3 ms·
"Peer review "is not falling apart", but it's taken a severe body blow. No longer will anyone be taken seriously who stakes a claim on the basis that it was pee
by timr 17y ago
"Peer review "is not falling apart", but it's taken a severe body blow. No longer will anyone be taken seriously who stakes a claim on the basis that it was peer reviewed."
No, you're exaggerating.
There's a difference between peer-reviewed scientific publication, and what the IPCC does, which is to aggregate and summarize the findings of peer-reviewed scientific publications. And though the panels assembling the IPCC report let through some questionable material, these errors of inclusion neither invalidate the hundreds of other lines of evidence in the reports, nor do they invalidate the system of peer review.
(Also, not incidentally: claiming that the glaciers are melting more slowly than argued in the IPCC report doesn't mean that they're not melting.)
- hga 17y agoWhat I'm referring to when I say "stakes a claim" is a) the sort of thing the IPCC does, science policy, and b) the documented abuse of the peer-review system by ClimateGate conspirators. And that's quite bad, since the point of a fair amount of science is to have real effects on the world at large; both these abuses is going to make that much harder. They could also have bad effects on science funding ... why should people trust such a system? Potentially worse is that this general group of people has been crying wolf since the '60s (no later than the publication of Silent Spring in 1962). One day we might truly face an existential threat and our ability to deal with it will almost certainly be crippled since we've been hearing a "we're all going to die!!!" message for half a century, and we're still here and seem to be doing quite well (e.g. life expectancy is going up).