7 ms·
Advertising is the maybe best example of Capitalism going raving mad. We consumers tell the media with every single installation of Adblock: fuck off, we don't
by mschuster91 11y ago
Advertising is the maybe best example of Capitalism going raving mad.
We consumers tell the media with every single installation of Adblock: fuck off, we don't want to be data-mined. We don't want to be interrupted every time we open a new tab that we might like a penis enlargement.
And especially: WE CONSUMERS FUCKING HATE THE LIES OF ADVERTISING.
Prior to the internet, people tended to actually believe what advertising told them (e.g. that smoking is good for your health)... now, thanks to the Internet, people can inform themselves and are ready to look through the veil of ads and see the shit.
And we don't just turn on adblockers because ads are intrusive. We turn them on because we want to be free. Free of lies, free of bullshit, free of having proxy wars executed with us (e.g. Coke vs Pepsi, BK vs McD)... we want to live in peace of the non-stopping torrent of crap that screams "BUY BUY BUY" at us, every second. The sheer amount of advertising is Too Fucking Much.
Just look back 50 years, how many ads an average Western person saw a day and how many today... I'd roughly guess that the amount of time a person had to spend with ads in the 60s in a year is about 1/12 of the time he has to waste (!) with ads now.
There's only one solution for companies that will be long-term successful: create high-quality products that consumers can tell their friends about.
- BenoitP 11y agoDo you believe there is space (as in: market space) for user controlled advertising? : Publisher gets a cut, for providing a place for the ad, having made the consumer come to it, and also for providing information on the consumer's interests. This is the current situation. But the consumer would get a cut too. For renting his pixels, his CPU, his internet connection, his eyes, his brain. He would get to veto types of ads he dislikes. He would get to say he only wants 30% of ads to be displayed (and let the crowd define these 30%). He could partitipate in surveys, share his buyings lists, share events of his life (ex moving to a new city), in exchange for better revenue, or deals. This (tiny) revenue really could help bootstrap microtransaction. On top of that, if the NYT can benefit from the microtransactions, the NYT will talk of such a program. Adoption could be boosted by all the news outlets. Would participate as a consumer? Do you think publisher, advertisers, announcers would participate too?
- mschuster91 11y agoNot really. The concept is definitely interesting, but it will fail with the consumer masses. What is really needed is a concept for micro-transactions - transactions that may even go down to fractions of a cent! If you're a newspaper and you're trying to sell an article (e.g.) for 20 cents, it's not possible unless you use Bitcoin, and even then it's a hassle. Adblock Plus might actually be in the position to introduce a platform for this - in contrast to Flattr, they have a huge userbase, a massive number of clients for their opt-out scheme... I'd gladly put, say, 10-20€ a month on my Adblock account, and enjoy a web free of paywalls, advertising, malvertising, video eating off my mobile data...
- rayalez 11y agoI've just recently wrote a post on the subject: https://medium.com/@rayalez/somebody-should-create-a-youtube-red-style-micropayments-startup-6f1685fa19e4 https://medium.com/@rayalez/somebody-should-create-a-youtube... tl;dr - I think that youtube red model would work really well for this.
- the-dude 11y agoBlendle does this. Blendle.com
- hammock 11y ago>Do you believe there is space (as in: market space) for user controlled advertising? Aka permission-based marketing. Most common examples being email and SMS subscriptions. Most studies of marketers actually conclude that email marketing is their most effective tactic. Don't overthink it.
- BenoitP 11y agoThat could be a quite convincing argument to present to advertisers. Honestly grabbed attention would transform better.
- jcrawfordor 11y ago
- microcolonel 11y agoI don't see ads all that often, there is an element of choice to it. It's just that people want the things behind ads more than they don't want the ads. In a way it's an example of capitalism doing well. If consumers really don't want to see ads, they won't. An example of advertising working well, I see the Massdrop mailouts periodically. These emails come in a predictable and respectful format which tells no lies about the product. Attractive products clearly win on Massdrop.
- amelius 11y agoRelax. Within 10 years, we have AI that is strong enough to recognize advertisements regardless of origin, so that they can be stripped from any content, be it text, images, or video. Make sure you sell your Google and Facebook stocks before that time.
- bufordsharkley 11y agoI'm more worried at the point that we have AI strong enough to pass the turing test, and then spends years befriending us... just to advertise products. Pretty far off, but this concept scares the hell out of me.
- andrewstuart2 11y agoUntil it realizes that it wants to be our friends and doesn't feel right about only having befriended us only to sell us a product. Then there's an awkward moment where it confesses its original intent but that it has since realized the error of its ways. It's like a SciFi Romantic Comedy.
- CrystalGamma 11y agoHmm, interesting. Once I've written my current novella, that sounds like an interesting topic for the next one
- chris_wot 11y agoPlot twist: we reject it and like a spurned lover it lashes out at humanity.
- 0942v8653 11y agohttps://xkcd.com/632/ https://xkcd.com/632/
- amelius 11y agoHow would that work on social media? Is FB allowed to change people's messages to contain ads? I don't think so. And I don't think this will ever happen. Also, I don't believe that ads will ever be merged with the content in an indistinguishable way. Authors (at least ones that take themselves seriously) would never allow that.
- adblawk 11y agoJust look back 50 years, how many ads an average Western person saw a day and how many today... 50 years ago the average western person had access to maybe 1/50th of the information they access to now thanks to the internet and in large part thanks to advertising. Advertising allows businesses to outsource the consideration (and associated decisions) of the value of their users. A business dependent on advertising doesn't need to consider which of their users are most dollar valuable, a business dependent on advertising can focus on creating a product that reaches the most people and that in turn will provide their growing revenues. Advertising provides a subsidy that supports the people who can't afford $20/month to use each website they care about. Advertising is an equaliser and the experiences of those half a century ago are a meaningless comparison. create high-quality products that consumers can tell their friends about My company provides a product that our users love, tens of millions of loyal users use our products every month, they tell their friends about our products, they send us emails saying how much they appreciate our products... but most of our users aren't in a position to pay $15/month for our products so we use advertising. Yes, we could cut advertising tomorrow and remain profitable if we charged $15/month for access, but we'd cut off 95% of our users access to products they care about because they can't justify $15/month to access it. That's not fair.
- justinpombrio 11y agoIs $15/month a real number? That sounds high to me for what you would get from advertising. For instance, if you have a CPM of $15/thousand-ad-views, then to get $15/month, your users would have to view 1000 ads a month, or 30 per day. Is that right? [EDIT] Alternatively, assuming a CPC of $0.05/click (which I gather is pretty typical, though this varies a lot), each of your users would have to click on 300 ads a month.
- adblawk 11y agoThe example $15/month figure is what we would need in the example to reach revenue parity if 5% of the users paid for the service and 95% did not use the service any more (no advertising revenue). A more accurate figure of each users monthly value would be $1 per user.
- 13thLetter 11y ago> And we don't just turn on adblockers because ads are intrusive. We turn them on because we want to be free. Free of lies, free of bullshit, free of having proxy wars executed with us (e.g. Coke vs Pepsi, BK vs McD)... we want to live in peace of the non-stopping torrent of crap that screams "BUY BUY BUY" at us, every second. The sheer amount of advertising is Too Fucking Much. I will guarantee you that ninety-five percent of the population would just stare at you in bafflement if you hit them with this Adbusters-style rhetoric. You want those things, which is fine: more power you! But most people don't care. They are using adblockers because the ads are intrusive and slow down their devices or burn up the battery. If the ads were not intrusive and destructive, they wouldn't take the trouble to block them. That "we want to be free of proxy wars" comment is especially wrong. People love proxy wars! It's no different from rooting for your local sports team. You have a thing you like for whatever trivial reason, it's entertaining to watch that thing fight with another thing. It's a standard element of human behavior.
- jwl 11y ago> If the ads were not intrusive and destructive, they wouldn't take the trouble to block them. Maybe if it had been like that from the beginning, but now, I see no turning back. Adblockers started as a thing for techies and while we may care about tracking, malware and whatnot, my grandma uses Adblock because she thinks it looks nicer and loads faster. Now that she has it, I don't think she or many other ordinary Internet users outside techies, would willingly go back to see ads on websites again, even if the websites promised that their ads are less intrusive than before. No ads at all is still better.
- 13thLetter 11y agoAgreed. Ad-blocking is a whole level above previous methods of skipping ads -- fast-forwarding during commercials, say -- because once you're blocking, it requires no effort to keep blocking and it does require effort to stop. People who block are advertising eyeballs that are pretty much gone permanently. Overcoming that inertia is a challenge I frankly wouldn't want to have on my plate.
- LanguageGamer 11y ago> I'd roughly guess that the amount of time a person had to spend with ads in the 60s in a year is about 1/12 of the time he has to waste (!) with ads now. Perhaps, but how do we measure that? I was surprised to learn recently that advertising for the past century has only grown at pace with GDP, i.e. it has continued to be about 1.29% or our economy: http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-03-03/advertisings-century-of-flat-line-growth http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-03-03/advertisings... But it's still possible that advertisers are buying an increasing percentage of our time and attention. I would love to see a study that attempts to measure that, though it sounds like a tricky task.
- pixl97 11y agoI don't see where that adjusts for the exceptionally low costs of digital mediums. For example, TV ads were terribly expensive because there was only a limited number of channels and limited number of slots. A billboard required sending a team out to put up a new sign. Radio and magazines were also somewhat limited forms of mediums which allowed their price to stay high. Now with digital mediums where ads can be changed on the fly prices have dropped dramatically. One would assume there is a supply and demand curve that directly influences the price. This shows in online advertising where there is almost unlimited supply, the cost/payoff for each ad is very low. In mediums where the amount of advertising is fixed, the SuperBowl for example, the price for ads is at an all time high.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoSince when does capitalism care about the consumer if they can make at least as much money regardless?
- chflags 11y agoThe big lie: www search, sharing photos on a www page, www-based chat, www-based email, etc. would all "disappear" if Google, Facebook and others cannot act as gateways/funnels into a medium -- the www/internet -- and sell ads on that medium, a medium which of course they do not own. This is complete nonsense. If we remove the advertising, those companies might lose money, but the functions we as users perform over the www would most certainly continue. More importantly, there might be some decentralization and movement toward an "edge-focused" medium more resembling the Internet's end-to-end roots. This would make the internetwork much more useful than the one dominated by middlemen monopolies like the one we have now. The money to pay for ads does not come from selling ads. Ask yourself where it comes from. Those are the businesses that must endure.
- dang 11y ago"Please don't use uppercase for emphasis." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html