17 ms·
You hear a voice in your head when you're reading, right?
- DanBC 11y ago> But as this is the first ever investigation into the question, and it used an unconventional methodology, it's fair to say the results are far from conclusive. See also the Independent article here: http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/most-people-hear-voices-when-they-read-normal-psychological-study-finds-a6890766.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/... As I understand it (and I could be wrong) "hearing a voice" pretty much means you hear a voice as if someone was speaking but there's noone there. The paper talked about claimed that 80% of people "hear a voice" when they read. I find that surprising, and I'd want to know what exactly is meant by "inner reading voices" - are these voices that people hear, or are they something else? > Why hasn't this topic been studied before? Vilhauer's study hints at an answer because she found that many people assumed that their inner experiences when reading were shared by everyone. This worked both ways, so some of the people who had an inner reading voice were convinced of its normality: "We all hear our voices in our heads at times – even those of others we know – especially while reading," said one Yahoo contributor. Yet others who claimed to have no inner voice felt they were the normal ones. For example, in response to a question posted on the site about whether anyone else hears an inner voice while reading, one responder said "Nooo. You should get that checked out" and another wrote, in capitals: "NO, I'M NOT A FREAK". The other reason is that until relatively recently everyone freaked the fuck out if you said you heard voices, and hearing voices was a sign of serious severe mental illness. We now know that's probably not true.
- zzalpha 11y agoI hear a voice in my head both when I read and when I write. AFAIK it's such a common experience that everyone (myself included) just assumed everyone else did... Until they discovered someone who didn't share that experience.
- pm215 11y agoFor me, when I say I "hear a voice" when I read, I mean that it's the same 'mental voice' as when I'm thinking, stream-of-consciousness stuff. It's definitely not like hearing an out-in-the-world audio thing, but reading to me is me saying the words in my head.
- Splognosticus 11y ago> I find that surprising, and I'd want to know what exactly is meant by "inner reading voices" - are these voices that people hear, or are they something else? I do this sometimes to shut out distractions. For me it's like remembering someone saying what you're reading.
- azeirah 11y agoCan you "hear" something in your head when you try remember a sentence someone said?
- DanBC 11y agoMe? I have my normal internal thoughts. I don't think I can hear it in their voice, no.
- jobigoud 11y agoI don't understand how it can be "the first ever investigation into the question" when the number one tip of basically every speed reading technique ever is to suppress that inner voice…
- schoen 11y agoI assume this is the same as subvocalization, right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subvocalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subvocalization Or is there a separate notion of hearing a voice over and apart from subvocalizing? (If I had to try to think about them as different concepts, I'd probably say that I never subvocalize, and usually don't hear a voice when reading quickly, but perhaps do hear a voice when reading slowly or focusing on individual words.)
- dragonwriter 11y agoAs your Wikipedia link discusses, the "internal voice" is a component of subvocalization, but subvocalization also includes other things that happen at the same time (involuntary muscle movements.) > If I had to try to think about them as different concepts, I'd probably say that I never subvocalize, and usually don't hear a voice when reading quickly, but perhaps do hear a voice when reading slowly or focusing on individual words. Since the involuntary muscle movements that are the other part of subvocalization are generally undetectable to the person doing the reading, what is your basis for saying that you never subvocalize, even though you do hear a voice when reading slowly?
- schoen 11y ago> Since the involuntary muscle movements that are the other part of subvocalization are generally undetectable to the person doing the reading, what is your basis for saying that you never subvocalize, even though you do hear a voice when reading slowly? I guess that's a totally unsubstantiated intuition. Can I test it effectively with an EMG?
- Semiapies 11y agoI never have. This may have something to do with why I can only appreciate poetry when read aloud.
- dibujante 11y agoI had this problem with Shakespeare, as well. No internal voice. He's very hard to read unless spoken aloud, probably because it lets you experiment with intonation and emphasis.
- hosh 11y agoThat's what I heard about JRR Tolkien's Silmarillion too. I tried reading it when I was younger, and when I tend to drop sound conversion when I read. It seemed impenetrable. Years later, when someone told me it was meant to be heard, not to be read, I gave that a try, reading it aloud in my head. It was a much different experience. Reading Silmarillion felt like reading a magical book of creation, where the speaking of the words themselves create the world.
- nikdaheratik 11y agoI agree. Particularly with the Sonnets where, once you get the sense of the expected rhythm of the words, and try to add how they would sound like spoken, they are much more enjoyable. The only experience I can think of that is similar would be sight-reading music before trying to play it.
- Terr_ 11y agoPerhaps we only perceive a "voice" when someone makes us direct our conscious mind towards analyzing, describing, or remembering the reading experience. I mean, consider reflex actions in response to pain: Plenty of people will (quite honestly) tell you that "it hurt, so I pulled my hand back" but the lower-level neurological evidence suggests we're fooling ourselves.
- rdancer 11y agoThe report (I don't even want to call it "research") is not quite scientific. However, I have a lot of faith in my fellow HN readers. What would be a good experiment to test your hypothesis?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tumbas 11y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Ejga4kJUts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Ejga4kJUts
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- falcolas 11y agoNot really. I do when writing/typing, but not when reading. I don't even really subvocalize, that I've ever been able to tell - I read too quickly to transform the words into sounds. I have a slightly above average reading speed (with average to above-average retention), mostly because I don't spend as time converting the words to sounds. Of course, this does mean that I don't always recognize words when said aloud that I've only seen in text before. Less of an issue as I grow older, but hearing some words vocalized was an interesting experience the first time (such as aileron or Qeynos (pronounced as kē-nōs, for those who never played Everquest))
- simonh 11y agoInteresting, I think I always subvocalise when reading and found it hard not to when I just tried. I just asked my wife and she says she never hears a voice or even music in her head like that and was a bit shocked when I said I could. When I was a teenager I took elocution lessons, read poetry and acted in plays. I would read through a piece imagining where I would pause, where to put emphasis, etc. So I know I subvocalised then, but don't know if I did before or if that's when I learned to do it. I know it takes me much longer to read a book than my brother or father or many of my friends. I can read a book once and remember small details from the story they have completely forgotten and sometimes they've read a book multiple times when I have far better recollection of it from a single much slower reading. I'm wondering if subvocalisation plays a part in that. Edit: another factor is that I remember words from their sound, not their spelling, so have always had difficulty with spelling. I can't visualise the word, and often need to actualy write a word out before I can figure out how to spell it. Just spelling out words letter by letter vocally is very hard for me.
- hosh 11y agoI've have experience with both reading with sound and not reading with sound. When I drop the sound when I read, it stays a stream of concepts, and I can read fast. On the other hand, it also drops pretty much all of the emotional nuances. I don't read much poetry, but I don't think it makes much sense to read it without a voice. I don't think I have tried typing without voicing things out, except maybe when I'm writing code. I don't read without vocalizing in my head much anymore. I found that without hearing that, my EQ in relation to communicating with a person drops. On the other hand, if I'm visualizing some systems interactions in my head, it's not going to be verbalized. Until maybe, I try to explain it to someone.
- dibujante 11y agoFunny that you bring up spelling. I have absolutely no subvocalisation when reading and have always been an impeccable speller. When I read, I have trouble with fiction because I can't imagine pauses, emphasis, or any other non-textual cues in dialogue. I read a lot of non-fiction.
- 11y ago
- anotheryou 11y agoI listen to podcasts at 2.7x speed. There is a funny jump, from the speed where you still vocalize to something faster. It feels like it's pumping it directly in to your brain :) 2.7 is the speed I can jump in any time, if I speed up incrementally I can easily go to 3.2 or something. (i use windows media player for the speed up, best real-time sound stretching I found)
- hosh 11y agoThat's interesting that speeding up your podcast would change your reading speed. It wasn't like that for me. I used to speed up the voice speed in my head when reading and occasionally drop them all together (so it's a stream of concepts, not voice). Then one day, I noticed that I would drop a lot of emotional nuances when I do, or misread/misinterpret emails and messages from other people. I started to try to slow things down, to even read it in the voice of the person sending the message (assuming I know them well enough to have heard their voice). My reading speed had dropped but it feels like I get a lot more out of what I read now.
- Sanddancer 11y agoI've found that any more than a mild speedup and I lose interest in a spoken word piece. The pauses, the emphasis on certain words, etc all help me put myself into the emotional shoes of the speaker. Without that anchor, my mind quickly wanders and the podcast just becomes a distracting presence.
- jessriedel 11y agoBy "sound stretching", do you you just mean increased audio speed, or something more complicated? I'm generally stuck at about 1.7x or 1.8x because I stop being able to make out the words even though I'm not having a problem processing them. It's hard for me to imagine 2.7x being remotely intelligible. (Can you do this for any sort of speech, or only speech where you can fill in half the words mentally?) I've been dying for a audio/video playback program that would speed up faster between pauses (breaths, breaks, etc.) while slowing down to ~1.6 speed for words. I don't even really know what search terms to use. Here's my SE question: http://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/27175/video-playback-that-smooths-speech-at-high-speeds http://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/27175/video-... Would love more info here.
- jerf 11y agoI do, and I don't. If you imagine there's some form of pipeline in your brain from sound to phonemes to words to concepts to comprehension, my reading probably comes in right at the "words" level. I "hear" the words like I hear them when real people are speaking them, but they do not really have "sounds" or "phonemes". When reading fiction, I may pick up accent if the author is spelling it out but I generally have no voice particularly in mind for a character. Not a "neutral" voice, it's really no voice whatsoever. Just words. For one thing, if a real voice was speaking at the speed I normally read, it would be virtually incomprehensible. I can't be simply "sounding out words" for that reason. I imagine people come in at different places in the pipeline and that probably explains the difference. There more phases of the pipeline than there are common words to try to explain our experience.
- dimfeld 11y agoMy inner voice is much the same. I never realized until reading this article that some people do have an "audible" component to theirs. Very interesting.
- normac 11y agoCount me in on this as well. It's very strange because it's not a voice, but in some sense there is sound--I can "hear" when there's a rhyme, for instance. I've heard it claimed that the reason some people think they dream in black and white is that there wasn't any color content at all (not even grayscale). They think back and can't remember any colors, and assume it must have been grayscale, because their waking consciousness can't imagine what it would be like to see something without color. Similarly, it's hard to imagine how you could hear words with no voice speaking them (at least it's hard for me) even though we're experiencing it right now!
- Sharlin 11y agoPeople's subjective experiences vary considerably. Yvain's 2009 Less Wrong article on the subject is very good: http://lesswrong.com/lw/dr/generalizing_from_one_example/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/dr/generalizing_from_one_example/
- seibelj 11y agoI hear a voice when I read, but what's amazing is that I hear a British voice when I read The Economist. TE uses various britishisms, but even in the parts that don't, I always hear some brit reading to me. It's partly why I like reading it so much.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 13of40 11y ago"For people who only ever heard the same internal reading voice, this was usually their own voice, but it was often different in some way from their speaking voice, for example in terms of pitch or emotional tone." I hear a voice when I read, and it's always the same one, but I don't think of it as my own voice. An interesting side effect of that is, even though I read posts from hundreds of people on the internet every week, they're all in the same voice, so I basically imagine all of you as, like, one person.
- fixermark 11y agoWhy is that person such a jerk all the time, right? What's their problem? ;) I have the "voice when I read" thing too; I've actually always thought of it as some kind of "true voice." I haven't perceived that it's changed since kindergarten (though, of course, change could be so slow that I don't notice it, since it's not like I have any external recordings to compare it against).
- 13of40 11y agoFunny about kindergarten: You just reminded me that when I was growing up, the voice would get mushy and garbled when I was reading cursive writing.
- saltvedt 11y agoIf you think this is interesting, definitely read "Generalizing From One Example" at Less Wrong [1]. Turns out that people have varying degrees of ability to mentally imagine things, where the range seems to be from "purely abstract" to "number of stripes on a tiger". Also; Feynman noted that people keep track of time in very different ways[2], either visual (imagining a clock) or symbolic (counting by talking to yourself inside your head). And that whole internal monologue thing? Turns out that some people report not having that... If anyone has more examples, please add them. This stuff is endlessly fascinating :) [1]http://lesswrong.com/lw/dr/generalizing_from_one_example/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/dr/generalizing_from_one_example/ [2]http://generallythinking.com/richard-feynman-on-thinking-processes-did-he-know-nothing-about-psychology-v/ http://generallythinking.com/richard-feynman-on-thinking-pro...
- xyzzyz 11y agoI lost the internal monologue during puberty. It was initially pretty scary when I noticed that -- it though I'm ceasing to exist, and in a few years the "me" will be gone from my shell, while everyone else around me will be none the wiser. Fortunately, it did not happen (yet). I think the way it happened was that as I read lots of books, I realized I need to stop processing consciously every word if I want to read faster. Additionally, I started to spend lots of time interacting with English language (which is not my native), and I was sometimes thinking in English before I stopped thinking in words altogether. I developed a speech impediment because of that: whenever I need to speak, I need to synchronize my mental state with the words coming from my mouth, which requires a little effort.
- shams93 11y agoYeah if I read aloud "in my head" my reading speed is like 50% of what it is if I don't do that. But for fiction and poetry its fun to "hear" the words in my head so for literature I definitely read differently than when I read for information or training.
- landtuna 11y agoI share your experience (lacking any inner voice), except when I'm staging words to be spoken (or written as a conversation). I'm a native English speaker, and I never remember having an inner voice. Until reading a page linked here, I had thought I had mental imagery, but it sounds like I don't have that as others do, either.
- bananaoomarang 11y agoI can read very quickly and not hear a voice, but usually I read slow enough that I can. The tone usually depends on what it is I'm reading (Hacker News sounds different to Harry Potter), but I think the actual voice is the same. I've never really thought about it before.
- mcculley 11y agoI generally don't hear a voice when I read and find that when I do intentionally, it slows me down. I've found that I often miss puns and other plays on the sounds of words in written text due to not sounding out the words.
- bchjam 11y agoSpeed reading techniques often try to break written word streams down into visual chunks and let the wetware do the rest. Unsurprisingly, results vary widely. Ironically though, this sounds a bit like a very high level description of segmentation as in computer vision
- dsmithatx 11y agoOk this is very strange. When I read I hear the same inner voice or steady stream of consciousness I hear all the time. It's my own voice. The article says some people find it scary or distracting? So when they have normal thoughts and are not reading does that mean they don't hear their own voice like me? Is it scary and distracting when just having normal thoughts and not reading? This is amazing if this hasn't really been discussed much and studied before. I'm really curious to hear other people's answers to this.
- finnh 11y agoThe majority of the time when I'm reading, I don't hear anything at all. So, you'll probably be unsurprised by my answer to your second question - I generally don't hear my voice (or any voice) when I'm thinking. That does happen sometime, but only when my task is particularly language-focused, like when I'm writing. When I'm writing _english_, that is. No voices, no language when coding.
- odonnellryan 11y agoThat's interesting, because I was wondering "what must it be like to not hear a voice when reading?" and until you said the bit about coding, I didn't know. Then I realized the same thing. I don't hear a voice when I'm coding or reading code. Odd.
- eidorb 11y agoAh-ha! This was a great insight for me. I can't not subvocalise when reading. But I too certainly don't subvocalise when reading code. Now I know what it's like.
- QuercusMax 11y agoYou just described my exact experience; when I'm reading or writing, or just thinking, I experience the words the same.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 11y agoThere could be a "feed forward" mechanism in language processing, which gets involved in reading also. That is to say, when you hear speech, perhaps that same "reading voice" is also there: perhaps the speech that you're hearing is synthesized into a voice, and those voices are compared, which reinforces whether or not you "heard it right", and perhaps this takes place in a loop which clarifies the speech.
- ProfFarnsworth 11y agoGood news, Everyone! I'm sending you all on a mission into your inner subconscious. While there, you can read the rest of this comment in my voice.
- other_herbert 11y agobravo good sir :) I need to go back and screen which of futurama episodes are ok-enough for a 9 year old...
- mutagen 11y agoI don't usually have an inner voice when I read. Now I do, thank you! Seriously though, I don't really have an inner voice, unless it is maybe something like this where I'm expressing myself and I read in my voice the thoughts I'm trying to express. I was just trying to image accents as I read and this comment sealed it that yes, I can hear accents and a separate voice when I read something.
- andywood 11y agoNormally, I read slower and experience an internal voice. It is different from hearing a voice with my ears. Not just quieter, but different in a way I can't put into words. Yet also similar. If I either speed up, or consciously suppress it, I can read without the internal voice, but comprehension goes way down. There's some comprehension, but it's pretty ineffective overall. If I'm in a relatively quiet place, I don't move my lips or tongue. If I'm in a very noisy place, moving my lips/tongue seems to help. I once knew someone who said she could not read at all without whispering the words to herself.
- mc808 11y agoIf I know who wrote a piece and they have a distinctive manner of speaking, I sometimes "hear" the text colored by their voice. In most cases I don't experience anything like that, but I suppose it's possible that I do and just read so much that it gets filtered out.
- king_phil 11y agoI hear a voice when I read, and I just need a few seconds of concentration to change it to another voice. I can choose voices that seem to fit the content in energy level, general way of speaking and accent and do that a lot. But they never speak to me when I am not reading. I realized just now that it is my brain reading me a story and I listen to the voice that reads it to me like a fascinated kid.
- king_phil 11y agoI hear a voice when I read, and I just need a few seconds of concentration to change it to another voice. I can choose voices that seem to fit the content in energy level, general way of speaking and accent and do that a lot. But they never speak to me when I am not reading. I realized just now that it is my brain reading me a story and I listen to the voice that reads it to me like a fascinated kid.
- Johnythree 11y agoFor me, reading definitely doesn't involve any internal dialog. My eyes scan the page and the information passes directly into my consciousness. I guess that I'm a very fluent reader, however I don't remember any intermediate "translation" steps when I was young. I think a good illustration of this internal dialog is learning a new language. At first you (verbally) translate each word in your head into your native language. But as you gain fluency, you begin to understand the new language directly. Many decades ago I learnt Morse Code, and the process was similar. At first I mentally (and painstakingly) translated each letter. Later I translated each word. But eventually the information just flowed into my head without any intermediate steps.
- bdcravens 11y agoWhen I read a comment on HN from a voice I know (DHH, patio11, Rob Walling, etc) I usually hear their voice as I read it. (in DHH's case, inserting a few extra obscenities for good measure)
- jbb555 11y agoWhat? No of course you don't "hear" the words. How could you? Reading is several times faster than speaking, and it's not like you look individually at every word and read them out, you see a larger area of text as a unit. This makes no sense. If you mentally read out every word you are doing it wrong!
- libeclipse 11y agoI get what you mean, but it's not as if you're reading it out. I'd say I read pretty fast: my eyes skim quickly across the page and I understand what is written there, but it's as if the voice in my head is reading it out to me at the same speed as I'm reading. It doesn't slow anything down.
- onion2k 11y agoIt doesn't slow anything down. That depends. Some readers do what is known as "subvocalization"[1], where they literally speak the words they're reading, but silently, actuating the muscles in their tongue and throat as if they were speaking aloud. If you're doing that then it does slow you down. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subvocalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subvocalization
- libeclipse 11y agoNope. It's solely in my head. I don't subvocalize.
- onli 11y agoHearing an inner voice is not speaking. It is all in the head, not using the mouth. It skips over parts of words and is faster than a normal speaking voice would be. > it's not like you look individually at every word and read them out, you see a larger area of text as a unit. Of course you do. It is impossible to predict what will be the next word just by looking at one, if you don't look at each one you don't read, you skim. Meaning you won't understand anything.
- libeclipse 11y agoFor me, the voice in my head is always there. My every thought manifests as a voice, both when I'm reading and when I'm not. The voice isn't mine and it's not the voice of anyone I know. It's just a voice, and is always the same. I can also imagine things in a decent amount of detail, but it's not always visual, it's as if the voice is describing the details to me. I thought that was normal.
- tomcam 11y agoNever hear a voice. It just goes directly to symbols/images in my head. Exception when learning something difficult, at which time I slow down to words.
- mirimir 11y agoThis can be learned. Basically you force yourself to scan the visible area, looking for structure. And then focus on the key areas. So reading becomes a very nonlinear process. TL;DR Speed reading :)
- hendekagon 11y agoWhen I read a fiction book I hear a general main narration voice, usually my own but it could be someone else if I know the author was American for example. Then I also hear accents for all the characters in the book, for example many of the characters in the book I'm reading atm are Scottish, and they all have Scottish accents and the women have women's voices while the men have men's. To those who do not hear an inner voice: I'm really struggling to imagine how the information gets in, how are you actually aware of the information ?
- taejo 11y agoDo you struggle to imagine that people born deaf can read at all?
- hendekagon 11y agono, I don't struggle to imagine that they can read, I struggle to imagine what it feels like to them
- lilcarlyung 11y agoI have an inner monologue when thinking and I hear an inner voice when reading (sometimes several if there are several characters in a text). The voices differ. When reading something from a friend I will hear their voice, my own when reading my own, and my brain will try to create a auditory context if its by an unknown author. For example, Hacker News covers a lot of news from Silicon Valley/San Francisco so reading the comments here I mostly hear an American voice with an Californian accent, mixed together with my own voice. My brain pairs this together with inner images. So if I read a book about exploding stars, for example, I will hear an inner voice narrating the topic while also seeing images of the things being explained. These voices and images are very weak compared to the real thing though. My inner voices lack clarity and my inner images have no color. Obviously this is not great for my reading speed. I did a test a while ago and according to that test my reading speed was compared to that of a 5th grader, with high memory retention of general concepts and average memory retention of specific details. I read for several hours every day. As for numbers, when doing maths in my head, I do it visually. I see the numbers as images. What is strange though, compared to other things I imagine, is that results to math problems manifest themselves as a gut feeling rather than as the logical result from a chain of continuous inner dialogues and imagery. If I try to calculate 5*5 I get a gut feeling to answer 25, often faster than I consciously understand how I arrived at the answer. Needless to so say I have a very strong imagination, sometimes so strong that I stop paying attention to the real world for a little while.
- normac 11y agoOn the off chance you haven't heard of him, you might want to check out Daniel Tammet [1]. He's a high-functioning savant who has number-related synesthesia, can do calculations by juxtaposing images as you describe, and he's cultivated these abilities to the point that he can perform incredible feats of calculation and memorization. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tammet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tammet
- fallous 11y agoIt depends on what I'm reading. Comments in a forum? I hear a voice in my head, with a certain character style based on either the text or if it's a known commenter. Most books, especially good fiction, I visualize to a high degree which is why I often want to avoid movie adaptations because they cannot match what I experienced while reading.
- Lennu 11y agoI find that this is happening most of all when I'm reading in a non native language. And when reading in native, the thought process is much faster and better that I don't get voices(:D) so much.
- sklogic 11y agoJust wonder how the voice-hearing people skim or fast-read. Does it sound like a fast-forward with a funny voice to them?
- jobigoud 11y agoMost speed reading techniques start by encouraging you to suppress the inner voice hearing and just consume the words visually. (Which is also why I don't understand why they are saying it's the first investigation in the subject matter).
- santaclaus 11y agoI'm curious what this means with regards to someone who is deaf? Language comprehension and the auditory system are decoupled, with obvious empirical evidence (people who can't hear can still read, write, and speak). What is a 'voice in your head' for a deaf person?
- DanBC 11y agoNot deafness, but there's a visual hallucination that affects people with deteriorating eyesight. It's called "Charles Bonnet Syndrome". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_release_hallucinations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_release_hallucinations You can hear about it here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b071fs79 http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b071fs79
- bhaak 11y agoHow does this inner voice compare to a real voice? Given that the scientists link that with auditory hallucinations, I'd expect that for at least some people it's indistinguishable from a real voice (one of the earliest known example would be Socrates' daimonion). I hear a voice usually when I'm reading but it is of some kind of soundless intensity. I think different characters in books have slightly different voices but it's possible that my brain knows that different characters should have different voices and it just tricks me in believing it. I only have an inner voice for my thoughts when I try to articulate something. Otherwise I only think in concepts, structures and visualisations. This is also how I tackle programming or solving problems in general. I visualize the problem and build a "problem structure" and then try to make it collapse into a simpler structure.
- wodenokoto 11y agoI think you answered your own question several times: > I hear a voice usually when I'm reading but it is of some kind of soundless intensity. and > I only have an inner voice for my thoughts when I try to articulate something. I'm sure just like some people see colours when they hear sounds, other people experience their inner voice as very, very real.
- rdancer 11y ago"One hundred and sixty posts from [Yahoo Answers] were analyzed using a qualitative content analysis approach" Cool tips on how 2 become a rsercher? The discussion here on HN is interesting, though.
- wodenokoto 11y agoI do not believe this has not been studied before. In psychology you talk about the inner monologue, in linguistic you have experiments measuring if silent reading activates muscles in the speech apparatus (as far as I remember, it does), speed reading is all about silencing the inner monologue. A quick search brought this up on Google Scholar: Auditory imagery, D Reisberg - 2014 - books.google.com "Psychologists have debated the role of inner speech in silent reading, and clinicians ...."
- Kenji 11y agoI think 'hear' is the wrong word. It has nothing to do with hearing. No hearing is involved at all, it is an auditory imagination and recollection. Like a good song that keeps playing in your head. And most people can clearly distinguish this kind of sensation from actual hearing, and they'd never mistake the auditory imaginations for actual things that are heard.
- agentgt 11y agoI have an inner dialogue as well. Not always but it's generally there especially when writing. The annoying thing is my inner dialogue is the same for writing and reading (Is this the same for others?). This is bad because my reading dialogue skips words and makes up pronunciations for words that are long or are just a pain to say. I imagine this evolved from the necessity to read faster. So when I write and even sometimes speak about complicated things I will skip words and maybe go lax on pronunciation (especially if its an emotional thing because well.. its hard for me to communicate emotions). The other annoying thing with inner dialogue is I often screw up homonyms. As seen in this recent comment with brake and break: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11159104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11159104 . Its exceedingly embarrassing for me when this happens. Even trivial mistakes like "to", "too", "two", "your" and "you're". This doesn't happen on serious writing but it does on the internet and I feel like an idiot when it happens (as I do know how to use the words correctly). EDIT: I just noticed I screwed up its and it's again.
- gkya 11y agoI guess you intended to say inner dialogue, and you didn't mistakenly use it instead of inner monologue. I couln't be sure because I've mostly seen inner monologue until now. I do have an inner dialogue too (I guess I've an inner Socrates which doesn't know to shut up for a second and to stop bothering me with stupid questions), I usually think in a dialectical manner. I haven't experienced your ortographic mistakes, or I haven't recognised yet that I do make them too. But sometimes I think of typing one word and I end up typing a completely different one: I want to type baboon and I end up typing, sth. like trumpet (made up example). This only happens with english though, so maybe it's because english is slowly becoming a sinaitic language with an iconographic ortography. That said I use my inner dialogue to study languages, and I've succeeded with English and Italian, my L2 and L3. I've perfect english reading writing skills, and in italian high reading skills and good listening comprehension (and I studied it for one and a half year, without native speakers to talk to except for scarce weekly lessons at the uni). What I do is I do my daily thinking in the target language. And if I have to speak in one of the languages (including my mother tongue, turkish), I have to do a context switch, which takes some seconds. If I had to switch from one language to another in the middle of the phrase, my pronunciation will be very very bad, with a very strong turkish accent, whereas if I were in context, I articulate way way better. One thing is, this method is hard to share, when someone asks me how I study languages, I have to talk about self immersion etc., because I don't want to make people think that I'm nuts.
- kalms 11y agoWhen I'm typing or reading english or any other foreign language I hear a voice — now that I think about it. Not in Danish though, which is my native tongue. This never occurred to me before; very strange indeed.
- DigitalJack 11y agoI thought it was common knowledge that some people do, some don't. I always thought the don't column was a learned skill... After all, unless your voice is one of the chipmunks, it's going to limit your reading speed. If you want to turn the voice off (off the text), you can try counting in your head as you read.
- gopalv 11y ago> I always thought the don't column was a learned skill Perhaps it is one of those things that happen only for your first language? Whenever I read English, I don't - I read through skipping syllables. But, I read/write two others, of which in Malayalam, I naturally read aloud in my head. Which is rather odd, because these days I dream in English too (odd way of saying it, but my fears speak English).
- rprospero 11y agoI just tried your counting trick and all I wound up with was two simultaneous voices going through my head. On the reverse side, for anyone who doesn't hear text as they read, I'm really curious how your mind handles the following paragraph. I can't imagine processing it in any way besides taking it one word at a time, but that is likely a limit of my own imagination. > During winter, and touring the humor, poignant observation to Hobbes, as if to created as an outside action—you can be found him for examples aliens typically The Family Circus, criticized him is the thing through Saturday, December 16, 1995. Mom's first appeared in some newspaper chapeaux during nature is the only babysitter are characters in another. Source: http://projects.haykranen.nl/markov/demo/ http://projects.haykranen.nl/markov/demo/
- rgejman 11y agoI don't hear a voice in my head when I read. When I try to read that paragraph, I can't get past the 4th word without an uncomfortable mental pause. In order to continue reading I do have to "hear" it as I'm reading it. How did you come up with this?
- 11y ago
- alex_duf 11y agoSo it's a study about what a 136 person described on a forum? hmm... Not sure we can jump on conclusion nor sure the population is big enough to user decimal points in the percentages.
- vitd 11y agoYeah, I was thinking that, too. And it's not just any forum, either. It's the notorious Yahoo Answers where people regularly troll each other as both question askers and answerers. See, for example: http://memebase.cheezburger.com/artoftrolling/tag/yahoo-answer-fails http://memebase.cheezburger.com/artoftrolling/tag/yahoo-answ...
- JabavuAdams 11y agoI hear my own voice. It's only ever my own voice -- it's not modified by the speaking character or the writer. I also feel my tongue forming the words even though nothing's moving.
- bitL 11y agoSometimes I hear, sometimes not, depends on how much fantasy I unleash or if I use voice "recordings" to prevent me from making mistakes in writing a text in a foreign language. And I practiced fast reading as a kid (e.g. 1 page in 2-5s), and that was for sure without any distinctive voice. Now this helps me to spot a line in code I need to change extremely quickly ;-) It's like with thinking - when you are a kid, you think in some proto-thoughts that aren't really based on a language (something like assembly language of mind) and the older you are and more languages you know, you tend to think in languages instead, except when you are in a creative flow when things just happen automagically.
- brightball 11y agoWhenever I read anything, it's as if I'm actually have a conversation. Every single word is spoken in my head with the real tone and intonation that I would expect if somebody were telling me a story in a coffee shop. I've always assumed that this is because I'm a very audible learner. When I'm paying attention to somebody who is talking, I tend to have a hard time focussing on anything else. For example, I'll miss turns driving if my wife is talking to me in the car unless I'm just actively ignoring her. As a result, she knows if we're following directions not to talk to me about anything because if I don't miss the turn, I wasn't listening to her. :-) The side effect of this is that I don't read particularly quickly. I can if I make myself but it's like the voice in my head becomes the Micro Machine guy. I read at about the speed I'd expect somebody to talk. I tend to write the same way. If it doesn't "sound right" I have to keep editing the sentence.
- fixermark 11y agoI have the same thing. If I try to over-read my head-voice speed, I can do it but it's exhausting and I don't retain the information nearly as well. I've also always been a pretty good speller; at some point, my brain started caching two copies of each word---how it sounds, and how it should sound based on how it's spelled.
- bobwaycott 11y ago> my brain started caching two copies of each word---how it sounds, and how it should sound based on how it's spelled. Oh, man. This happens to me all the time. Glad to hear I'm not alone.
- throwanem 11y agoOnly when I want to, which isn't often because it slows me down. Sometimes it's fun to listen to the dialogue, though.
- _archon_ 11y agoI wonder how this relates to how we learn our primary language in the first place. My parents put objects in front of me and gave me the word to associate with them, or talked around the meaning of abstract words. I learned English (my primary language) entirely verbally. Then, when I began to learn to read, I learned what sounds letters made, and verbalized these sounds when reading, and tried to parse those sounds into a word I recognized. Since I learned my language verbally, the process to comprehension included conversion to sound. This has continued to my adult life; I wonder if I can re-train my brain to associate text with meaning. I also wonder if I do this already, but every time I try to notice whether I'm internally verbalizing, I internally verbalize (because it's in the back of my mind), so I think I do regularly even though that may not be the case. Experimenting with this idea would likely require teaching children with text, which may or may not be ethical. Sign language is different enough from English that it doesn't directly relate.
- deeteecee 11y agoon a side note, i heard its suggested that you don't have the audible voice if you want to achieve faster speeds at reading comprehension :)
- RUG3Y 11y agoI don't hear a voice in my head. I read much faster than anyone can talk - I can't imagine what that would sound like.
- pmarreck 11y agoI also often see the words that are spoken by someone else. As a result, I have a high-level ability to spell and be grammatically-correct.
- hellbanner 11y agoNot if I read fast enough. Which can be done by looking at 1/3X of the Line N, then looking at 2/3X of the line, then recurring with Line N+1. This has >10x sped up my reading speed and improved comprehension as my brain takes in the whole picture (gestalt of the paragraph) more times total and more times per second. Try it!
- Burr1805 11y agoHas anyone found this affects memory? I 'see' thoughts but since words never completely describe an object, my brain seems to auto fill in the rest. And when asked later I can describe what I read along with what my brain auto filled in (and sometimes can't remember which I actually read and which my brain filled in). For instance I read about a tree, and I 'see' in my thoughts a pine tree. When asked later about the tree I might describe it as a pine even though that was never physically described.