3 ms·
As one middle manager pointed out to us, at Apple the top managers are engineers. “We make everything into a business case and use figures to prove what’s good,
by lordnacho 11y ago
As one middle manager pointed out to us, at Apple the top managers are engineers. “We make everything into a business case and use figures to prove what’s good, whereas Apple is engineer-driven.” Top managers acknowledged to us that “there was no real software competence in the top management team”.
That stood out for me. Whenever I've worked with managers who didn't understand the field, interactions have always gone something like this:
Manager: Can we deliver X?
Team: Sure, it will take 3 months.
Manager: Can we deliver X in 2 months?
Team: No, I told you 3 months.
Manager: I need it done in 2...
And how it proceeded depended a lot on how bone-headed the manager was. Sometimes they would effectively let someone competent on the team do the management. Sometimes they would just try to bully until they got the answer they were looking for.
- kabdib 11y ago"What if I got some more people to help out?" "Five months." "You guys are too slow. I'm going to give it to team B over there. They say they can do it in two months, no problem." "You'll be asking us to help out that team in about a year." It is amazing how little value most managers add.
- madeofpalk 11y agoSounds like you're working in a pretty crappy place. I don't consider my employer to be exceptionally great, but at least there's no managers stupid enough to act like that, or developers to tolerate it.
- kabdib 11y agoOh, that's from very long ago. And most of them weren't that bad. And I have had good managers, really good ones who added value, but only 3-4 really qualify (in 35 years). I work in a flat organization now. No managers at all. So it's an interesting perspective.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoWhenever I've worked with managers who didn't understand the field, interactions have always gone something like this I've seen that, but there's something even worse. It's when a manager who doesn't understand something thinks that it must be simple and/or easy. Where I experienced it firsthand was working for a VP of Engineering who was from a hardware background. He didn't grok software and therefore believed that it should be easy to do. I didn't mind, I was one of the hardware guys. But that meant that the software guys at the company were sucking hind tit. Hey, at least its better than working for a company run by sales and/or marketing people. They have contempt for both the hardware guys and the software guys.
- raarts 11y agoSo much this. I have been working in a company which was run by sales, who thought 'how hard can it be?' all the time. Sales did not sell, company was sinking, sales disagreed. I left.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAstonishing especially in the startup world. Where your product better get the respect of other innovators and early adoptors, or you're sunk. Yet sales asks for mainstream average performance/features. And can't seem to find any traction. I've unfortunately experienced more than one startup failure due to sales getting control.