6 ms·
>> While American banks appear to have turned the corner since that gut-churning autumn nearly eight years ago, European institutions are girding yet again for
by sandworm101 11y ago
>> While American banks appear to have turned the corner since that gut-churning autumn nearly eight years ago, European institutions are girding yet again for another round of restructuring.
The world should not work for the banks. The fact that American banks are now bigger than ever before is not a good thing. We need more banks, more competition in the marketplace. For that to happen the big banks have to first shrink and/or be manually broken apart. Europe's banks may not be happy, but Europeans should be. They are doing what American and the UK want but have so far failed to accomplish.
>> there’s once again a flight to simplicity. That’s what regulators are demanding. And that’s what legions of customers are expecting as startups deliver financial services at the tap of an app.
I wouldn't go that far. The answer to the too-big banks isn't necessarily a new paradigm. A larger number of smaller and more traditional banks offering very traditional services is also an answer. I'm not sure I want any of my banking to ever be "at the tap of an app". I don't take money so casually. Online yes, app tapping no.
- omegaworks 11y agoExactly. I wonder how much of this transformation can be emulated in the states; how much people in Congress are paying attention to what's happening across the pond. >> That month, Deutsche agreed to pay $2.5 billion in penalties to U.S. and U.K. authorities for its role in the Libor rate rigging. (No current or former member of the bank’s management board was implicated.) It's very hard for me to feel bad for these people.
- kasey_junk 11y agoJust for added context citi & jp Morgan paid over 2 billion in penalties as well.
- Eudyptula_minor 11y agoSomething tells me American Congress is not paying attention THAT much.... XD
- tomp 11y ago>> (No current or former member of the bank’s management board was implicated.) > It's very hard for me to feel bad for these people. Why would anyone feel bad for them? They got what they wanted (bonuses), and didn't face any negative consequences (jail).
- lmm 11y agoThe core business of a bank is taking a global view on risk. The very idea of maturity transformation (at the heart of what a bank does) relies fundamentally on being big enough that the laws of large numbers come into play. If we're saying we don't want big banks then we're saying we don't want banks. Maybe you want that - maybe mortgages should be sold directly to investors on the same maturity terms - but it would be a radical change to the way finance works for everyone.
- orbifold 11y agoIdeally banks should be done away with as soon as possible, that is for certain. Private institutions that control part of the the money supply in exchange for taking on the risk of evaluating and assessing worthy recipients of credit is something that made sense before there was a supercomputer in everyones pocket. There are now already better alternatives. Replacing banks should be just one example of recovering centralised power for the people by means of technology.
- ApplaudPumice 11y agoI'm not good with economics, do you have any link which explains alternative models sans banks?
- smaddox 11y agoThe only role banks fulfill that couldn't easily be replaced by a digital currency is financing speculative investments by providing loans. Unfortunately loans also expand the money supply (and contract the money supply upon repayment/default), resulting in a positive feedback on investment, which can induce instability (i.e. the business cycle). It would be much better to decouple the money supply from investment. The money supply could be controlled either by a trusted agent (e.g. central bank), or possibly by a built-in stabilization algorithm (an interesting avenue for research), while investment could by financed privately. This would be the best of both worlds.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago
- rayiner 11y agoDo we need more competition in banks? We have way more viable banks than say viable mobile operating system makers, or viable desktop operating system makers, or viable search engines, etc. Do those markets lack adequate competition?
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "Do those markets lack adequate competition?" Yes, they certainly do. All of the markets you listed could do with stronger competition. As for banks, I also think they could do with stronger competition. We should never have any company which is 'too big to fail'.
- rayiner 11y agoWhat makes you think competitive markets keep entities from becoming "too big to fail?" There are enormous economies of scale in nearly any business. There is a reason there are just a handful of companies left capable of gabbing their own chips. Same with say Amazon and Wal-Mart. The market equilibrium in any moderately capital-intensive industry favors just a handful of huge competitors.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "The market equilibrium in any moderately capital-intensive industry favors just a handful of huge competitors." That's why it's necessary to occasionally clip their wings. Even if capitalism left unchecked results in large concentration of power, the role that government plays in regulating these markets is to enable (or at least, should be 'to enable') new competitors to emerge that can compete with established players, in order to maintain healthy levels of competition.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "I'm not sure I want any of my banking to ever be "at the tap of an app". I don't take money so casually. Online yes, app tapping no." I'm not sure why convenience takes away the seriousness of what a bank does. It's just a place to store money and invest in the economy, what does it matter how you access the information about your account? For example, what's the issue with a bank like Mondo? https://getmondo.co.uk https://getmondo.co.uk