3 ms·
That's not a similar example to what's going on here. Your example would have to include a situation in which the FBI makes copies of the keys to the house, co
by adventured 11y ago
That's not a similar example to what's going on here.
Your example would have to include a situation in which the FBI makes copies of the keys to the house, copies of the hard-drives, etc. Then inevitably makes it embarrassingly easy for other parties to get access to those as well, permanently reducing your net security to almost zilch regardless of the outcome of the context and warrant.
And worse, in the process of gaining access to that one house and hard-drive, they simultaneously gain the potential to access millions of homes and hard-drives that have nothing to do with the warrant, and then those millions of houses and hard-drives see their net security reduced to essentially nothing.
- rayiner 11y agoThey're offering to let Apple do the unlock themselves and just hand over the data.
- criddell 11y agoAnd that establishes a precedent. So, in a future case that is less sensational, the court could order to Apple to unlock that phone as well and Apple would have to comply. Apple doesn't get to pick and choose which court orders it complies with. That goes for court orders in the US, China, Canada, etc...
- vectorjohn 11y agoSlow down there, you're moving the goal posts way too fast. If you have an argument, stick with it. If Apple doesn't want to look bad complying to FBI requests, they shouldn't have put a backdoor in their software.
- snowwrestler 11y agoApple cannot do the unlock. They're attempting to force Apple write new software that will make it easier to brute force the passcode. Whether they force Apple to also do the brute force themselves, or the FBI does the brute force, is not really the important part.
- vectorjohn 11y agoNo, this would not reduce the net security of anyone at all. The FBI isn't asking for a master key to everything, or a backdoor to all iPhones. They're asking for the data on this one single device. In other words, if some other party got the modified software, it wouldn't do anything. The software was asked to be device locked, which is trivial to do. The reduced security you worry about already happened on the iPhone.