3 ms·
> So just as we as individuals need to adjust to a world where our love affairs are known to our telcos and smartphones before our spouses Wait, what? Why shou
by GordonS 11y ago
> So just as we as individuals need to adjust to a world where our love affairs are known to our telcos and smartphones before our spouses
Wait, what? Why should we simply accept mass, indiscriminate surveillance that has an incredible potential for misuse now and in the future?!
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoBecause the upsides, properly managed, outweigh the down. My lifestyle, as a piece of anonymised health data, along with my genome can benefit medical research as well as my own health choices who I meet or converse with, who is nearby, who is willing and able to purchase the same product as I locally to gain discounts, who is looking to hire someone with my skill sets, who is looking for sex. So many options exist once We all place our digital life up on a publically readable board that it is hard to imagine we will refuse it. But there are about four options 1. Police state. The only people with access to my digital life are the police. China is currently looking at a digital credit score, incorporating party loyalty amoungst other things. 2. Private walled gardens. AOL, Facebook, health insurers, driving insurers. All of these private companies collect my digital life right now. Some of not all can or are compelled to give the data secretly to 1. Above. Even if they were not, the total utility of the data is dramatically reduced in walled gardens plus why is trusting Facebook more sensible than trusting my government with the same data. 3. Anonymised and public. So no walled gardens but lots of open protocols for sharing data, and anonymising that data. This means my weight and most recent meal can be used by medical researchers. However, anonymising data sets sucks - there is little chance I will remain as anonymises as the idea of "privacy" indicates 4. Totally open. Just stick the raw data up and let cottage industries come tell me something interesting. It's most probable that "good" societies will find a balance between 3 and 4. Some my even be the societies currently seen as developed democracies, but there is no guarantee. The advantages of data are such that a society built around the right precepts for big data will win big time - like a society that wrote down its precepts 250 years ago, "we hold these rights ..." The only protection against being blackmailed for being gay in the military is to not make homosexuality a criminal offence and then have all the gays in the military come out. This is the same protection we have against all the mass surveillance - that we know everyone's business. Is it going to be really hard to manage? Yes, and that's why some Socities will make it and many won't. Most have not grasped modern democracy.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAnonymizing data is a myth. Enough data, and you can guess from only a few details who its about. There are ways of identifying a computer by what software/updates are installed. Identify a 50+ male on my street who buys embedded processors - well, that's only me. See how easy?
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoThat's what I said. But somewhere between trying to anonymise and totally open is likely to be the sweet spot of the next 100 years
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoNo, somewhere between anonymizing and not collecting the data at all, will be the safe spot. Otherwise, Big Brother.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoWe won't avoid collecting the data. It is then just about who has access to that data - I say that giving everyone access to everything is the "safest", and that we can pull back from that in a controlled manner towards anonymising data. But we cannot avoid this. For example one suggestion is that paving stones will come embedded with "RPi-level" computing (IoT will be so cheap ...) and will in essence be used by my local council to assess wear and tear and potholes etc. What this means is that my paving stone outside my house will be able to report every time I leave, and you can tell the difference from me stepping out or in and someone walking on the preceding flagstones. Can we complain about the council improving how it handles potholes? But it is a total loss of privacy at my front door. This stuff will be everywhere
- isaacremuant 11y agoYour theory is thought provoking but it seems to fall under the same problems as the others. 1. How do you regulate that companies are actually giving things up? People will hide things if it's beneficial to them and there's very little you can do about it short of becoming the police state you said you didn't want. 2. How do you deal with the fact that some entities will have more resources than others to make use of that open data? It doesn't seem to level the playing field as you suggest. If you think that you can force them to level the playing field because their pursuits will be open as well, go to 1. 3. Innovation, competition, defense, dealing with other countries who won't act the same way and a long etc. While I understand the abstract concept I'm not sure how much thought you've put into it with regards of the practicality.