4 ms·
This is a confusing point. At the moment, there is no software or tooling to do what the FBI wants so the subpoena asks them to "develop new capabilities" in or
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
This is a confusing point. At the moment, there is no software or tooling to do what the FBI wants so the subpoena asks them to "develop new capabilities" in order to meet it. However, once they have done that for this one phone, they will no longer be able to say truthfully "We can't do that." and any time a phone needs to be unlocked the FBI will get a judge to issue a subpoena and if Apple doesn't comply, with the proof out there they could comply, then they are in contempt.
It is that follow on that is the back door. So now Apple is in the position where they have to unlock phones on demand, and not doing so will subject them to fines and imprisonment (you cannot easily appeal an order to do something in a case which it is clear you have the capability to do).
What is worse, if they are forced to comply and develop this capability, and then design the next generation of phone so that they once again don't have a capability to break into it, that case then is even harder. The FBI can sue Apple for intentionally obstructing justice.
Don't be fooled, this isn't a case about one phone and one set of people who have shot a bunch innocent people. This is very much a calculated strategy on the Justice Department's behalf to get back doors into phones and create legal precedents for which they can compel those back doors.
That will force the group that doesn't want back doors to get Congress to create a law that specfically forbids them. And the Justice Dept knows that would be very hard for folks to achieve.
- mikeash 11y agoIf Apple can build the software and tooling in question (and as far as I've seen nobody disputes that they can, the question is simply whether they will), then they are already unable to truthfully say "we can't do that."
- matwood 11y agoFor the 5c and possibly the 6. What if they design the 7 to not be able to create the tooling? Would Apple be in violation of precedences set earlier?
- mikeash 11y agoI don't see how. "Break into this phone." "OK." Then later: "Break into this other phone." "Can't." How does that violate anything?
- snowwrestler 11y agoThe fundamental question is whether a federal court can require a private company to do new work, to assist a federal investigation. The answer now is no. Companies must provide access to information if they possess it, but that's not the same as writing new software to enable access to information they don't possess. Once that Rubicon has been crossed, it is unclear what the legal test would be to limit the work that can be requested. If a court can require Apple to write some piece of software, why couldn't it require Apple to write some other piece of software? Or take any other affirmative action that might assist the FBI? I know this might sound crazy but this is how common law works. Court decisions create precedents, which are often in the form of heuristics for constraining future decisions. A very famous example is the Supreme Court precedent on abortion: before a fetus is viable, the government does not have a legal basis for considering it to have independent rights. Whether or not one agrees with it, the rule is clear. Right now the rule is clear for what companies must do under court order. If the FBI succeeds in applying the All Writs Act in this case, that clear rule will be gone. What will take its place? Edit to add a concrete example: Apple announces that iOS 10 cannot be broken even by Apple. The FBI goes to court and says that they are tracking known terrorists who are using iPhones. If those terrorists get iOS 10 as announced, the FBI will be impeded. So Apple must alter iOS 10 to ensure that they can deliver retroactive access to phone contents in some way. This would be the smartphone equivalent to CALEA, which requires network operators to build their networks in a way that permits wiretapping. The big difference is that CALEA was passed by Congress, whereas the FBI would only need a court order for smartphones!
- tamana 11y agoSo this debate may end of FBI asks Congress to pass a law and Congress certainly will. :-(
- 11y ago
- Laaw 11y agoThe standard is "without undue burden".
- tamana 11y agoHow much is "undue burden"? In the past, the govt paid companies for ther wiretapping efforts. Would that make the burden less undue?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoLets put it a slightly different way, lets say you make safes for protecting valuables. And you make your safe so that any attempt to break into it without the combination would destroy the contents, or make it so that the only way to open it, like cutting into the steel with a torch, would destroy the contents. The FBI can (and does) hire locksmiths and safe crackers to get into safes where they believe there is valuable information inside, but they don't compel the manufacturer of the safe to create a capability of bypassing its safeguards, but if they did criminals would seek it out so they could rob those safes, and customers would stop buying that safe because they knew criminals could probably get their hands on the same tools the government could to break into and defeat its countermeasures. So having the government able to order a safe maker to build a safe that can be broken into, the safe maker loses customers and business because their customers don't want a safe that can be broken into, they want one that protects their valuables from everyone.
- mikeash 11y agoIn this case, the government isn't ordering a safe maker to build a safe that can be broken into. The safe maker already built a safe that can be broken into. The government is just ordering the safe maker to take advantage of that fact and break into it. Many people equate this to demanding that Apple create a security vulnerability, and I don't get it. The vulnerability is already there. The iPhone 5c is already insecure against an attack by Apple. The government is just ordering Apple to exploit that existing insecurity. There are compelling problems with that too, but it's not the same as requiring Apple to build something insecure.
- vectorjohn 11y agoPerfect. To fix your analogy and make it more accurate, it's more like the safe making company has the ability to make a device that can disable the self destruct capability for a single safe. If the safe company simply hadn't built in that capability, there would be nothing the FBI could demand of them, because it wouldn't be possible.
- samstave 11y agoWe need to find out who at the FBI is literally responsible for this request and require that they lose their job (impeach? How do you as a society demand that someone in the position to make this request be removed) Remember the attorney general who molded the torture stance for the bush admin? John Yoo and Alberto Gonzalas? We need to be able to make these people accountable and be removed when they do stuff like this. Those both are basically war criminals.
- vectorjohn 11y agoBut we already know they'd lying if they said they can't "do that" now. That's why they aren't saying "we can't do that." The threat to privacy is no different weather Apple complies or not. No precedent would be set, because this isn't different than any other time the FBI has demanded documents about a person from a company. I'm not a lawyer, so I don't know if a company has to comply when the FBI demands information for a person. But if they do, this shouldn't be seen as any different.