4 ms·
>>> Apple also argues that since its reputation is based on security and privacy, complying with the court’s demands based on an expanded application of a 200-y
by sandworm101 11y ago
>>> Apple also argues that since its reputation is based on security and privacy, complying with the court’s demands based on an expanded application of a 200-year-old law could put it at risk of tarnishing that reputation.
One one hand, a corporate reputation. On the other, people from the FBI saying they need access to prevent terrorist attacks. There are many arguments to be made. This is not the winner.
- heartbreak 11y agoFortunately that argument is being made in the NY case which is not the terrorism related case in CA.
- MBCook 11y agoThe interesting thing in the CA case that's not getting a ton of play is the FBI has the support of the phones legal owner (a government agency) but the owner doesn't know the passcode in this situation. If the suspected terrorists owned the phone themselves, we'd also have the 5th amendment wrapped up in that case too.
- rosser 11y agoIf the suspected terrorists owned the phone themselves, we'd also have the 5th amendment wrapped up in that case too. No we wouldn't. The "suspected terrorists" are dead.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoNot all of them. Their neighbor is a suspected accomplice and is currently being investigated.
- rosser 11y agoIrrelevant. He has no 5th Amendment standing vis à vis the deceased shooter's work phone.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThe what-if scenario was if the suspected terrorists owned the phone (as opposed to the deceased's employer). The living neighbor is a suspected terrorist. If he owned the phone and let his now-deceased neighbors borrow the phone, the complications mentioned above could arise.
- rosser 11y agoOne of those sides is being fatuously disingenuous. The San Bernardino shooters demonstrated rather competent op-sec, and the 5c the FBI wants Apple to backdoor was a work phone, not even a personal one. I'm spectacularly skeptical they used that phone in any way whatsoever relevant to the attack. More to the point, the attackers are already dead. There is nothing to prosecute here. They picked this case as the one to push because they thought it had the best PR value for their purposes, not because of any exigence or concern over further impending attacks. That is to say, the FBI is cynically leveraging the outrage at a mass-shooting, inflicted by "brown people", to further their anti-crypto, "We must have access to ALL OF THE THINGS!" agenda. It's pretty disgusting, frankly. EDIT: snark.
- mc32 11y agoBoth sides are positioning themselves for maximum advantage vis a vis their publics. Neither one is acting without self interest. The USG says it wants to prosecute crime and associates, Apple say they want to protect the privacy of their customers and not doing so tarnishes their image which damages their business proposition. The courts, the congress and the people will ultimately determine who prevails.
- rosser 11y agoYou'll note that I didn't dispute Apple's self-interest in their position. But they're being up-front about it: "Our customers will lose trust in us if we do this thing, and that hurts us as a business, as well as them." That's not merely PR. That's a fact. The FBI's stated position, "These people did a terrible thing and we have to investigate it" is pure PR; the phone the case is proximally about is not at all what it's ultimately about.
- chrisdbaldwin 11y agoIrony being that the real shooters were 3 tall white dudes from Craft Intl.
- 11y ago
- scottyates11 11y agoI think the two parties need to hold a meeting and make some agreements in the future because more and more personal information or activities will be saved on the phone. The number of conflicts between Apple and the government will keep increasing. People need to find out the point of balance.
- CaptSpify 11y agoWith respect: I completely disagree. I don't think the govt has any right to force apple to allow them to bypass anything encrypted. IMO, this isn't a balance situation, but rather a binary situation.
- scottyates11 11y agoThanks for your opinion. Do you think this is a problem can be solved? Or the two parties will just keep fighting without an end?