11 ms·
If people think this is wrong the same people should ignore taking any deductions on their personal taxes. If we want companies to pay their "fair share" then
by mc32 11y ago
If people think this is wrong the same people should ignore taking any deductions on their personal taxes. If we want companies to pay their "fair share" then governments should institute international tax reform and have a tax treaty where signatories abide by whatever they agree to.
Here companies are rationally choosing ways to pay as low a tax burden as the laws allow. As they say, hate the game, not the player.
- jjoonathan 11y agoIf the player is able to rewrite the rules of the game (or prevent such rewriting) in order to benefit themselves, they gain culpability. Yes, we should focus on fighting them, but that was never in question.
- mc32 11y agoI'm not opposed to countries capturing whatever they feel is just to tax corporations, however, crying foul when they allow this by their own laws is their problem. Pass the laws, make everyone abide by them and we'd be good. I simply don't agree when they allow a loophole and them complain about companies using the loophole. Same with corporate inversions. If we don't think it should happen then get some tax treaties in place and enforce it.
- mike_hearn 11y agoExcept Google, Apple etc did not write these tax laws. Actually, the EU and Ireland did. The companies came later to take advantage of them ... in Ireland's case, it was done quite knowingly for that exact reason. They prefer having the companies and employment than having the corporation tax.
- jgalt212 11y ago> If people think this is wrong the same people should ignore taking any deductions on their personal taxes. That's a false equivalency and and you should be smart enough to know it.
- refurb 11y agoCould you explain why?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- csomar 11y agoCan you try to criticize the comment instead of the commenter?
- xnfnnfd 11y agoIt's a fair comment to make if someone is a self-described Google apologist.
- superuser2 11y agoThat someone is predisposed to argue a certain way has no bearing on the validity of their argument.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tn13 11y agoIf Google makes more profit it means my grandma who haw invested her life's saving in stocks makes more money, it means self driving cars will be reality sooner and it means poor people on Indian railway stations can access internet now. If that money ends up in government coffers it means some American is getting harassed somewhere, Mexican drug lord getting assault rifles, our phones being spied and wars on the other side of the globe. Less money in the hand of government under any pretext is a good thing.
- adamnemecek 11y agoPlease tell me your post is satire.
- frogpelt 11y agoExactly what I was thinking. How many salaries and how much research can be funded with $2.4B? On the flip side, if it were received as tax revenue how much government bloat and inefficiency would it have to cut through to produce something useful? There's a way for the U.S. to fix this and that is to cut the corporate tax rate in half. Watch the money come flowing back home.
- Symbiote 11y agoI know better than to debate the merits of public spending with Americans, who for some reason see reducing funding as the only way to improve their government... But why should Google benefit from tax evasion at the expense of most smaller businesses, who pay the normal rate of tax? If Google paid their share, that's $2.4 bn less everyone else would have to pay to maintain the same level of service. Or you could use the money to fund an American CERN, for example. (Because no private company funds such long term research.)
- joelrunyon 11y ago> But why should Google benefit from tax evasion at the expense of most smaller businesses, who pay the normal rate of tax? You're assuming that because Google is being strategic in their tax planning that other people are getting hurt. This is similar to you having a good accountant who saves you money and thus are "cheating" the system because other people don't have as good of accountants. Not to mention that it's easier than ever for small companies to operate multi-nationally.
- tn13 11y agoAlso, all these people should not invest in Google stock either.
- NetStrikeForce 11y agoActually, shareholders should be the first ones to make sure the company plays by the rules. Creative accountancy has led to very nasty outcomes in the past - I wouldn't like my accountants to be too creative with my taxes.
- notahacker 11y agoDeductions on personal taxes are intentional provisions to encourage certain types of saving/investment/giving. Weaknesses in tax treaties are not designed to encourage people to repatriate their profits to artificial entities in tax shelters. Google pretending that sales are made in Ireland (and not by the revenue-targeted local salesperson selling local ads to local eyeballs) in order to enable them to deduct fictitious license fees owed to a subsidiary in Bermuda is not even in the same ballpark. It's the equivalent of me donating most of my salary to a "charity" created for the purpose of paying my mortgage. I don't think many people here do that, or would consider it if their accountant suggested it.
- nunyabuizness 11y ago>It's the equivalent of me donating most of my salary to a "charity" created for the purpose of paying my mortgage. I don't think many people here do that, or would consider it if their accountant suggested it. Why not? If it was legal, why wouldn't you do it?
- DanBC 11y agoSome tax planning is clearly legal, and is an expected use of the tax laws. Some tax planning is clearly illegal. People are hiding money and evading tax. There is a grey area in between. People use tax laws in unexpected ways. Their accountants and lawyers claim this new planning is legal. The tax authorities claim it isn't. To find out if it's actually illegal it gets tested in court, except no-one wants that. Companies don't want it because lawyers are expensive. Tax authorities don't want it because lawyers are even more expensive for them and it looks terrible if they fail in court. So some weird deal is made. The company repays a trivial amount of tax, some rule gets added or taken away to make it clearer that the tax plan is unlawful. So, here, a big company can do it because spending many thousands on lawyers and tax accountants means they save hundreds of thousands, millions, billions, on the tax bill. I can't afford the tax accountant, so those schemes usually are not available to me. And as soon as enough people start using them the laws change, sometimes leaving me in a tricky situation.
- deleted 11y ago
- libraryatnight 11y agoYou might be right, but that doesn't make it right or responsible.
- microcolonel 11y agoI think it kinda does. In fact, it may be considered fiscally irresponsible not to do this. A CFO who wants to pay taxes is a liability, and if you have shares you should want them fired.
- libraryatnight 11y agoI disagree. This feels like short term greed that hurts everyone in the long run.
- Nutmog 11y agoIf the US changed the law so it could collect that tax money, couldn't you equally say that it's the US's short term greed that hurts everyone in the long run? Afterall, it would hurt Google's profits and perhaps how much they can invest in useful new technologies. How do you decided that it's only greedy for Google to get money but not the government? What's the government going to do with it? Fight more wars? House more prison inmates? Pay more social welfare? Are you sure it's going to do something better with the money than Google is?
- dogma1138 11y agoIt's the responsible thing to do for their shareholders if they do not play the same game anyone who owns a Google stock could get their board hanged. If a company intentionally does something that results in a financial loss they are liable to their investors this is how the market works.
- matwood 11y ago> It's the responsible thing to do for their shareholders And not just shareholders, but for employees, suppliers and everyone else the company deals with. Companies usually do not sit on the money, they invest it trying to make more money. Usually this investment is on salaries, but can also be on R&D, acquiring other companies, etc... It always ends up on the fundamental question of who is better to determine how to spend money - the public or private sector.
- refurb 11y agoI agree 100%. A great analogy for you is the "backdoor Roth" contribution. In the US, you can contribute up to $5.5K per year (post-tax) into a Roth IRA. You will never pay taxes on any gains made as long as you withdraw after a certain age (56? 65? I can't remember). Now the gov't phases out the allowed contribution based on income. If you make more than $117K but less than $132K per year (individual, it's probably changed since I last remember), the allowable contribution is scaled back. Anything over $132K per year and you can't make a contribution. Now, the interesting thing is that you can make an IRA contribution and convert it to a Roth IRA with no income limits. Hence the "backdoor". Plenty of people do this. It's 100% legal and the IRA will tell you can do it if you call them. Is it wrong to take advantage of it? I would say no.
- dogma1138 11y agoIt's not the same thing at all, some things are exempt from tax this is a "smart" tax policy that is instituted to ensure that people save money, in the US you have an IRA in the UK it's called an ISA, most countries also give you tax credit for participating in a pension scheme. If you want a good analogy on a "personal" level (even tho there isn't really one) is that if you would transfer all your property to an offshore trust and they pay yourself rent deducting the rental costs from your overall taxes under various schemes. If a normal individual would play the same game they would be singled out for tax evasion, and while if you are wealthy enough you can hide behind off shore trusts and shell corporations you money is often tied down considerably more than the money of a multi-billion dollar corporation. Google can't really move that money easily either if they want to move it into the US they'll have to pay taxes eventually but as long as they keep it offshore they can use that money for credit as well as actually pay out any debts they might have to presumably other multi-billion dollar corporations without having to pay taxes on it. But what usually they do is either wait for a "bad" year or when they have enough carry over deductions to move their money back in without paying any taxes due to deductible or horde it until they'll get a good deal and only have to pay a fraction of the tax that they would've normally pay (and every couple of years you read that corp X has came to agreement with country Y to pay couple of billions in tax, what you often do not read is that amount is usually less than a quarter of what was actually due). Now don't get me wrong Google isn't doing anything illegal, and unfortunately as a public company they are pretty much forced to do it because otherwise they open the selves to their investors because if a company "intentionally" waste a shitload of money it will have to answer to their investors and the board can kiss their positions and bonuses good bye. The problem is that international taxation is complicated there isn't a single good international tax treaty and when you involve multiple jurisdictions you complicate things even further because even if the US will have a treaty to collect taxes from say an Irish subsidiary when it does not generate any taxable income in Ireland because it's in account debt to another subsidiary in Bermuda there's nothing you can do. One of the "good" sides of the TTTP is that it actually gives (at least the US) quite substantial tax collecting provisions as well as limits the taxes that can be set on US goods, while this might help the US many of the other countries might get screwed over this because it doesn't necessarily works both ways.
- devsquid 11y agoYou are right, but its still wrong. Even if the legislation around the subject matter doesn't work, it doesn't mean the companies aren't paying their "fair share". They aren't. Just because something is legal, does not make it morally acceptable. At the very least it should show the fan boys that companies like Google, Microsoft, and Apple really do not give a shit about you. Its about profit, they are a corporation, stop idolizing corporations.
- spydum 11y agoHow does this play against a companies fiduciary duty to shareholders? If your competitors can use these legal techniques, aren't you also obligated to stay competitive?
- Sven7 11y agoTrue. Which is why I approve the activist shareholder plans at Microsoft and Google to move their CEO's and global HQ's to India.
- fixermark 11y agoThat's functionally impossible at Google, unless there's a defection in the core leadership. The company has never let more than 51% of the voting shares leave a very tight-knit group.
- devsquid 11y agoYes you are. It still doesn't make it morally ok.
- IncRnd 11y agoWhat is wrong and immoral is that a single company is considered immoral for not paying an additional $2,400,000,000 in taxes.
- devsquid 11y agoWhy? The US is clearly in desperate need of tax dollars. Look at how much we spend a year for the military alone, which accounts for around half of the USA's total budget. Whats also shocking is that the tech companies have billions of dollars sitting around doing nothing.
- fixxer 11y agoI don't think there is anything "wrong", but I appreciate the irony that Eric Schmidt and his ilk have spent a lot of time and money getting cozy with politicians that want to tax me into the ground.
- ThomPete 11y agoOf course they are rationally choosing that. But they are irrationally not paying their debt back to the same society that made it possible for them to build the business to begin with. This is not a company who came out of nothing and created the TCP/IP protocols, the Internet, WWW, the billions of pages and information out there. It's a company who is building on top of something society invested in. And is now trying to avoid paying that back to same said society. Legally they have no obligations but morally from a company who used to claim "don't be evil" they do.
- fixermark 11y agoGiven that the government they owe those taxes to has consistently minimized funding on infrastructure, has yet to build a national broadband policy that is competitive with the world, and consistently underfunds the NSF year over year while continuing to approve the NSA's black-box budget, perhaps the optimal approach for "Don't be evil" is to do everything within the law to keep their cash in-house, where it can be put to better use?
- ThomPete 11y agoBetter use for who? Right now Google is one of the leading companies in making work obsolete leaving a growing number of people without any chance of participating in the society because digitalization and automation two areas google is one of the key drivers of taking a lot of jobs out of the market. So not only didn't Google create their company in isolation from society but on top of what society established they are also transforming how society works affecting a lot of people negatively. This is not true with all companies but it's certainly true for Google.
- Nutmog 11y agoUsing your argument, internet companies in every country are morally obligated to pay tax to the US government, at least if they claim not to do evil. Do you also agree that every company making cars should pay tax to the German government because Germany started the car industry?
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoExcept that a company can lobby Congress, and let this tax setup stay like this forever. An individual like me can't.
- fleitz 11y agoCompanies can't vote...
- mahyarm 11y agoThey pay for ads which generate votes.
- fleitz 11y agoi would suggest voters vote based on something other than ads... However if people wish to vote based on ads that's their prerogative. They could vote based on something else but they are usually so concerned about a democrat/republican getting in that they'd rather vote for a republican/democrat.
- TheLogothete 11y agoThat is what ads are for. They activate the electorate with appropriate messaging.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoUnless you personally know the people you vote for, or spend a lot of time researching their history, their programs and the relation of those to political, economic and social issues, you are voting based on ads. Believing something else is deluding oneself.
- fleitz 11y agoMost of the time I don't vote. When I do I vote libertarian, I've never seen an ad for the libertarian party in my country. When I buy ads (donate) I buy ads I buy for the Green Party in areas where they are splitting the left wing vote. The best way I know of to influence government is to have professionals prepare my taxes, and to ensure the government follows the law to the letter. Voting is designed to limit the influence of the individual on politics while appearing to give people choice. If we wanted government representative of the views of the people we'd just draw 500 names of citizens out of a hat.
- ryguytilidie 11y ago"If people think this is wrong the same people should ignore taking any deductions on their personal taxes." Perhaps its time to just ban humans from analogies...
- pointernil 11y ago"As they say, hate the game, not the player." Why? Change the quite strong word "hate" to something less extreme and polarizing and then let's discus why it is OK, acceptable and not out right destructive to setup and use and actually benefit from those tax avoidance schemes? Blame the game? The corporation? Well, how about the small (or not soo small in case of CFOs) particles making up a corporation, the CFOs and their teams actually seeking and personally benefiting from those actions. How comes these people are not to blame? Rules of Law ARE NOT the final instance of morality or of constructive social conduct... or are they? Only for the "rational agents", i guess. The game is to blame, the gov/civil-organizations on almost all sides are to blame, the corporations are to blame, the individuals driving this are to blame, too. ps: how "rational" is it for a corporation to avoid its share pay back to the society? It due time to close these morality-loopholes. Actually that's the only way, i think, to tackle these problems: a change in socially acceptable behavior because there is no way we can close all loopholes in all the laws. Those people (yes, people and not abstract 'corporations') in the end "should not want to" circumvent the tax-obligations.