3 floppys. Assuming a transfer rate of 500kbyte/second the peak data rate for the array would be 40E9 byte/second!
- sdoering 11y agoDamn. It would have never occurred to me, to hack something like this together. I really love it when someone comes up with creative ideas to reuse old stuff and mixing in some new things as well.
- anewhnaccount 11y agoCute. Does anyone remember the superfloppies of the late 90s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Floppy_disk_variants#Superfloppy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Floppy_disk_variants#Superflop... ?
- sweetbacon 11y agoI remember stacks of zip disks as my backup mechanism <shudder>.
- brodie78382 11y agoI used to have a LS120 SuperDisk drive in my computer. I really liked the idea but it was useless because no one else had them. I think I still have the drive and several disks stashed away somewhere.
- voidz 11y agoHey, I'm the other guy who had one, pleased to meet you after all those years! cackles
- digi_owl 11y agoYou also had Sony's Minidisc that in the end could store 1GB in a physical format very similar to a floppy. This was magnet-optical based though, thus it involved having a laser heating the media before the magnetic arm could flip the bit.
- agumonkey 11y agoThe 1GB was later or implied compression IIUC. First models, in the floppy disk era, were 300-400MB. Still would have been a beautiful computer storage device, but Sony sonied.
- digi_owl 11y agoTrue, they called it HiMD. The drives could also up-format the older MD disks to get a bit more storage. That said, i think there was a version of the original MD format sold as a data drive in Japan. I think Sony had a model or two of their Vaio laptops with it built in. That said, what basically sunk the format was slow write speed and that the Sony Music tail was basically wagging the Sony Electronics dog. The MD was from day one laden with DRM, and the HiMD took it even further (want to put those MP3s on there? Had to format convert to Atrac via some crazy program. And the only way to get them back out was via the analog hole). This just at the time as large capacity flash was coming to market, and you could dump any random MP3 onto them with a drag and drop operation.
- alblue 11y agoAlthough this is a fun idea, it's just putting an SD card into a 3.5" floppy disk case and then wiring up the read/write head with contacts to make it appear like an insertion of a normal mass storage SD card. A more accurate title would be "putting an SD card in a floppy disk case"
- digi_owl 11y agoMakes me ponder a 3.5" SD reader with a eject button though.
- delinka 11y agoOr maybe a 3.5" SD card filled with SD technology ... I wonder how much storage that would be.
- digi_owl 11y agoOn that note, while idly looking into SD readers for the 3.5" bay, i came across one that could dock a 2.5" SATA drive. http://www.akasa.co.uk/update.php?tpl=product/product.detail.tpl&no=181&type=Card%20Reader/Hub&type_sub=Card%20Reader&model=AK-ICR-10 http://www.akasa.co.uk/update.php?tpl=product/product.detail...
- pmarin 11y agoSprite TM did the same thing several years ago: http://spritesmods.com/?art=macsearm&page=3 http://spritesmods.com/?art=macsearm&page=3 https://youtu.be/9pJHqaF23B8 https://youtu.be/9pJHqaF23B8
- agumonkey 11y agoWould love to see a whole lot more of repurposed, upgraded old tech. VHS, audio tapes, you name it. My latest thrill is the pico8 project. Low res, 8bit games but with the extra compute power of today, it yields funny results.
- pvdebbe 11y agoI would like to see the 3.5" floppy do a comeback, for instance as a 1TB+ flash drive. It is large enough that you can comfortably handle it physically and label it, maybe it could be a small throwback to the age of floppies and zip drives.
- ant6n 11y agoAnd nowadays the write back buffer could be on the device itself, and as you hit the 'eject' button it could use the power from a small capacitor to commit it to the disk. Thus no separate 'eject' in the operating system - pop it out and go. They could replace Blu Ray with this new format, so all those sci-movies in the 80ies where there are films on floppys - those will turn out to be right.
- Namrog84 11y agoAs cool as that'd be and my first thought as well. Then I realized the fat that most all laptops and tablets out there that Re too thin to ever handle something like that makes me think it's less likely to happen.
- Crespyl 11y agoAt that size you could even get fancy and throw in an e-ink re-writable label, which could be used for anything from archive manifests to album art. No need for power on the disk, since that can be provided by the drive during write. I love that we can fit tens of GB in a space the size of a fingernail, but it does get rather fiddly to pass around. USB thumbdrives are nice, but are thick enough that they don't really stack up well, or fit into folders and binders nicely. The 3.5" form factor really is kind of a sweet spot for more than just nostalgia, IMO.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rodiger 11y agowhere/when can I buy this
- lawpoop 11y agohttp://www.ebay.com/itm/FLASHPATH-ADAPTER-FLOPPY-DISK-ADAPTER-FOR-SMARTMEDIA-NOS-NIB-/201380015519?hash=item2ee32f2d9f:g:apsAAOSw-vlVkfax http://www.ebay.com/itm/FLASHPATH-ADAPTER-FLOPPY-DISK-ADAPTE...
- addled 11y agoI was struck by a talk by Kirk Knoernschild in 2013 where he pointed out that there is now a generation of users who don't know what a floppy disk is... Yet it is still the "save" icon in nearly every application.