6 ms·
Lot's of "nothing new" comments here, but I think that may be missing the point. Wall Street has been hiring physics & math graduates for a good while now, bu
by ska 11y ago
Lot's of "nothing new" comments here, but I think that may be missing the point.
Wall Street has been hiring physics & math graduates for a good while now, but typically as quants, not traders. Those were (are?) hugely different positions, in terms of responsibility and dollars realized.
Not my area, so I may just be missing something too. But when I had acquaintances going into this sort of things, they weren't getting anywhere near a trading desk. At least, not for a while.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- scott_s 11y agoAgreed - I've had colleagues (with PhDs) go to financial jobs, but they were not traders.
- kasey_junk 11y agoThe line between trader and quant in electronic trading scenarios is pretty vague and has been for some time.
- jorgecurio 11y agoOne gets you fired when you lose money and the other gets you a speaking opportunities at universities where kids are discovering Gordon Gekko.
- mrchicity 11y agoYou want it to be that way, but it's the other way. If you're just a "cog in the machine" doing research or writing software for a trader, and he ends up sucking, the firm will probably shuffle you around to work under someone else. You have generally useful technical skills, cost less than the trader, and recruiting good technical people is expensive. If you're a supposedly brilliant trader but cost the firm money taking stupid risk or fail to make any profit to justify your inflated salary and bonus, there's not really much they can do with you.
- lintiness 11y ago.... like john merriweather or victor niederhoffer for instance. two guys who've blown up the world multiple times but still manage to find capital and manage huge funds.
- ska 11y agoThat's plausible, my indirect experience is not current.
- whatok 11y ago> Wall Street has been hiring physics & math graduates for a good while now, but typically as quants, not traders Smart people have been hired as quantitative traders for decades, this really is nothing new.
- SCAQTony 11y agoIs it really a market then if wall Street is investing in the flow of money in and out of a position rather than the company itself?
- hueving 11y agoTraders != investors. It's never been a market maker's job to invest in companies.
- vostok 11y agoAre you saying that Wall Street should be taking larger proprietary positions? Not a criticism, just curious.
- SCAQTony 11y agoNo offense taken. Idealist me thinks that Wall Street should invest in those companies they believe in and wish to assist in achieving their business goals. As an exchange, the investor shares in the profits and enjoys the satisfaction that they directly and indirectly brought prosperity to themselves and others. If it is just about agnostic profit over assisting business expansion and creation than Wall Street is really is a casino than a market. I would never knowingly invest in a tobacco company or an arms maker. (I am long the S&P 500) Some might feel okay with it since they are smokers and appreciate a strong defense but who is okay with a computer crashing a market becasue it was profitable?
- vostok 11y agoI really appreciate your response. >Idealist me thinks that Wall Street should invest in those companies they believe in and wish to assist in achieving their business goals. It seems that the general trend is against banks taking proprietary positions. I guess my knee-jerk response is that I agree with that trend as I don't want my deposits used to fund someone's investment thesis. If I did, I would put my money in a mutual fund or other investment vehicle rather than a bank. At the same time, it's certainly not against the law for banks to make longer term investments. >but who is okay with a computer crashing a market becasue it was profitable I am certainly no fan of banks, but this does not seem like an accurate representation of their role in the markets.
- MathsOX 11y agoWell the line between traders and quants has always been blurry to the point of no differential at Jane Street, D.E Shaw, and Citadel since inception. Traders have always had quant background, but have focused on more execution-oriented analysis whereas quants are a bit more idea-oriented. Any sell-side investment bank still has clear lines between traders and quants. In fact, while they blurred more pre-2007 I'd argue they've become more clearly defined. Source: work at a prominent investment bank.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 11y agoWhen I graduated from NYU's mathematical finance program with a Master's, I thought I'd be a quant. I thought they make the big bucks. Nope, that was traders and they didn't even need a bachelor's degree sometimes. I never quite figured out how traders get into those positions where they make multi million dollar annual commissions, but I realized early on I like to create social web apps and left finance. I still always joked about the idea of myself and a friend becoming traders and trading opposite strategies, then splitting the bonus one of us is bound to get. Obviously we'd need to obfuscate that the expectations on our ambitious strategies would be roughly mirror images of each other -- one would get fired, the other may get a few million.
- tomp 11y agoHaha, it doesn't work that way, unfortunately. If you have any strategy that's statistically different to zero, you have a winning strategy; if it's loosing money, you can just trade the opposite strategy yourself! The problem is, that most strategies are zero, on average. You win some, lose some with your trades, but what eats your capital is the trading costs. Then even trading the opposite trade would still diminish your capital.
- EGreg 11y agoNo, you don't know whether it will win or lose ahead of time. You just trade opposite strategies in an ambitious way so you are GUARANTEED to have a large chance of winning a lot ... the arbitrage is that one trader gets fired and the other gets a large bonus for being right!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mathattack 11y agoI think what's happening is in ETFs, the quants are writing programs that trade, as opposed to slamming phones. In my stint in Wall Street I saw a general move in Fixed Income towards traders with CS/Math/Engineering degrees, sometimes paired with MBAs.
- yomly 11y agoWhilst I think this was inevitable, as banks have become increasingly technical, it also makes me a bit sad that now you need a Math PhD from MIT and a Harvard MBA to go and be a trader. I think back to an earlier HN discussion [1] on the article "The Rent Seeking is Too Damn High" [2] - when my father worked at a bank he said it wasn't uncommon for your market salesman from the street to get picked up as a trader, indeed my friends mother went from secretary to trader. She was given a chance because her boss felt like she had a spark about her. It's fun to look back on the past with rosy eyes thinking "those days were better" but truly how can we hope for meritocratic (in the true sense of the word!) social mobility if you need 0.5 million USD in school fees to get a job as a trader?
- gjm11 11y ago[1] http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-rent-seeking-is-too-damn-high/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-rent-seeking-is-too-... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11054527 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11054527 or possibly https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11041340 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11041340 (two days earlier, way fewer comments)
- yomly 11y agoThanks for that (forgot to get the sources as was posting on mobile!)
- mverwijs 11y agoI worked for Optiver (largest marketmaker in Europe) between 2007 and 2010. We hired grads for trader positions all the time. Optiver even sponsored the mathematic, physics and cs study association for students in Leiden for the longest time. Trying to win over students before they graduated. https://www.deleidscheflesch.nl/p/optiver https://www.deleidscheflesch.nl/p/optiver Competitors did this too. Really nothing new here.
- gadders 11y agoDepends what you're trading. Cash Equities - probably not needed. Fixed Income Options - probably needed.