2 ms·
> I've always taken "turtles all the way down" to mean the fixation that Lisp/Forth/Scheme/Smalltalk/etc... people get about implementing everything in their la
by raganwald 19y ago
> I've always taken "turtles all the way down" to mean the fixation that Lisp/Forth/Scheme/Smalltalk/etc... people get about implementing everything in their language of choice
That's how I take it as well. I wrote this to point out that Turtles all the way down languages make it easier to make consistent languages. I get that you don't care for that.
> Turtles all the way down is a philosophy where you try to define a ridiculously minimal set of orthogonal axioms and build the language by combining those axioms...
> But the advantage of having everything in the language built on top of a small set of axioms is that when you want to make a new feature possible, it's often just a case of burrowing down a level of abstraction and combining the existing things in new ways. For example, it could be as simple as rewriting select to return generalized variables instead of values... if Ruby really treated "=" as a method instead of treating it as a special case that is sometimes a method and sometimes something else and sometimes a third thing.
> Elegant is often a thing to be admired from afar, rather than something you use every day.
"Elegance" sounds like some effete aesthetic quality, there's no point in debating that word. Instead, I am asking you to think about consistency and discoverability, qualities that have a direct relationship to the programmer's ability to translate thought into programs.
- davidw 19y ago> I get that you don't care for that. You're putting words into my mouth. And you and I are talking about different things: > Turtles all the way down is a philosophy where you try to define a ridiculously minimal set of orthogonal axioms and build the language by combining those axioms What I'm talking about is the "my whole environment must be Smalltalk/Scheme/Forth", from the OS, or even silicon, on up. That's different from your version of turtles. Yours is not the enormous waste of time that the "environment turtles" are. However, I'm still not sure whether consistency is really that important. People seem to do ok with some inconsistencies and warts in their languages, and continue to favor languages with warts and weirdnesses and quick idioms to the ones under discussion (incidentally, what could we call Smalltalk/Scheme/Forth to group them together?). Since there are many factors that contribute to popularity and diffusion of languages, it's hard to pin down what has kept those languages from being as popular as many people think they ought to be, but it's a question worth asking. Naturally, I think the more people are aware of languages like that, the better. It's good for your brain and a great way of expanding your concepts of how to do things.
- raganwald 19y ago> > I get that you don't care for that. > You're putting words into my mouth. My bad: I misinterpreted what you meant when you said: > Elegant is often a thing to be admired from afar Any ways... > > Turtles all the way down is a philosophy where you try to define a ridiculously minimal set of orthogonal axioms and build the language by combining those axioms > What I'm talking about is the "my whole environment must be Smalltalk/Scheme/Forth", from the OS, or even silicon, on up. That's different from your version of turtles. Yours is not the enormous waste of time that the "environment turtles" are. Perhaps I'm talking about "turtles most of the way down" and you are talking about "turtles almost all of the way down." I understand why you say what building, say, a Lisp Machine seems like an enormous waste of time. > I'm still not sure whether consistency is really that important. People seem to do ok with some inconsistencies and warts in their languages, and continue to favor languages with warts and weirdnesses and quick idioms to the ones under discussion Are we equating popularity with importance?
- davidw 19y ago> Perhaps I'm talking about "turtles most of the way down" and you are talking about "turtles almost all of the way down." I understand why you say what building, say, a Lisp Machine seems like an enormous waste of time. Your breed of turtles is contained entirely within the language itself, and makes no demands that the language interact with: an OS written in the language, a GUI written in the language, a database written in the language, etc... It's an internal thing if I understand you correctly, and orthogonal to my breed of turtles where people turn their nose up at interacting with anything that's not written in The Language. > Are we equating popularity with importance? I don't know about you, but I am, at least to some degree, although I suppose my phrase might read better as "really all that important to most people" or "that important for many practical applications". I think you're correct about the elegance, simplicity and power of a language built as you describe, but my gut feeling is that, taken as a whole, that kind of power has not been enough to tip the scales in favor of languages that wield it. I'm genuinely curious as to why that is the case. The facile argument revolves around people being "too dumb", but I think that's an easy out for fans of those languages.
- 19y ago