5 ms·
Product Hunt's Response to Accusations of Exclusivity Is to Increase Exclusivity
- w1ntermute 11y agoProduct Hunt's problem is that even though a less exclusive/biased system would create more value for users, such a system wouldn't allow PH to capture much, if any, of that value for themselves. By enabling biases in their listings, they're able to shift some of that value from the users over to themselves. It's good for the companies that get more attention than they deserve, and most consumers won't find out due to information asymmetry and apathy. It's the same reason why you can't trust Yelp reviews - they needed to generate revenue somehow, and the only real option was to offer to hide negative reviews in return for money.
- cperciva 11y agothe only real option was to offer to hide negative reviews in return for money. I don't understand this. Why couldn't they sell "you seem to be looking for a dentist... this other dentist (who paid for this advert) has a higher rating than the one you're looking at right now"? It seems that Yelp could have been in the enviable position of selling advertising which is actually useful to the viewer.
- Fede_V 11y agoBecause then why would any dentist who is not at the top pay for advertising?
- cperciva 11y agoBecause they would gain customers who were previously looking at inferior-to-them (according to Yelp ratings) dentists.
- hayksaakian 11y agoYou would think so, but in reality they sell banners on a CPM basis on blanket categories. How they screwed up this opportunity, I don't know.
- hayksaakian 11y agoYou would think so, but in reality they sell banners on a CPM basis on blanket categories. How they screwed up this opportunity, I don't know.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- timr 11y ago"It's the same reason why you can't trust Yelp reviews - they needed to generate revenue somehow, and the only real option was to offer to hide negative reviews in return for money." This isn't true. You are repeating unsubstantiated rumors as if they are fact. Source: I worked there. I know the code and processes in question. It isn't true.
- rl3 11y ago>Submitters without any network at all are screwed. If success in becoming featured on Product Hunt is contingent on the submitter's network, then the submitter's product is probably of such quality that they're screwed anyways. That, or their product is solid but it simply isn't appealing to the PH crowd. You see cool stuff every day that fits that description, usually accumulating a mere handful of votes. Generally speaking, the more niche the product is, the more likely it is to end up in that category. Product Hunt is ruthless curation. It isn't designed to be fair. Suffice it to say, exceptional products—or products that make waves elsewhere—are almost assuredly bound to do well on Product Hunt, regardless if the author even has an account there, let alone a network. To be clear, I'm not defending insider voting rings, I'm just saying the best strategy is to trancend them entirely.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoThe difference is where the product shows up on the PH page. With a network, you automatically get access to the front page. Without it, you won't even show up on the site even if it's the best product in the world for the PH crowd.
- rl3 11y agoIt'd still be posted on Product Hunt though, despite no self-submission. That said, banking on PH to carry your initial launch is a bad idea if you've no network there, let alone posting ability.
- taytus 11y agoSo people are more worried on being featured on PH than having a profitable business? Am I the only one who couldn't care less about PH?
- PM_NAKED_PIKS 11y agoWay too many idiots playing entrepreneur. My customers aren't on PH. Most, if any "customers" on PH are short lived.
- taytus 11y agoI honestly don't get it. Maybe is my fault, I don't know, maybe I'm missing something.
- w1ntermute 11y agoYou're not missing anything. Product Hunt will fade away as the VC bubble continues to deflate.
- PM_NAKED_PIKS 11y agoThis. Don't get attached to PH, when the bubble is a poppin' PH will be gone.
- minimaxir 11y agoIt doesn't, and I'm not saying that it is. However, the perception of some naive entrepreneurs is that being on Product Hunt is a one-way ticket to success, which is why there are tons of blog posts on Reddit and Medium about success stories: https://www.reddit.com/r/startups/search?q=Product+hunt&restrict_sr=on https://www.reddit.com/r/startups/search?q=Product+hunt&rest... Another trend in those stories is "I had a strong network upvote my product!" which entrepreneurs think is a good thing (the hustle!) and obviously does not matter in the real world. I think PH is a negative externality on the startup ecosystem.
- callmeed 11y ago
- flashm 11y agoMy main issue with Product Hunt is that most of the products are so trivial that it almost seems like a parody site. A sample from right now: 'The funniest dog name generator ever' 'Fast and easy way of collecting email addresses' 'Finally, an emoji keyboard for the modern desktop' Don't people have more interesting things to do with their time, or try to create more interesting, useful products?
- moab 11y agoProducthunt tends to attract the same sort of 'undergrad CS major with a business minor' types that has contributed to the valley's reputation a status circle-jerk since the 90's. I think producthunt is also the natural result of hackathon culture---a culture where how you dress up a project and sell it matters infinitely more than the technical prowess or understanding that building it took. For anyone in the know---have they fixed their issues regarding product submission? IIRC, they have some weird, draconian rules regarding multiple submissions, so if someone happens to submit your side-project and you weren't really ready for the traffic they just tell you 'too bad' (that is unless you have some well connected VC pulling strings for you).
- devindotcom 11y agoYeah, it cracks me up nearly every time. I mean, there's definitely a place for little projects like this where a couple people say "man there's gotta be a better way to collect email addresses and put them in a shared doc" and put something together. It's like a novelist writing a little two-page short story - just someone executing an idea. But there are so many, and they're often so overwrought! I guess it's really easy to make a professional-looking landing page for stuff now, but that doesn't excuse the vapid self-hype the items give to themselves: "Hat management will never be the same again." "Prepare to start a new life with this revolutionary alarm app." "You've never experienced productivity unless you've tried these Slack automation scripts." (fake but still representative) So yeah. I've thought about doing a column mocking these things but it would probably just leave me more jaded.
- untog 11y agoProduct Hunt's greatest success is being the perfect reflection of the Silicon Valley industry and mindset that surrounds it. Whether you consider this a feature or a bug is a personal judgement. Personally I'm glad it exists because it seems to divert at least some of the vacuous SV sycophancy away from Hacker News.
- cynical_sheet 11y agoProduct Hunt is the mirror image of Silicon Valley startup VC scene. It's all about connections, nepotism, pedigree, ass-kissing and brown-nosing.
- teleclimber 11y agoIt's too bad OpenHunt didn't take off. But of course why would it? With no public commenting system it simply isn't "sticky" enough. https://www.openhunt.co/ https://www.openhunt.co/ HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10759879 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10759879
- fweespeech 11y agoYeh but it also takes a substantial, sustained effort to build a community and after the initial launch the OpenHunt crew stopped. https://www.openhunt.co/audit https://www.openhunt.co/audit Maybe no spam for all of Feb?
- wnm 11y ago> The front page real estate taken by the in-network posts comes at the expense of those out-of-network in a zero-sum game. Submitters without any network at all are screwed. I don't know if that assessment is true. I don't have a network. If I submit something to PH and someone with a network upvotes it, their network is now more likely to see it. So if you create something cool, that a few people with networks discover on the upcoming feed, you're chances to reach even more people and get the foot in the door (and land on the frontpage) are higher now, with this new front page algorithm, no?
- minimaxir 11y agoGranted, if you don't have a network, your submission is stuck in the "upcoming" purgatory, so that issue already blocks the probability of a serendipitous upvote.
- solveforall 11y agoNow you can't submit something unless you're invited to the network and PH approves. Anybody want to help me out with an invitation?
- callmeed 11y agoIt's sad. The response PH gave in December dodged the true question of how do things get to the homepage [1]. Defenders stuck to the concept of "Great products will make it to the homepage"–in reality, everyone knows that's complete BS. I find myself going to PH weekly now instead of daily. It's almost predictable the things you'll see there now (yet another mockup tool, "ProductHunt for X", trivial toy app, etc.). Maybe a site like this simply can't scale and keep this format. [1] https://twitter.com/rrhoover/status/679150836862218241 https://twitter.com/rrhoover/status/679150836862218241
- timrpeterson 11y agoThanks for the analysis. I'd be curious to see PH's traffic. I get the vibe from checking # of retweets/hearts on their tweets that PH has peaked and are now on the descent.
- gravity13 11y agoThis is exactly what happened to Digg. You had people getting paid to get stuff up on Digg's front page. So Digg introduced friends and the ability to see what friends are digging. And they banded together to really ruin the experience for others. During the time it happened, I did a bit of offhand calculation and found that of all the posts on Digg's front page, most had the same 100 or so "power diggers" in the first 200 likes of the submission. And these 100 users were authors of at least half the submissions on the front page, many of which were clear promotional ads.