9 ms·
'Flash Boys' Exchange Isn't About the Little Guy
- theseatoms 11y agoOf course not. The pre-existing, traditional exchanges are about the little guy. A retail investor can now buy or sell a stock with unprecedentedly low execution slippage. The current HFT-driven market penalizes haphazard execution of much larger orders.
- jonknee 11y ago> The current HFT-driven market penalizes haphazard execution of much larger orders. Many of which are made on the behalf of the little guy (through pension or mutual funds).
- tptacek 11y agoThe largest and most reputable of which funds publicly support HFT driven trading/execution/market-making. I guess it depends on how much you trust Vanguard. I trust them a lot.
- patio11 11y agoThomas brings this up a lot in these threads; I appoint myself the designated copy/paster of the URL: https://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-02-10/s70210-122.pdf https://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-02-10/s70210-122.pdf Choice quotes: As the number of trading venues increases, discrepancies in prices across those venues will naturally result. The price discrepancies across multiple markets create an opportunity for nimble traders to make a small arbitrage profit by scouring the markets for these discrepancies and eliminating them. As the number of trading venues expands, the number of such arbitrage opportunities increases. So, it is not surprising that we have seen a tremendous increase in trading volume over the past decade, and that the activity is increasingly dominated by "high frequency traders." While Vanguard does not engage in this type of trading, we recognize that such trading has a positive impact on the markets at large, including longer term investors. Such arbitrage trading enables investors to get a fair price across market centers. Vanguard believes that the market structure changes facilitated by the Commission's various regulatory initiatives and the "knitting" together of the marketplace by "high frequency trading," have led to a significant decline in transaction costs for long-term investors over the past ten years through increased liquidity and tighter bid-ask spreads. and Various groups have attempted to quantify the reduction in transaction costs over the last ten to fifteen years. The Commission will continue to receive this data throughout the comment period. While the data universally demonstrate a significant reduction in transaction costs over the last ten to fifteen years, the precise percentages vary (estimates have ranged from a reduction of 35% to more than 60%). Vanguard estimates are in this range, and we conservatively estimate that transaction costs have declined 50 bps, or 100 bps round trip. This reduction in transaction costs provides a substantial benefit to investors in the form of higher net returns.
- theseatoms 11y agoThanks. I was going to ask for a citation. Vanguard is 100% correct, though there should probably be fewer exchanges in the first place.
- tptacek 11y agoThere should be fewer exchanges and less competition? Why?
- kasey_junk 11y agoYesterday Levine posited that less fragmentation of exchanges makes more economic sense: http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2016-02-24/oil-loans-and-cohen-cubs http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2016-02-24/oil-loans-a... I found it odd given what we saw in the US exchanges was the opposite of that before fragmentation, but the argument is that the network effects of large exchanges reduces the overall costs.
- theseatoms 11y agoOn exactly what front are exchanges competing? Order types? Fees? Volume? Differences in any of these are very often opaque to the customer. From what I've seen, exchanges are basically functionally equivalent, since they provide a utility-like service. And, as Vanguard points out, more trading venues means higher market frictions and costs. TBH I'm still trying to forming a strong opinion on the issue, as indicated by "probably" in my initial comment. And I think it's a topic worth discussing.
- gnaritas 11y agoIt doesn't matter if it's opaque to the customer or if every exchange is selling an identical product; there's reason for multiple exchanges to exist to avoid monopoly. Multiple players want to play in the market, that means multiple exchanges. Saying there should only be one exchange is picking a winner and giving them the entire market.
- 11y ago
- chuckcode 11y agoTitle is a little misleading. The article is seeking to refute a letter from Citadel opposing the establishment of IEX ('Flash Boys' exchange) on the grounds that it is not as efficient for the smaller retail investor. Article explains how 1) many of the retirement funds and institutional investors do actually represent the little guy 2) why exchanges that encourage HFT are costing all of us with retirement funds lots of extra dollars. I for one would like to see traders compete something other than speed and hope to see the IEX up and approved as an exchange sooner rather than later.
- gnaritas 11y agoTraders have always competed on speed and "will always" compete on speed, you can't stop this, it's not possible, nor is it bad. So why exactly are you against competing on speed? > why exchanges that encourage HFT are costing all of us with retirement funds lots of extra dollars. Why do you believe this, HFT lowers the spread making entering the market cheaper for those guys.
- chuckcode 11y agoBoth the article and the original "flash boys" book make a compelling case about how HFT can in some cases be used to virtually front run orders. I personally don't understand the system enough to prove or disprove those claims. I do think that an exchange that places less of a premium on speed like the IEX is a reasonable way to let the market itself evaluate the benefits of HFT. If the exchanges with HFT do provide a better value in terms of liquidity or price then the IEX will suffer as it provides an inferior product. If IEX flourishes then it is providing some value to investors. Let investors vote with their dollars
- tptacek 11y agoNeither the article nor Flash Boys makes that case. The article doesn't make that case because Levine is semi-famous for repeatedly calling Flash Boys into question, particularly with regards to the book's claim that HFT allows "front-running". Flash Boys doesn't make that case because it's an incoherent mish-mash of different arguments that don't add up to a definition of "virtual front running", let alone an argument that it's happening.
- data_spy 11y agoAnyone think we will get something that is happening in AdTech? There are several ad exchanges and there is 'header bidding' technology which let's you hit all the exchanges at once for the bets price. Anyone know if this is already occurring in stock exchanges?
- jstanley 11y agoYes, of course. Exploiting price differences between exchanges is arbitrage. It's very easy to take advantage of (if nobody else is doing so) so is done early on in any market.
- smoorman1024 11y agoSounds like you are describing the NBBO (National Best Bid and Offer) which literally requires everyone to execute at the best price (or better) to buy or sell in the market. If you send an order to an exchange (say NYSE) and they don't have the Best Bid then they will route your order to the other exchanges (NASDAQ/BATS/etc). Is this what you are getting at?
- pgwhalen 11y agoThis is what everyone in capital markets execution has been doing for over a decade actually.
- kolbe 11y agoAs a side note, if you are an outsider who is at all interested in finance and are a well-educated person, Matt Levine (the writer of this article) is one of the finest sources of information. His articles are accessible, thorough and well thought out.
- thatsaid 11y agoThis is usually true; but in this case he's parroting a data "analysis" that excluded 99+% of IEX's orders. Essentially, in < 1% of types of trades, IEX underperforms, in the rest it outperforms. However, the IEX opponents decided to pretend that this minuscule fraction of trades was important, and Matt Levine was either careless in believing this; or he purposefully wrote a dishonest and misleading article. I won't state which it is, but he's a smart guy... it's hard to believe that he'd make such an egregious error by accident.
- thekingofspain 11y agoCan you expand on this more? I'm looking to learn about finance, but it all seems so... overly complicated. It's hard to digest information when the simple stuff is hidden behind tons of terminology. I will definitely look more into Matt Levine. Any other recommendations for how to learn more about finance in general?
- aristidb 11y agoHe's probably the only journalist who can make the topic of bond market liquidity _funny_. slight hyperbole
- randomname2 11y agoUSA Today did a profile today as well: http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2016/02/25/why-wall-street-hates-man/79518728/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2016/02/25/why-wall-stre... Interestingly IEX's application has attracted 388 comment letters, with 99% supportive and Citadel's one of the handful against: http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4709.html http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4709.html For contrast, the BATS application received 3 comments only.
- smoorman1024 11y agoThat must be related to the publicity of "Flash Boys" and the fact that some entities are rallying the public to send comment letters. BATS when it became an exchange was nothing but a vanilla competitor marketed as a Better Automated Trading System. It didn't have anything like a speed bump.
- elecengin 11y agoA bit disingenuous - the handful against include major exchanges like NYSE and BATS as well as major trading firms like Citadel. You could argue that these are direct competitors of IEX and therefore have a vested interest in preventing the new exchange - or you could argue they are best suited to see the holes in the application. Keep in mind that previous exchange applications have went through without this level of discussion. You could argue that this is because the other exchanges are "scared" of IEX. Or... consider the possibility that IEX's application has some faults. For example, much of the focus has been on IEX's smart order router not following the same rules as all the other exchange participants. The argument is too nuanced to summarize here... but you should never decide an argument based on number of responses!
- cpwright 11y agoI think Matt Levine points out that most of the comment letters from individual investors should not be taken with much weight.
- ComteDeLaFere 11y agoI've started reading through the 388 comment letters to IEX's application, and this one in particular is basically a free lecture on the relevant issues by a professor at the University of Chicago - https://www.sec.gov/comments/10-222/10222-371.pdf https://www.sec.gov/comments/10-222/10222-371.pdf
- tptacek 11y agoThe author is a critic of continuous limit-order book markets for what seems to be a different reason: as the interval at which things trade constricts, correlations can break down between things that should be priced 1:1. His best example is ES and SPY, two different ways to trade the S&P500. There's a straightforward high-frequency arbitrage strategy to deploy against that problem: if ES or SPY is "mispriced", trade in offsetting amounts, in the expectation that the correlation will be restored (as it must eventually be). In Budish's view, this trading is a needless cost that doesn't improve price discovery. I'll just say, that's not IEX's argument against HFT.
- scottlocklin 11y agoI'm shocked; an actually good article about IEX which doesn't come from their marketing department.