5 ms·
Interesting - almost every single paragraph of this response is incorrect: <-- I would like to inform you that our website has a 128 bit encryption. With this
by ghshephard 17y ago
Interesting - almost every single paragraph of this response is incorrect:
<--
I would like to inform you that our website has a 128 bit encryption. With this base, passwords that comprise only of letters and alphabets create an algorithm that is difficult to crack. We discourage the use of special characters because hacking softwares can recognize them very easily.
-->
I don't even need to dissect the "hacking software can recognize them very easily" in this forum. They sound like they are suggesting reducing the possible keyspace is a _good_ thing. It isn't. It really, really isn't.
<--
The length of the password is limited to 8 characters to reduce keyboard contact. Some softwares can decipher a password based on the information of “most common keys pressed”.
-->
This one is just so wrong as to make it hard to understand what they are saying. Ironically, _fewer_ keys, make it easier to guess based on the "common keys pressed (4 character passwords on Intercoms are easily guess based on "Wear")
<--
Therefore, lesser keys punched in a given frame of time lessen the possibility of the password being cracked.
-->
Still making no sense.
<--
Moreover, American Express is committed to protecting the privacy and security of all of our Cardmembers, both on-line and off-line. We believe that our current security measures, which include our sophisticated monitoring systems to detect unusual or fraudulent card activity, provide strong, ongoing protections for our Cardmembers.
-->
Nothing to do with passwords, and, based on the previous sentences, doesn't really inspire faith on their Sophisticated Security. I'm not saying amex doesn't have their act together, it's just not coming through in this email.
<--
Rest assured, I have forwarded your comments to our webmaster for review. During this review, we may contact you if additional information is required.
-->
Well, at least there is hope that the "webmaster" may come to their senses.
- Alex3917 17y ago"They sound like they are suggesting reducing the possible keyspace is a _good_ thing." I disagree. If a password is lost on the user side, it's probably going to be due to a keylogger, phishing, or a trojan. Requiring short passwords doesn't make the user any more vulnerable to phishing, and it may make it harder for keyloggers or trojans to identify the password. And since the bank locks your account after three wrong guesses, there is no vulnerability from brute force attacks, especially with an RSA token. The number of people who lose their bank password from shoulder surfing or people noticing keyboard wear is probably virtually zero, so optimizing your system to prevent against these scenarios makes no sense.
- necubi 17y agoThat's great until someone gets access to their user database and is able to crack every password in very little time. Increasing the key space (both through longer passwords and more allowed characters) makes these sorts of attacks far more difficult. And if you think it's unlikely that AmEx will ever lose control of their user database, you clearly have not been paying attention the last few years.
- Alex3917 17y agoCouldn't you just salt the user database with 100 fake accounts for every one real account, so that way as soon as someone tries to log into a fake account the bank knows its system has been compromised?
- dmoney 17y agoThey could block whatever location the fake account was accessed from, but the attacker could try one account each from lots of different locations (perhaps through a botnet). For this to be useful the bank would have to lock all account access from everywhere when a fake one was accessed.
- calcnerd256 17y agoat which point the only thing to say is "denial of service"
- staticshock 17y agoAdditionally, the mined usernames / passwords could still be used to brute force other banking / credit card web sites.
- pingou 17y agoInteresting idea, but you need to save in your database which accounts are fake accounts, so if an hacker get an access to the database he will get this information too, unless this information is saved elsewhere.
- JadeNB 17y agoYou didn't even single out my favourite bit of that: > With this base, passwords that comprise only of letters and alphabets create an algorithm that is difficult to crack. Setting aside the strangely atypical abuse of ‘comprise’ (which does not take a preposition), what in the world does it mean to say that passwords create an algorithm?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Pistos2 17y agoIt can take a preposition, but only in the passive form. Valid: "x comprises y"; "y is comprised of x". Invalid: "x comprises of y".
- JadeNB 17y agoI believe that that is not correct, and that correct usage says that the whole comprises its parts, the parts compose the whole, and the whole is composed of its parts. As with all prescriptions, this is not universally agreed upon; Merriam Webster (the first Google hit for ‘comprise’, at http://www.merriam-webster.com/netdict/comprise http://www.merriam-webster.com/netdict/comprise) says (say?): > Although it has been in use since the late 18th century, sense 3 [the relevant one for this discussion] is still attacked as wrong. Why it has been singled out is not clear …. You should be aware, however, that if you use sense 3 you may be subject to criticism for doing so, and you may want to choose a safer synonym such as compose or make up.
- endtime 17y agoYep. My applied crypto class is laughing about this on our newsgroup. Just awful.
- anamax 17y ago> They sound like they are suggesting reducing the possible keyspace is a _good_ thing. To be fair, while allowing "special characters" increases the possible keyspace, allowing them doesn't significantly increase the likely keyspace because even the people who use them don't use them in the same frequency that they use "normal" characters. There's a difference between 64 random bits and 7 random seven bit quantities with an 8 bit random quantity inserted somewhere in the sequence. The latter is closer to 56 random bits. (Yes, I know that A-Za-z0-9 is not 7 random bits.)