4 ms·
We don't consider handing a letter to the USPS "giving over the information to a third party," so we have an example to apply to other supposedly third-party in
by nitrogen 11y ago
We don't consider handing a letter to the USPS "giving over the information to a third party," so we have an example to apply to other supposedly third-party information that is really first-party information temporarily handled by, but not intended for, a third party.
- ikeboy 11y agoThe USPS can't read the letter without breaking the seal. That's different from Tor, where the three parties can team up and exchange data, and they'll know who visited what, without breaking any seal. If the mail is unsealed, they're allowed to open it. See https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/39/233.3 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/39/233.3
- nitrogen 11y agoI can very easily call any of the layers in a secure connection a "seal". Besides, it's an analogy to demonstrate that there are things that are considered private while in a third party's control, not a literal point-for-point template for how to design privacy law for the Internet. The third-party doctrine does not match any non-lawyer's expectations, and it's the doctrine that needs to change, not just people's expectations.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoThey can read the mail through the seal using the shirt off tech used by archaeologists to read rolled up scrolls. Surely the point is when sealed there user expects privacy just as seven using Tor a used expects privacy - in both cases there is a system in place to protect the content from being simply read. That the technical solution used can be overcome doesn't change the users expectation that the 'seal' will mean the content is carried without being read.
- ikeboy 11y agoThe fact that all relays working together can determine the information means that the user gave up the info. If the US were to operate all three relays, would you still consider collecting that data to be illegal?
- nitrogen 11y ago"Consider...illegal" sounds like a trap. It should be illegal, and is definitely wrong.
- ikeboy 11y agoShould it be illegal for a private person to do so? If it's legal to run a single relay, what changes when you spin up more?
- nitrogen 11y agoYes, it should. It's illegal for a private person to steal unencrypted cable, it's illegal for a private person to spin up a bunch of servers to siphon information from a corporation's computers, it's illegal for a private person to tap into someone else's unencrypted phone calls, etc.
- ikeboy 11y agoAll of those are illegal under the CFAA, because they accessed a computer without authorization. In this case, every use of a computer was authorized. If someone's calling up random numbers and talking into them, my predicting which number they'll call and buying it, then listening to it doesn't violate any laws (although you can argue it should).
- nitrogen 11y agoThe CFAA has nothing to do with stealing cable or tapping phones, both of which existed (and were almost certainly illegal) before the CFAA and before digital cable or digital phone systems. Regarding buying random phone numbers, I'd say again, analogies are only useful to demonstrate the existence of an area of law in which something is legal or illegal, but not useful for designing in detail the laws governing digital/networked activities. There's not a sufficient parallel to make any decisions based on any analogy to a previous situation or technology; there's only enough parallel to prevent closing off the discussion of making privacy violations illegal by saying "it's not".
- pthreads 11y agoActually when you give USPS a letter you are giving the recipient's address, and optionally yours, by writing it in plain text on top of the envelope. The same argument could be made about IP addresses. By connecting to a Tor node you are willingly giving your IP address.
- newman314 11y agoThere is evidence that the USPS has been logging all that metadata. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/04/us/monitoring-of-snail-mail.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/04/us/monitoring-of-snail-mai... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_Isolation_Control_and_Tracking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_Isolation_Control_and_Tra... I'm not saying that it's right but it apparently is happening.