8 ms·
Yahoo rolls back decision to combine Tumblr’s sales team with Yahoo’s
- tacos 11y ago550 million users and less than $100 million in revenue. A penny and a half per user per month. This company turns 10 next year.
- RyJones 11y agoThat is an astoundingly low ARPU. I see Twitter predicts between $2.50 and $4 ARPU. I looked for but couldn't quickly find a recent Flickr revenue breakout. http://finance.yahoo.com/news/twitter-targets-ads-logged-users-154256083.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/twitter-targets-ads-logged-use...
- tomjen3 11y agoFlicker has a relatively low free tier and is targeted at people who are amature or professional photographers, ie people who can afford at least 2k of entry gear. Tumblr has no paid tier and is targeted at (or mostly used by) teens and early twenty-somethings. So I would question any direct comparision between the two.
- tbyehl 11y agoFlickr killed Pro several years ago, removed restrictions on the Free tier, offered paid options to go ad-free or add a second TB of storage, then later killed those options and brought back Pro as stats and no ads. Flickr's free tier is no longer low. What their audience is these days, who the hell knows.
- n72 11y ago... and it's even worse when you consider the site is > 10% porn.
- dangerpowpow 11y agoNot sure what happened but I kinda miss some(many actually) of the tumblr blogs that I had in my bookmarks, most of them return a 404.
- pavlov 11y agoAFAIK, Tumblr closes blogs that receive too many copyright infringement notices. That's probably the reason.
- skewart 11y agoI've noticed a lot of tumblr blogs I used to enjoy simply stopped being maintained by their creators. In some cases they've even been deleted. There still seems to be a vibrant community on tumblr, but it's different from the one that flourished five or six years ago. A lot of the design-focused bloggers have simply left.
- true_religion 11y agoWhere have they gone to? Medium?
- ddw 11y agoEllo! (kidding)
- funkyy 11y agoTumblr is a jewel in a crown of Marissa Meyer. It should be in instruction book under - how to screw huge opportunities.
- rayalez 11y agoTumblr has a lot of potential, it could be really great, but it's not well done. Design should be better, discovery system should be better(more like on medium/reddit), it is also ridiculously slow on tablet. Also search is horrible, I am typing a blogger's nickname or the name of the website and his original content is nowhere in the results, only reposts and copies. If they would just learn from medium and copied a lot of the things they did right - that would already be a huge step forward. Then they could monetize it by allowing bloggers to advertise their blogs, or by creating a store with ebooks/merch, or a smart donation system.
- aikah 11y ago> If they would just learn from medium Medium is content "centric" and tries to promote "good" content or writing. Tumblr is 80% porn. There is nothing they can learn for Medium.
- dawnbreez 11y agoActually, Tumblr is 35% politics, 15% porn, and 50% random gifs of videogames. And 95% of statistics are made up, too. It's hard to say what Tumblr actually consists of.
- chris_wot 11y agoYup, this is what happens when you force through "integrations" on a profitable, smaller organisation with your larger, slower organisation. You get: * integration technical problems * power struggles * dominance by the bigger group, and a lack of understanding what made the smaller company work so well * some of your best people leave. If you mishandle it, lots of your best people leave. * a major slowdown in any growth whilst largely valueless politics and questionable business practices distract the original company and they take their eye off the ball Honestly, precisely how many tech takeovers really work? The CEO and board gets this great idea that they can buy a hot company to turn around the fortunes of their existing company. Then they take all their inefficiencies, bad ideas, politics, incompetence and total lack on insight and corporate memory and force that upon the company they bought. They normally chuck out the original management (not always, but frequently) who made it all work in the first place, then they start imposing changes on customers, leading to pissed off customers. A good example is that the taken-over company has support processes that work quite well for them, but they force customers to go through their existing support systems, which are often slow, inefficient, off-shore, and have a first point of call who probably doesn't know much about the service they are meant to support. Often the parent company don't know about back channels used by the original company to gather feedback to iterate effectively. Those aren't normally documented and are part of institutional memory and culture, gained over years of hard work. Goodwill in the company then dives, and after 2-3 years (sometimes earlier) the original management team have a shell of the original company. Then they realise that their profit forecasts they originally promised to justify the takeover were hugely optimistic, and even the realistic forecast that in all probability would have been met had they not taken over the company won't be met due to the bloody awful decisions they have made. At this point, they either: roll back their pointless or bad changes, bring in a new management team, or shutter the acquired company after strip mining the assets of their acquisition. Rolling back the changes often leads to an even worse situation because now the original company has lost their momentum, lots of key people have left, they haven't been able to adapt as the market changes, and they have lost a huge amount of existing customer goodwill. Now the company must a. Fix the problems caused by the people who imposed it on them, b. Still play political games as people who were responsible for the awful decisions cover their arse and still have the ear of those in the parent company (which makes it harder to justify going back to the way things were), c. Explain to customers who have been put through turmoil (and who might be getting used to the albeit detrimental changes they have experienced) why they must now go through yet more changes as the company tries to put things back to the way they were, and d. They now have to justify their very existence, even though their momentum, talent, and direction were severely and adversely disrupted. Point d. is particularly damaging because they are still expected to meet the unrealistic earnings targets predicted by the original CEO, but often it's an impossible task. Bringing in a new management team rarely works. Unless they are extremely good, then all the disruption of rolling back changes tends to happen, but now you have a new set of people who don't have a clear grasp of the business, and this time they don't even have the advantages of the original team (advise, goodwill, talent, etc) that the original management team had. Eventually, if rolling back changes or bringing in a new management team don't work, then the original company gets shuttered anyway. If the acquiring company is lucky, the profits generated by the acquired company largely cover the costs of acquisition. But they lose enormous amounts of goodwill, both from those who are retrenched (ultimately for no good reason) and who might be potential customers or even competitors in the future, and from customers who were treated shoddily and who quite possibly see your company as a risk to deal with as they were left in the lurch and now need to spend time and resources finding an alternative product or service, with all its corresponding risks and implementation issues. I can't see larger companies ceasing or even improving their acquisition processes any time soon. All I can say is that if you are a customer who uses a product or service from a company who is taken over or is part of a merger, start immediately planning on the best way to migrate from them should you need to so you mitigate your risk. And if you are an employee, by all means hold on for the ride, but be aware that the things you love about working for your company are quite likely to change or be entirely lost - and ultimately you may find you won't have a job. Dust off your resume, do not fight the system (that way madness lies), accept it's out of your control and take steps to handle disruption in your working life.
- shaurz 11y agoTumblr is an virtual insane asylum for various narcissistic personality disorders. I'm not sure if it's a good thing to keep these mentally disturbed people in one place, or if this is outweighed by the echo chamber effect which amplifies their destructive behaviours.
- 5ilv3r 11y agoWhat a bunch of yahoos...
- nashashmi 11y agoThis reminds me of a trail of failing integrations. The lesson I derive is that it is much easier for a highly disciplined (and uncreative) organization like Microsoft to incorporate a technology/acquisition into their team, than it is for a highly creative undisciplined organization to incorporate the discipline and technology of its parent. Case Study Example: AQuantive and HP Autonomy
- at-fates-hands 11y ago"We were distributing Tumblr sponsored posts across Yahoo content in their native stream, but very few advertisers actually wanted it because it’s a different audience. And the content on Tumblr was very different from the content on Yahoo," Isn't this something fundamental to having one sales team? Knowing which ads should be run on each platform? Not sure you could miss something so huge and still expect the same or better results. This is a huge "WTF" moment for both properties.
- josu 11y agoNot clickbait title: "Yahoo is rolling back the decision to combine Tumblr’s sales team with Yahoo’s broader sales organization"
- chris_wot 11y agoMy understanding is that there is a preference in keeping the original source's title.
- dang 11y agoExcept when it is misleading or linkbait. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: I'm not sure the OP was particularly baity, but we'll change the title to josu's suggestion.
- chris_wot 11y agoI really need to reread those guidelines.
- Animats 11y agoThis is strange. They ran into trouble merging the sales organizations. Two product lines doesn't mean you need two sales organizations, even if they have different demographics and need different types of ads. Why sell the same customers twice? Does Youtube have a separate sales organization from Google Ads?
- NegatioN 11y agoYour point has merit, but I would argue that YouTube has a much broader audience than tumblr. I assume this would make it easier to have a centralised sales team. (If they actually do)
- Gratsby 11y ago> "She also named Tumblr as one of the three core platforms for Yahoo going forward, " I thought Tumblr went the way of Friendster years and years ago. I find it hard to believe that their user base is getting any bigger aside from bots and spammers.