5 ms·
"Last year, undercover TSA agents managed to smuggle concealed guns and bombs past security 96% of the time." So does that mean that thousands more weren't det
by rahimnathwani 11y ago
"Last year, undercover TSA agents managed to smuggle concealed guns and bombs past security 96% of the time."
So does that mean that thousands more weren't detected?
- spike021 11y agoI'm curious if there's a bias here though. Do the undercover TSA agents not already know where the weaknesses are in the detection process?
- elthran 11y agoPossibly - but if they know the weaknesses, then it means that they are being left unaddressed for whatever reason (malicious or otherwise)
- derefr 11y agoOr just that highly-experienced senior agents who've worked in many different locations and have "seen it all" know what to look for, but most agents are junior and don't.
- mseebach 11y agoThat's very possible -- but it really doesn't change much, does it? A gun on its own isn't dangerous, a gun in the hand of a bad actor is. If bad actors (who, being motivated, must be assumed to have access to the same knowledge of weaknesses as the TSA) are getting ~96% of their guns through, it doesn't really matter that only 30%(no idea, just put a number<<96%) of neutral actors' guns do. Compare pen-testing: You want the best possible hackers, with as much information as possible, to take a swing at your system - not a bumbling amateur, even if the amateur accurately models 99% of your regular users.
- mirimir 11y agoMaybe undercover TSA agents are better smugglers.
- nickik 11y agoGoing by the usual standards of TSA people I dont think that guy was Jason Bourn.
- EvanPlaice 11y agoTo give them some credit. They have been pretty consistent about flagging and searching the portable electrical toolkit I use for work. Every time I check it as baggage, I get it back with a TSA certificate notifying that it was searched. Of course, I'm probably on some list now as a result. So, I got that goin' for me, which is nice.
- joakleaf 11y agoAccording to http://sos.noaa.gov/Datasets/dataset.php?id=44 http://sos.noaa.gov/Datasets/dataset.php?id=44 there are 29000 commercial flights per day in the US. If the 7 guns per day corresponds to 4% found, that would mean that there are 7.0/0.04 - 7 = 168 guns per day not found. That's abound 1/2 percent of flights (one in 172) where a gun got aboard undetected.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoThere's a huge difference between someone trying to get a gun through security and some poor person who just accidentally forgot it was here. The latter would be way easier to detect than the former. Of course it's the former that we really care about.
- DanBC 11y agoI don't care about terrorists, because that's fantastically rare. I do care about the fucking idiots who carry a lethal weapon but forget that they're carrying a lethal weapon, because those are the people who are less likely to keep that weapon away from tiny children. (Roughly one shooting a week in 2015 by children under the age of 3 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/11932821/toddler-shooting-gun-controls-america.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/1...)
- avar 11y agoAren't those numbers overwhelmingly related to someone leaving a gun in a drawer at home and a toddler finding it? What does this have to do with airport security? Do you think someone's going to accidentally bring a gun to an airplane and their toddler somehow manages to find it during the trip and shoot themselves? That seems like an awfully contrived scenario.
- DanBC 11y agoIf you're the kind of idiot who forgets that you have a gun in your bag you're the kind of idiot that forgets to put it in out of the reach of children. We want those people to be discovered, and reminded to keep their lethal weapon in a safe place and to remember at all times where their lethal weapon is.
- dhd415 11y agoYou can't extrapolate from the two facts of "2,653 firearms discovered by TSA" and "undercover TSA agents managed to smuggle concealed guns and bombs past security 96% of the time" to an expectation that some ~63,500 total firearms were not detected because it is likely that many if not most of the firearm discoveries were not attempts to smuggle the firearm onto the flight. It is not especially uncommon for someone who routinely carries a weapon or other non-TSA-approved item in his or her purse or briefcase to forget to remove it when flying. I've done this twice with a Leatherman multi-tool (among its tools are a pocketknife blade that is obviously not TSA-approved) that I used to keep in my laptop bag. In areas where guns may be carried, this happens with guns. In these cases, the travelers had simply forgotten to remove the weapon or unapproved item and were not attempting to smuggle it onto the flight. When it's pretty clear that there was no intent to smuggle the item onto the flight, the traveler is generally asked to remove the item and there is typically no penalty. I was asked to return the Leatherman to my car or pay to have it Fedex'ed back to my house.
- scotty79 11y ago... so TSA is probably really good at preventing people from accidentally carrying weapon onto a plane.
- dkersten 11y agoWhen you do it by accident, you're not exactly trying hard to conceal it. So, yes, they probably are really good at preventing this. The 96% statistic suggests that they are not good at preventing concealed, hidden weapons from slipping through...
- rahimnathwani 11y agoYou're right, of course, and that's why I said 'thousands' rather than doing the math assuming the least charitable interpretation (giving your 63.5k). If the guns the TSA detects are carried accidentally, it seems that using x-ray or metal detectors to find them is overkill. Just ask 'please remove your laptop, liquids, and guns' before putting your bag through the x-ray.
- wahsd 11y agoI think what it means, relative to the OP claim, is that the TSA stepped up its game and is now reporting the guns it itself is trying to smuggle past itself as the subject guns that are being detected at airports. If you know how the government works, that is the only plausible explanation.