9 ms·
The poor are better off when we build more housing for the rich
- gizi 11y agoA housing crisis is pretty much always caused by government policies. It would be perfectly possible to build a satellite town up to 50 miles outside a major agglomeration connected by a high-speed transport link, such as a highway or train. People would live up to an hour from their work places. Housing units costing between 15 000 - 20 000 should be affordable even for the very poor. It is important, of course, to make sure that there is enough local retail and entertainment, but that is just a question of not regulating it out of existence. Without heavy-handed government intervention, it would emerge spontaneously. None of this would be economically a problem. The reason why it does not happen, is government interventionism. Seriously, there does not exist a problem in the world that is not made worse by governments.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoA two hour+ daily commute does not seem ideal.
- xivzgrev 11y agoIt is if houses were much much cheaper. Shit I had a 2 hr daily round commute INSIDE San francisco, taking bus from the ocean and then walking to office. Id be beside my self if there was cheap housing an hour commute away.
- xivzgrev 11y agoI don't think it's just government. Youd also have to go thru all the existing private land owners for a 50 mile track. And there may be some hope - marin and Sonoma counties just built a train. http://main.sonomamarintrain.org/ http://main.sonomamarintrain.org/
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoAre you familiar with the concept of a "company town".
- DiversityinSV 11y agoThe data is nationwide. But California proves this NOT to be the case. Sunnyvale/Mountain View have experienced 4 years of building new housing without limits, yet every year is more expensive. The new units (rental or for sale) are way higher than the average rent or price. (e.g. ALL the new housing being built now in the peninsula is priced at $1MM or more) I fail to see the point of pushing for new unregulated housing here besides saying in 30+ years the middle class will move to housing built for the rich now. Sure... In 30 years the middle class won't exist. (and in SV I give it 12-15 years)
- rst 11y agoIt also neglects a huge factor in several hot markets, particularly New York: rich out-of-towners buying apartments as investments, and leaving them unoccupied. The owners aren't living there, and the buildings are typically reworking or replacing former residential units where people actually resided, so the net effect of that new construction is that the stock of housing available to house people who actually live in the city is reduced.
- danieltillett 11y agoThis problem is so easily fixed via the tax system I am surprised it has not been done already. Just tax high and rebate for residency.
- Radim 11y agoToo naive, I'm afraid (as well as, in my opinion, misguided). Just put yourself in the shoes of the investor. Government announces they're gonna make you pay through your nose if no one "lives" in your apartment. Leaving aside the dubious morality of such penalization (it's a slippery slope!), is your reaction going to be "Oh noes, I am ruined! Better sell my apartment now."? Or can you think of half a dozen simple, practical ways around it? I bet you have already.
- spc476 11y ago
- zach 11y agoThis is specifically related to the SF Bay Area and there is a link to the source which has a easy-to-use Excel sheet of the data, so feel free to make an awesome geo-mashup: http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3345#Technical_Appendix http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3345#Technical_App... Also, the measure is not whether available housing is getting more expensive, but whether low-income households are being displaced.
- jimrandomh 11y agoThey aren't being displaced. There's a good breakdown of the new construction that's happened in http://rationalconspiracy.com/2015/05/25/new-york-times-makes-up-facts-about-sf-housing/ http://rationalconspiracy.com/2015/05/25/new-york-times-make... ; the short version is, new units are replacing vacant lots and abandoned buildings.
- raldi 11y agoI think you two are talking past each other because one of you is referring to "being displaced" in the sense of it happening because of new housing being built, and the other is referring to "being displaced" by the lack thereof.
- staunch 11y agoIt's an absolute crisis. The government should response just as it would in the event of war time profiteering.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoOr people could move, but sure it's just like war time profiteering.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoIf you're living paycheck-to-paycheck, or even close to it, no, you can't move. Edit: I'm curious what people are disagreeing with here. Do you think that moving to a new city doesn't require expenditures?
- raldi 11y agoMany landlords would love to be able to evict their tenants and replace them with new market-rate renters, in exchange for paying the old tenants' moving costs. Or even the moving costs plus a year's rent in the new location.
- staunch 11y agoNot true in 99% of cases and no one said anything about paying below market rate rent except you...
- CyberDildonics 11y agoIf you were living paycheck to paycheck but it was because your rent was too expensive, wouldn't it seem that you couldn't afford not to move?
- staunch 11y ago> Or poor people could move, but sure it's just like war time profiteering. ftfy
- 11y ago
- rokhayakebe 11y agoEveryone (myself included) cries about house prices, yet I believe there are many many truly beautiful small cities and towns where you have great internet access, safety and amazingly affordable housing. People just needs to have the guts to move to these places and recruit friends and family and like minded folks to join them.
- Grishnakh 11y agoYou seem to be forgetting that there are no jobs in those places. Affordable housing isn't worth jack when the only job you can get there is working at Walmart, because there aren't any software development jobs there (for instance). The other problem is that if you're a young professional, you may very well be single. Moving to a small city or town means you will not get a date, unless you want to date some overweight, uneducated woman who has 4 kids and talks about Jesus and guns all the time. If you're on this site, that probably isn't the right demographic for you. You'd have better luck moving to a foreign country; rural and urban America are that different these days.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- trav4225 11y ago"rural and urban America are that different these days" ...which is why I'd prefer rural America over urban America any day. :)
- mehwoot 11y agounless you want to date some overweight, uneducated woman who has 4 kids and talks about Jesus and guns all the time I think if I wanted to pick a comment as the canonical example what is wrong with people on HN this would be the one.
- Kalium 11y agoHonestly? When I lived in South Texas, that was only a slight caricature. They didn't talk about Jesus and guns all the time.
- transfire 11y agoIt's rough when the rich own numerous suites they rarely dwell in. They have to give some middle-class loner a basement apartment with discounted rent to meet occupant requirements. Yea, that'll help.
- _cudgel 11y agoYou know, it makes sense to me that increasing supply should drive down demand and hence prices. But I frankly don't care. The entire piece reads like an excuse to not do things for the poor. How about we actually do things FOR THE POOR instead of tossing them scraps from the tables of the rich?
- xtqctz 11y agoEvaluating arguments on their merits seems nice, but mood affiliating feels so good.
- swehner 11y agoPredictable drivel. How about using international data?
- gradstudent 11y agoI think the headline is only true if the new housing for the rich actually increases the overall supply. Is that actually happening in SF?
- jimrandomh 11y agoNo one is tearing down old units. People are trying to get new units built, mostly on vacant lots, and getting blocked by incumbent landlords who want to see prices go even higher.
- gradstudent 11y agoTearing down old units is not enough. The construction works need to actually increase the overall housing stock. If old tenement buildings disappear and are replaced by oversize luxury apartments the overall stock goes down and the situation for the poor is made worse.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThat trend has been going on in SF for a long time. Dwellings are getting larger steadily over many decades, and the number of people who live in a dwelling has been getting steadily smaller.
- greggman 11y agoDo you have any links that show this research?
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThe census tracks people per household. In 1940 this stood at 3.08. In 2010 it was 2.26. A "housing unit" built today simply doesn't hold as many people as it once did.
- 11y ago
- pennyless 11y agoThere is nothing in the article to justifying the headline. What the headline should have said is "more expensive housing keeps the prices of the expensive housing lower". While true, this has absolutely no reflection on the affordability, the latter being dependent on things like level of income and such. If the cheap housing is removed to be converted to expensive, there is less cheap housing, and it becomes less accessible, because more poor compete for it.
- stale2002 11y agoAnd if the total housing stock increases then that means that rich people won't be buying up the poor housing stock. For every "Rich Person Condo" that is built in SOMA, there is one less "Up and Coming Apartment in The Mission" that gets taken up by a rich techie. The rich are going to move to the city whether we like it or not. They have the resources, they can buy out whatever place they choose. The only choice we have to make is whether to build housing for them or to just let them displace existing residents.
- raldi 11y agoWhat about the part where it said, "low-income neighborhoods with a lot of new construction have witnessed about half the displacement of similar neighborhoods that haven't added much new housing"? In other words, building more market-rate housing in a neighborhood helps keep that neighborhood's low-income families from getting displaced. Or, to put it another way, the poor are better off when we build housing for the rich (than when we don't build housing for anyone).
- pennyless 11y agoThere is nothing in the article to justifying the headline. What the headline should have said is "more expensive housing keeps the prices of the expensive housing lower". While true, this has absolutely no reflection on the affordability, the latter being dependent on things like level of income and such. If the cheap housing is removed to be converted to expensive, there is less cheap housing, and it becomes less accessible, because more poor compete for it.
- myohan 11y agowhat about the rich foreigners buying up the new development for the rich to park their money
- scotty79 11y agoThey don't rent what they bought? That seems dumb from investment perspective.
- avuserow 11y agoSome don't, and it can make sense. If you rent it out, then you have to be a landlord, which puts you on the hook for repairs, finding tenants, and collecting rent or evicting them. There's always the possibility of tenants trashing the unit to a large degree. Some of these problems become way worse when left untreated for a week, a month, or longer. I can imagine it making sense for foreign investors to leave units empty in these circumstances. In a similar vein, it's not just foreign investors. It might also make sense to leave the grandparent's house empty while they are in the nursing home if you live further away. If the grandparents don't need to sell the house to pay for retirement, you'd probably come off cheaply enough to leave it empty, pay the property tax and minimal utilities, rather than risk having tenants.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoIf the units are left empty with no supervision, won't they get squatters? If they pay for supervision, they might as well pay for someone to serve as landlord.
- scotty79 11y ago> you have to be a landlord, which puts you on the hook for repairs, finding tenants, and collecting rent or evicting them I imagine that there are companies that do exactly that for you taking percentage of rent you'd get if you done all that by yourself. I also imagine there are insurances for landlords and/or investors. There's so much money in this when you approach this as investments (as opposed to not renting your grandfather house because it's too much of a bother to clean it out and think about) that I imagine no sane investor lets their property, they just bought to stand empty.
- mc32 11y agoMy hope would be the supervisors for The Mission district as well as Chinatown in SF would read this and take notice. But... given their politics, even if they came to understand it, I don't think they'd come around on this, to the detriment of those they purport to represent. The politics in SF are weird. Many politicians do superficially irrational things --they look good on the surface, but in effect they are detrimental. On the bright side, the mayors themselves have been rational about attracting business and bringing in development. If you listen to KQED and their local reporters, it's like they'd like to have SF frozen in time in 1992. As if they'd rather it go down the way of Detroit rather than it become an economic center on the Pacific with the effects they bring ("gentrification" population moves, etc.) They want to eat their cake and have it too. And I understand it. It's very attractive. Let's have a great economy BUT let's have it so all other things stay the same, no disruption, no changes to neighborhoods, etc. Not even China can pull that off. Especially when SF proper is all but 49sq mi. But if we will it that way hard enough...
- rmason 11y agoI do not think that San Francisco can in any way be compared to the decline of Detroit. Poor civic planning, racism and the loss of jobs to non-union Southern plants all paid a part in Detroit's population dropping by two thirds over a fifty year span. I read a great book over Christmas, Once in a great city by David Maraniss, which covered Detroit at its peak from 1962-1964. Wayne State actually pretty accurately predicted the city's future then but the report was ignored by those in a position to stem its decline.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mc32 11y agoYou're right, it's not the same. Detroit is a remarkable exception. But, SF in the late 80's early 90's was not a place you might think would grow. People were leaving the city for other bay area cities. Labor intensive industries were leaving [bedding for one] SOMA, Tenderloin, Market were severely depressed areas. And companies can go --just like they left Detroit; just like they left SF in the late 80s early 90s.
- rahim00 11y agohi
- rahim00 11y agohi
- obrero 11y agoThe language in this is Orwellian. She talks about how new construction is needed and how people are stopping it. Then she points to examples where people are not stopping it, just not letting developers do whatever they want (the dangerous junk developers build near me is insane), then she goes back to saying we need more housing. No working class housing groups are trying to stop new buildings. They're just asking for the same things groups like these have asked for almost a century. Article translation: "Hack employee of the Washington Post Co. says wealthy parasite developers and trustafarian transplants should ignore everything long time, mostly working class black people want, they don't matter". Well why not, that's the same message we've been hearing in this election campaign all year.
- raldi 11y ago> No working class housing groups are trying to stop new buildings. Ahem: http://www.savethemission.org/save_the_mission_district_yes_on_prop_i_endorsements http://www.savethemission.org/save_the_mission_district_yes_...
- kincardine 11y agoExtremely misleading headline. The poor are better off when there isn't a housing shortage, because (surprise, surprise) the rich aren't the ones who are going to be forced out.
- raldi 11y agoYou say the headline is misleading, but you seem to be arguing the same point as it. Could you go into more detail about why you feel it's misleading?
- ryankupyn 11y agoIt's only misleading in the sense that it would better to say "The poor are better off when we build more housing of any sort, even if they can't afford the units being built."
- bostik 11y agoI'd say the title omits an important context. Let's see how it looks like if I add a few extra specifiers.. "The poor are better off when we constantly build more than enough housing for the rich." The last paragraphs actually point that out, albeit in a slightly reversed manner. As long as high-end housing supply is continuously being satisfied, the more aged buildings become affordable even without 95% percentile incomes. On the other hand, I do find it somewhat insulting that the figures assume a time window of 50-60 years. This kind of approach ignores a crucial externality: if it takes ~3 generations of neglect to see the problem, it also takes another ~3 to repair it. Even assuming a perfect 180-degree flip in housing, zoning and transit policies, that's a century lost to bad decisions and blind greed. And in the meanwhile, the city is pricing itself out. I'm not a historian, but I sure would like to know a bit more. Has any great city survived 100 years of exodus? Dislaimer: I live in (Greater) London.
- ethbro 11y agoCan't take a purportedly urban planning article seriously when it doesn't explicitly mention zoning and density. "More housing" is a pretty fluff summary of the intricacies of building sustainable neighborhoods.
- known 11y agoSounds like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- timr 11y agoFunny thing about this theory: the luxury housing market in San Francisco is in decline, and yet, it's still a seller's market for middle- and down-market properties. [1][2] This is not surprising to anyone who follows real estate. There's no such thing as "a market for housing" -- there are several markets, each moving more-or-less independently, based on the net worth of the participants involved. A drop in the prices of units in the Millenium Tower doesn't have much of an impact on the rent of a pre-war hovel in the Mission. The reason that the author doesn't understand this is because there's a latent correlation at play: the communities with the most high-end construction tend to have the most construction overall. But in a city like SF, where all of the new construction would be high-end (if so allowed), all bets are off. Observing that properties become cheaper as they age is also silly. There are some properties that become cheaper as they age, but there aren't many of them, say, in Pac Heights. [1] http://wolfstreet.com/2015/11/08/san-franciscos-luxury-condo-bubble-turns-into-condo-glut/ http://wolfstreet.com/2015/11/08/san-franciscos-luxury-condo... [2] http://sfist.com/2015/11/09/at_high_end_sfs_housing_market_fina.php http://sfist.com/2015/11/09/at_high_end_sfs_housing_market_f...
- reality_czech 11y agoNot a problem. Just move the poors to Flint and keep SF as low-density housing for uber-douches.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]