3 ms·
There's a very simple answer: the middle class pays very low income taxes in America. Nearly all of the income tax burden is on the top 25%. If you want to shut
by adventured 11y ago
There's a very simple answer: the middle class pays very low income taxes in America. Nearly all of the income tax burden is on the top 25%. If you want to shuttle over half the population into a new single payer health insurance system, they're almost all going to be a (big) net drain. It's an inherent consequence of a highly progressive tax system.
Your typical middle class single person is now spending $300 to $400 per month on health insurance (employer sponsored is closer to $100 per month, but that's merely subsidization), and you want to shift them into single payer, then you have to recover that $300 to $400 via taxation.
The median in the US has an effective income tax of about 3% to 5%. Put another way, putting all of that toward their new single payer insurance, wouldn't come close to covering how much they'll cost you (and that's before getting into family cost structures).
- kefka 11y ago> the middle class pays very low income taxes in America Citation needed. There's "fees", "taxes" and all sorts of hidden ways that eat into the middle class. Not only that, but how much "Fees" were in the eggs you bought? None, right? Not really: they're just bundled in and hidden. Ever get a speeding ticket? That's a fucking tax. Property tax, car "license plates" - tax. Gas has taxes, and a lot of them. As does alcohol. And then there's sales tax- just because you sold something. Hell, there's taxes for dying. But myopically, it looks small. I'd wager that these 'little bits' here and there by far exceeds the percent paid in taxes than the top 1%.. and we know it hurts the middle class far worse.
- refurb 11y agoThe top 10% (over $125K/yr) pay 70% of all income tax in the US. In 1990, it was 55%.[1] [1]http://www.ntu.org/foundation/page/who-pays-income-taxes http://www.ntu.org/foundation/page/who-pays-income-taxes
- kefka 11y agoBut they at most work with IRS numbers regarding federal income tax. Lets be real here: any money that's leaving my pocket that goes towards "compliance", "fees", "fines", "tickets", or what have you is Tax. Now, I don't have a problem with tax itself (as a concept). I get that services need to be paid for, and that's us. But what I want to know, is out of my paycheck, how much really is taxed? No one can answer that.
- vorotato 11y agohighly progressive compared to what?