6 ms·
The CIA and/or NSA very likely knew that the 9/11 terrorists were in the US, learning to fly airliners. Not long after 9/11, there were reports that Mossad agen
by mirimir 11y ago
The CIA and/or NSA very likely knew that the 9/11 terrorists were in the US, learning to fly airliners. Not long after 9/11, there were reports that Mossad agents (the "art students", as I recall) had been tailing the 9/11 terrorists. Almost all of whom were Saudis. But I've seen no credible reports that any of them knew what was planned.
And yes, those pages might be very interesting.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, some of those pages have been leaked by the German Federal Intelligence Agency (BND), because some of the attackers lived in Germany before and it was a priority for them. Funnily, one of the attackers used to have a small internet cafe in my city before he learned to fly an airplane.
- s_q_b 11y agoThe NSA also had a tap on the Yemeni safe house where the attackers were calling to coordinate. The hijackers even stayed in Laurel, Maryland, from which you can literally see Alpha and Bravo. Yet the 9/11 commission only spent three visits and a paltry amount of time up at Fort Meade and NBP, anecdotally because the commute to the Fort is too long. Edit in reply: No, they never put the intelligence together. See here for a not-terrible summary: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/01/13/the-al-qaeda-switchboard http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/01/13/the-al-qaeda-sw...
- mirimir 11y agoSo did the NSA know what the attackers were going to do? I find it very hard to imagine that the NSA and/or CIA would have let the attacks happen, even to protect key assets and methods. Maybe they had compromised some Mossad communication channel. Or maybe they had a double agent. But what would have been worth the risk to DC and NYC?
- toyg 11y agoMore likely, they had taps but did not know what they were talking about. It was widely reported that, pre-9/11, Arabic translators were scarce in most Western intelligence services including the US, since their traditional focus were Russian, Eastern-European languages, and Chinese. You just need basic informal codes for most logistic purposes (which would be mostly "I've done this, I've done that" to confirm timings and prepare the next steps, rather than "I will hijack a plane and crash it into NYC" which would have been agreed beforehand) to make it very difficult for people who might not know all the intricacies and slang of regional Arabic varieties. So the NSA might have known these people were learning to fly and maybe even preparing a hijack, but until 9/11 this was not dramatic -- if and when the hijack happened, they would have been expected to fly to Cuba or something and then dealt with. Pre-9/11, airplane hijacks had become rare since their '80s and '70s heydays, maybe there was some complacency (as in "yeah these guys will never manage it, and even if they do, we'll likely get most passengers back safely anyway, let them play"). Or at least that's what a sharp Occam's razor would suggest.
- mirimir 11y agoOK, that makes sense. And maybe the NSA and CIA weren't talking, either.
- dorfsmay 11y agoOld style hijack had become rare because police forces around the world made sure that you couldn't come out a winner, you typically get killed. Hijacker are at a disadvantage: limited resources, stuck in a small space easy to surround. The fact that the 9/11 highjackers had planned to die as part of the hijack was a game changer.
- matwood 11y agoExactly. A 9/11 style attack is also a single time event. Now that passengers know the outcome, they simply will not let it happen again. The only possible method would be to turn an existing pilot into a suicide killer.
- 11y ago
- avs733 11y agoVery much in the opinion space here... To an extent, as with all big data systems, massive collection of data has both opportunities and risks. The risk in overcollection (e.g., the NSA type programs) is that you collect so much damn information that you are either behind in analyzing it or flat out never get there [1-2]. Combine that with (as others have noted) the lack of translators and you get what you got [3]. The old maxim* that not all data is information (DIKW) heavily applies here [4]. This whole phenomenon becomes especially problematic when you are spending all that time energy and money largely trying to predict 'black swan' events using what has happened before as what to look for in the future (e.g., the TSA as a whole or the NSA still focusing on cold war languages pre-9/11 [3]). [1] http://www.zdnet.com/article/nsa-whistleblower-overwhelmed-with-data-ineffective/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/nsa-whistleblower-overwhelmed-w... [2] http://apps.washingtonpost.com/g/page/world/how-the-nsa-tried-to-collect-less/518/ http://apps.washingtonpost.com/g/page/world/how-the-nsa-trie... [3] http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/aug/31/lack-of-translators-still-hampers-intelligence/?page=all http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/aug/31/lack-of-tran... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DIKW_Pyramid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DIKW_Pyramid Edit: *fixed typo of maximum to maxim
- matwood 11y agoI agree that it is extremely unlikely they let it happen. I think if all the documents are ever declassified it will be a case study in the breakdown of communications in a large organization. There was office politics (FBI vs. NSA vs. CIA), no overall coordination, and plain incompetence to name a few things that were wrong. We see this all the time in large companies now, the difference is that rarely do people die as a consequence. Maybe the NASA Challenger accident is a comparable organizational breakdown.
- avs733 11y ago>I think if all the documents are ever declassified it will be a case study in the breakdown of communications in a large organization. I have always been curious about this as an organizational phenomenon. What percentage of documents are classified for actual security reasons as opposed to things like embarrassing the country or allies, covering up misconduct or outright illegal conduct, or just as the default reaction. Study would be impossible/impractical even with access, but it sure would be interesting.
- mirimir 11y agoThis one?[0] > Indeed, some of the C.I.A.’s best information about Al Qaeda came from the F.B.I. In 1998, F.B.I. investigators found an essential clue—a phone number in Yemen that functioned as a virtual switchboard for the terror network. The bombers in East Africa called that number before and after the attacks; so did Osama bin Laden. The number belonged to a jihadi named Ahmed al-Hada. By combing through the records of all the calls made to and from that number, F.B.I. investigators constructed a map of Al Qaeda’s global organization. The phone line was monitored as soon as it was discovered. But the C.I.A., as the primary organization for gathering foreign intelligence, had jurisdiction over conversations on the Hada phone, and did not provide the F.B.I. with the information it was getting about Al Qaeda’s plans. So was the NSA also monitoring the Hada phone? Or maybe providing technical support for the CIA? [0] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/07/10/the-agent http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/07/10/the-agent
- hartpuff 11y ago> The CIA and/or NSA very likely knew that the 9/11 terrorists were in the US, learning to fly airliners. Has there ever been an explanation why the hijackers risked conspicuously attending flight schools under the noses of the US authorities, rather than, say, absolutely any other country in the world?
- mirimir 11y agoThe better to learn how US airspace worked?
- ptaipale 11y ago>Has there ever been an explanation why the hijackers risked conspicuously attending flight schools under the noses of the US authorities, rather than, say, absolutely any other country in the world? Because there are more flight schools in the US than anywhere else, and if you want to do some flying in US airspace, those are in the best position to teach how it works, what controls there are, how to avoid them, etc.
- sokoloff 11y agoMost flight training in the world is done in the US, by a wide margin. Because of that, they would probably stick out much less doing it here than trying to do it in one of the few EU airline training facilities.
- tptacek 11y agoNot only that, but for the plot to work, the hijackers had to start from within the US. Implanting them in the US long before the attacks made it easier for them to reliably get to their target airports the day of the attack. In a sense, the comment upthread litigates the whole idea of a "sleeper cell."
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIs that the right word? Validates? mitigates?
- ck2 11y agoEveryone also forgets the twin towers were already successfully attacked several years earlier by a huge bomb in the basement. Anything about the world trade center should have lit up intelligence reports like a christmas tree.
- tootie 11y agoThe CIA most definitely knew and refused to share that information with the FBI. http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/07/10/the-agent http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/07/10/the-agent
- prostoalex 11y agoThere's a good reason for lack of sharing as both Aldrich Ames (CIA) and Robert Hanssen (FBI) ended up providing much more sensitive information to the adversary than their rank qualified them for. The agencies seem to be on the cycle of high compartmentalization -> criticism for lack of sharing -> low compartmentalization -> major spy scandal -> high compartmentalization.
- tootie 11y agoThose guys committed treason by sharing with the Soviets. I don't see how that's relevant. The reason for the wall is because they have conflicting mandates.
- prostoalex 11y agoThe natural response of each agency to prevent such massive information losses in the future is to limit the amount of information available, make it accessible only on the need-to-know basis, and introduce bureaucracy into the information retrieval process by keeping the logs and requiring sign-offs.
- hackuser 11y ago> The CIA ... very likely knew ... They definitely knew something: A month before the attacks they gave President Bush a briefing titled: "Bin Ladin Determined To Strike in US" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike_in_US https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike...