4 ms·
Wouldn't that just be a weird corner case though? If the cars were frequently getting vandalized in shady neighborhoods, they probably wouldn't be frequently ro
by maxerickson 11y ago
Wouldn't that just be a weird corner case though? If the cars were frequently getting vandalized in shady neighborhoods, they probably wouldn't be frequently routed that way anymore.
- kevingadd 11y agoWhat about people who have no choice but to live in a shady neighborhood? In that case, the car really just needs to handle dangerous situations properly. The alternative is not being able to get a car ride in the self-driving-only future unless you live in a nice neighborhood, which is exciting...
- maxerickson 11y agoIf people in a neighborhood are using the cars, the nasty people planning on obstructing the vehicle to detain the passenger probably won't target the cars in that neighborhood.
- a3n 11y agoNot sure, but I've accreted the idea that it's against the law for a taxi company to not serve certain neighborhoods. That doesn't mean it doesn't happen.
- hodwik 11y agoFor some people who live near the ghetto, that's not really an option. If I'm coming from the South I either have to go through the ghetto, or add another 30 minutes to my ride to avoid it.
- crusso 11y agoIt's not a weird corner case for the female co-worker with whom I was discussing self-driving cars. I'm generally very optimistic about the positive impact SDCs will have upon society and I was surprised when my enthusiasm was met with her statement, "I will never own a self-driving car." Her main concern was safety. Regardless of "shady neighborhood" or just someone looking to hurt her in a better neighborhood - the concept of not having some kind of easy manual way to get out of danger made the SDC a non-starter concept for her. I have to admit that after that conversation with her, the helpless lack of control of the SDC has figured more highly in my thinking about the subject.
- clort 11y agoIts pretty sad that people really feel this way in the modern world (Note: not them, but that they feel this way). Not that you said you were living in a similar world to myself but I guess I can see that more vulnerable people might feel that way in some parts of the world. In defence of the world with self driving cars, I could say that - you could specify the route (not via the bad part of town please), just as you currently can - the passengers would not necessarily be on display so a vulnerable passenger is not as exposed - the self driving car does not necessarily need to allow the doors to be opened from outside - the self driving car could choose to value the passengers safety over third parties interfering with normal operation - the self driving car could log/stream a whole lot of data about any such third parties - the self driving car could summon assistance (police, or private security) - the owners of the self driving car would not be motivated to allow it to frequent areas known for issues which may cause damage - as the passenger of a self driving car with a weapon, you can focus on fighting off intruders while the car drives to safety and perhaps others.
- VLM 11y agoThat's quite a display of de-personing poor people. And I wouldn't worry about the car, but the people inside it.
- maxerickson 11y agoMy intent was to focus on frequent attacks on self driving cars being unlikely, sorry I didn't worry over the phrasing. (There's also the thing where I can think owners of self driving vehicles will do things to protect the vehicles without necessarily agreeing with or liking those things.) edit: and there's the thing where routing around danger would in fact protect the passengers along with the car.
- marcosdumay 11y agoThat's not a corner case in a big part of the world. But it's really easy to solve. The car just has to submit the route to you, for acceptance.