3 ms·
We should not be commuting 45 minutes. In the future, you telecommute or live in communities designed to minimize commutes. Traveling long distance should bas
by ilaksh 11y ago
We should not be commuting 45 minutes. In the future, you telecommute or live in communities designed to minimize commutes. Traveling long distance should basically be an edge-case and might involve something totally different from short-distance transport like an evacuated tube train e.g. "HyperLoop".
http://tinyvillages.org http://tinyvillages.org
- melling 11y ago45 minutes is probably a 5-30 mile commute. Do you really think we need to travel at 600 mph to solve that problem? If you read the article, they are only talking about 4 miles, as mentioned in the first paragraph: "On a brisk October day in Chicago, a few employees from the design firm Ideo left their office and headed to Knife & Tine, a restaurant about four miles away. The goal, besides lunch, was to complete the journey within 45 minutes, on a budget of just $10 for the whole group, all while carrying bulky shopping bags."
- ilaksh 11y ago5-10 miles no, 30 miles it might be workable to use a high-speed transport. I assumed long distance since they said 45 minutes. A 45 minute commute, walking or otherwise, indicates a poor design. Sustainable doesn't need to mean giving up convenience or technology.
- ghaff 11y ago30-45 minute commute is pretty normal even within cities with good subway/transit systems. Walk to transit. Wait for transit. Possibly switch to another line. Walk to destination. This can easily amount to that timeframe even over just few mile distance.
- ilaksh 11y agoYes, I am quite familiar with typical cities and commute times as I used to live in New York. However, there are some fundamental design changes that we can and should make that will dramatically improve the situation versus a typical city of today. Please see my http://tinyvillages.org http://tinyvillages.org which has most of it. But I will mention a few things. One, most office work can and should be done over the internet with increased used of voice, video and other collaboration. Secondly, most metropolitan areas are actually largely suburban. My design improves land use and density by about 800% over current suburbs, which means much shorter distance between business and home and therefore much shorter commutes. Thirdly, automated single passenger (self-driving) vehicles can dramatically reduce commute times by reducing waits to near zero and massively improving traffic efficiency. Fourth, a sane urban design will have a law and information system that distributes operating/commute times evenly along morning and evening windows to effectively mitigate rush hours.
- melling 11y agoHow many single passenger self-driving vehicles do you think you can drive into Manhattan or San Francisco?
- mc32 11y agoEven in high density cities with great public transit like Paris, Tokyo, London and Moscow have long commutes. I'd be interested in seeing data from these commuter friendly cities showing average "work related" commute times. It's not like when you get a new job you can just rent a new place close to work. In vast metro areas, commute times are going to vary from very short to very long.
- barney54 11y agoIt is very difficult to minimize commutes because of all of the things you are simultaneously minimizing and maximizing. In two income families, you have two different job locations, with kids you have school considerations (as well as distance to grandma's), you have housing considerations (size of house, lot, urban, suburban, ex-urban) and more. But just the issue with minimizing two commutes is difficult. I hate commuting, but I love riding my bike to work. But because I need to drop off or pick up the kids, it means I have to drive on some days. My wife and I choose our house for a number of factors and due to the fact that DC has some of the worst traffic in the country is commute is about 50 minutes to and hour each way.
- dilemma 11y agoSkyCity One.
- microcolonel 11y agoThis page is ridiculous, if for no other reason than the bloody "solar roadways". A failure of thought process on every level; ideas this facially bad should be recognized immediately.