7 ms·
I really hope you're talking about taxes. That's where half of my salary is going to, not to some mythical "evil rich", but to pay for beurocracy and welfare pr
by golergka 11y ago
I really hope you're talking about taxes. That's where half of my salary is going to, not to some mythical "evil rich", but to pay for beurocracy and welfare programs.
- etherael 11y agoPor que no los dos? One is the hand, the other the wallet.
- dragonwriter 11y agoYou see the part of your salary that goes to taxes; less visible is the share of the economic gain produced by your work that doesn't make it into your salary I the first place. The GP was referencing the latter.
- golergka 11y agoMy salary is negotiated on open, highly effective market. Share of my work that goes to the company shareholders represents their investment. If the company fails, I don't risk anything, but they will lose the money they put into the company in the first place. Naturally, if the company succeeds, they have to get capital gains on that investment. The fact that I will be able to get any salary from this company at all will be a direct consequence of a risk that they took upon themselves, not me.
- refurb 11y agoWhy do you assume that an economic gain would automatically be added to someone's salary? Salary is based on supply and demand, not the value you create. That's why an assembly worker building a $20K Ford makes about the same as one building a $100K SUV.
- Tsagadai 11y agoFord makes $776,348 per employee. I will take a stab in the dark and say that the assembly worker is making substantially less than that regardless of whether it is $20k or $100k car while still producing far more value than the cost of either vehicle. http://csimarket.com/stocks/singleEfficiencyet.php?code=F http://csimarket.com/stocks/singleEfficiencyet.php?code=F
- 1123581321 11y agoThat is revenue. Revenue per employee can be a useful measure, but usually it's better to look at net income since industries have varying levels of expenses. Ford's net income in 2015 was about $40,000 per employee. That's healthy, but low enough, when you consider that multiple employees and systems are involved in the design, production and sale of vehicles, that the less profitable vehicle lines need to be cost controlled to stay in production.
- refurb 11y agoAs already mentioned, that is revenue, not profit. If you take $1000 worth of material (costs) and make something you can sell for $2000 (price), then you've created $1000 in value, not $2000. My point is that the value created by a worker doesn't define the salary (although it creates a cap, you can pay more than value created). A great example are lawyers. With the glut of lawyers out there, a lot of lawyers are getting paid less than $50K/yr. I would argue the work they do is worth more than that, but since there are so many lawyers chasing so many jobs, salaries fall.
- tome 11y ago> you can pay more than value created "can't", presumably.
- dragonwriter 11y agoI'm pretty sure that what I said not only does not assume that economic gains would automatically be reflected in salary, but indeed that it's entire premise is that economic gains from work are often not, automatically or otherwise, reflected in salary but instead captured by capital. Maybe you'd like to ask a sensible question?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Retric 11y agoMy taxes are inflated so rich can pay a lower percentage than I do or even just skim off the government. Beyond that, my Rent and healthcare costs are ridiculously inflated, but you can find a lot of padding in other areas. FYI even just at the federal level things are effed up. 33.9% of taxes collected are payroll taxes, but social security caps at ~120k. Hint it's just a tax, you can receive benifits without ever working and millions on disability are simply pulled off welfare rolls.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- golergka 11y agoI'm not from US, please stop assuming it about HN readers already. Also, the percentage of income as basis for tax doesn't make any sense. I don't pay a percentage of income for broadband or Netflix or insurance, why should payment for government services be different?
- thecage411 11y agoA decent analogy for most governments is that they behave similarly to an insurance company with an army. You absolutely pay a percentage of the value of what you are insuring (here your life, wealth, earning potential) not a flat fee.
- darkr 11y agoBecause taxes aren't a personal payment for government services for yourself. You're paying into a shared fund on a capacity basis so that _everyone_ can have access to those services.
- refurb 11y agoTop 1% of income earners pay 50% of all federal income taxes collected. What would you consider a "fair" share of the top 1%'s wealth?
- thatcat 11y ago
- DenisM 11y agoI know a guy in a project that generates a few millions per employee. His share is less than 10% in salary. In this case the discrepancy is easy to see, but the same is true in many other places where it's not so obvious. But we can see it in the big picture, statistically half the money in the country goes to the 0.01% or something along those lines. All the gains from productivity went to the super-rich. It doesn't make a lot of sense for you to keep your eyes fixed on taxes and welfare when there is a lot more money at stake. But it makes a lot of sense for the super-rich to ensure that you keep doing it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gigigufuch 11y agoSpend some time tracking who gets what from the government, directly through tax subsidies, and indirectly from fed zirp policies, its total kleptocracry. Special laws, ie you're now mandated to purchase healthcare, special barriers to entry, copyright give aways etc etc, the rich get super rich through government corruption.
- sokoloff 11y agoI believe that an employer should make a substantial margin on an employee's labor. That provides a stable situation, covers for the employer's risk (if an employee's project/work fails to create value, they still get paid), and covers the overhead. If you want full value (which might be zero or negative at times) for your labor, you should start your own thing and keep 100% of the value you create. If my employer wasn't making at least 3x (and ideally more like 5x) the total cost they were spending on me, I'd start worrying about the stability and longevity of that relationship. (So far, very happily employed there almost 13 years and no end in sight.)
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago> I believe that an employer should make a substantial margin on an employee's labor. That provides a stable situation, covers for the employer's risk (if an employee's project/work fails to create value, they still get paid), and covers the overhead. A workers' cooperative can do the same job. What justifies the privatization of the cooperative's profits to a single individual?
- devishard 11y agoYou realize that if the rich paid the same percentage of their income that you pay, you'd pay drastically less taxes? And that a lot of your taxes go to the evil rich?
- golergka 11y agoAnd if I just rob other people, I would get their money and not pay any taxes at all. So?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- devishard 11y agoIf you were robbing people and paying no taxes I'd want the government to do something about it. Likewise when the rich rob everyone and pay no taxes I want the government to do something about it.
- maxxxxx 11y agoI don't know about your situation for most people the salary increases of the last 30 or so years have gone to the "rich".
- minikites 11y agoTaxes are lower now than at any point in the last 100 years.