6 ms·
The irony is that Uber is somehow showing that you don't need taxi licenses to run a responsible taxi service from the point of view of the drivers. It's totall
by ThomPete 11y ago
The irony is that Uber is somehow showing that you don't need taxi licenses to run a responsible taxi service from the point of view of the drivers. It's totally doable to run an effective and safe service without requiring taxi licenses.
The problem is their morals when it comes to how they treat their drivers.
- newman314 11y agoAND your data...
- ThomPete 11y agoFor what?
- trollingineer 11y agoGo easy on the sass there, Thomas...
- brbsix 11y agoThere's been some legitimate concern over what Uber does with the customer data it collects. Spying on and blackmailing journalists and whatnot. Who knows what else. They don't exactly have a "do no evil" motto. http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/blog/ubers-deleted-rides-of-glory-blog-post http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/blog/ubers-deleted-rides-of-gl...
- ThomPete 11y agoWhich is why i said form the point of view of the drivers :) I.e. the claims that because uber isn't doing things by the book it's somehow less safe than using regulated taxi's. This is obviously false since the logging of the drivers and the passengers probably make it one of the most transparent safety protocols out there. Most studies show that some of the biggest detergents against crimes is the risk of being detected. So in other words. Uber is as safe for the passgener, if not safer, than any other taxi company out there.
- newman314 11y agoAFAIK, Uber holds on to your trip data forever. There is not an option to say expire my trip history after x months.
- DanBC 11y agoThe insurance of Uber cars outside the US is dubious. I'd question whether uninsured cabs are a safe option.
- TheCoreh 11y agoHere in Brazil at least, Uber requires drivers to pay insurance for both them and the passengers for any potential accidents.
- ThomPete 11y agoNot in Denmark although a small country. In fact most European countries will have them insure themselves to the extend it's needed to be self employed to begin with. Also the US insurance (and legal) system is a very unique one which other countries don't actually have. So not sure what you are worried about from that perspective.
- DanBC 11y agoIn the US Uber provides insurance to the drivers. Outside the US drivers are responsible for their own insurance. How do you know the Uber you get into has suitable insurance? Any commercial passenger carrying driver needs more insurance than a normal car driver.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoAs parent said, the USA market is unique. How do you know your taxi has suitable insurance! Or insurance at all? Insurance laws in China are completely different from the US (everyone is seriously under insured, even the normal taxis).
- venomsnake 11y agoLets just say that after the sexual assault allegations both in US and India - responsible is in the eyes of the beholder.
- z92 11y agoWould like to add that these type of things happen in legal taxi services too. One can't prevent it. Therefore the question is: How easy is it to track the offender, in both the services?
- ThomPete 11y agoThis happens with all kinds of taxi services not just ubers. But the big difference is that with uber you know who did it.
- kuschku 11y agoThe German license is just the requirement for the driver to actually have a drivers license. In Germany people who want to transport others for profit need a special drivers license. Say bus drivers, taxi drivers, chauffeurs, etc. If Uber drivers are willing to get this license, they can operate completely legally.
- johannes1234321 11y agoNo they can't. In Germany Taxus have a lot of regulation. Among other things: Fixed prices approved by city councils (I.e. no extra charges in times of high demand), "Beförderungspflicht" (the driver can't easily deny a trip, even when goinh just round the corner), taxi operators have to ensure providing "enough" round the clock service and a few such more things Reason is to ensure taxis are a reliable part of pulic transit systems. You can make the "Personenbeförderugsschein" which allows to do "shuttle services" but compared to taxis they can't randomly pick up passengers but I.e. have to return to their base before picking up the next passenger, no waiting at a "strategically" good position etc.
- kuschku 11y agoI never claimed they could operate as Taxi, but in the way they planned to operated. And a Personenbeförderungsschein is the only thing you need for that. In some cities even the only differences between a hired service like Uber or a Taxi is that Uber may NOT use Taxi-only spaces, and may only pick up people who have arranged the journey before pickup. Which is exactly what uber wants.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoAlso, to say, if the city allowed chauffeurs before Uber arrived, and decides that Uber should be regulated as a taxi, they must force those existing businesses to register as well, or create special onerous laws to make a distinction.
- germanier 11y ago
- marcoperaza 11y ago>The problem is their morals when it comes to how they treat their drivers. I'll bite. What's immoral about how they treat their drivers? Their drivers choose their hours, choose which rides to take, and can work for as many uber-like services at the same time as they want.
- ThomPete 11y agoAnd will will answer you. You hire people as self-employed but rip them of the opportunity to work as self-employed by. 1) Not allowing them to set their own fees 2) Not allowing them to hire people to drive for them 3) Discouraging tips 4) Deciding what types of cars they can drive in. All things you would normally do to people who where hired because they would trade that potential upside of being selv-employed by for instance having access to ex. healthcare and vacation. In other words. Uber takes away all the good things about being self-employed and replace them with restrictions that would normally only apply for someone who was employed. While at the same time not giving them access to those things that are actually advantageous about being employed. Uber isn't a technology disrupter it's a legislation disrupter.
- SilasX 11y agoThat doesn't seem to address the parent's point that no one is forcing them to take the job, and they find it to be better than their other options. How, then, would banning them help? Is Uber responsible for the generally poor opportunities in the economy? Does their offering of these positions disrupt a solution to some public goods problem? (A good heuristic for whether one should care about a kind of lawbreaking, btw.)
- iamdave 11y agoThat doesn't seem to address the parent's point that no one is forcing them to take the job, No one forces self-employed independent contractor tradesmen to become self-employed independent contractor tradesmen, and yet when one comes to your house to fix your plumbing or electrical work-there are still requisites under the law that they're entitled to.
- tn13 11y agoWTF is a "responsible taxi service" ? Is the bar to being 'responsible' getting some government license ? Exposing itself to "license" means exposing themselves to arbitrary government control and has nothing to do with being responsible. On the contrary focusing on making good profits is the best way to help both drivers and passengers without compromising interests of both.
- kuschku 11y agoBecause the government license insures the taxi has insurance, the driver is trained, every part of the taxi is separately checked every year, the taxi is clean, the driver can't overcharge, the profits from the taxi driver stay in the region and are not transferred to New York.
- kafkaesq 11y agoExposing itself to "license" means exposing themselves to arbitrary government control and has nothing to do with being responsible. You know, "arbitrary" things like insurance, anti-discrimination provisions, etc.