13 ms·
Why are Americans so angry?
- yasth 11y agoThe data [1] is pretty noisy, but dissatisfaction with "the way things are going in the US" is pretty common in (presidential) election years. This shouldn't be shocking, all of the media is basically talking about how things are going wrong. [1]http://www.gallup.com/poll/1669/general-mood-country.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/1669/general-mood-country.aspx
- mtviewdave 11y agoI don't see how the page you linked to supports your thesis. It doesn't call out, or even discuss, election years. 1996 looks to be better than 1993, 1984 better than 1981.
- mc32 11y agoIt's better for people to be angry and express frustration such as through occupy, blm, rural anti federal blm, anti open borders, etc., rather than allow things to simmer unnoticed and then suddenly erupt. These movements allow politicians who want to take notice to do so and address grievances slowly with input and participation from others, so that the outcomes are at least marginally palatable, rather than intractable.
- davidw 11y agoIt'd be even better if they did whatever they were doing peacefully, without guns. That armed refuge occupation here in Oregon is costing a ton of money.
- humanrebar 11y agoIt's odd that you call that out as violent and not the demonstrations in Ferguson.
- davidw 11y agoPeople rioting are not good. People demonstrating peacefully have a right to, even groups like the KKK, much as I despise them. Sometimes bad stuff happens on the fringes of mostly peaceful demonstrations when there are a lot of people involved, and emotions run high. I didn't follow the events in Ferguson as much, as I was still living in Italy. The refuge takeover is 2 hours east of me, so I've followed it more closely, and there was never anything peaceful about how those guys showed up armed to the teeth. It's a threat, no matter how much you say that it's not. Especially in light of some of the stuff they did: see the FBI complaint about how they threatened a woman wearing a BLM shirt, saying they knew where she lived.
- doktrin 11y agoWhat's odd is that you immediately try to insinuate some kind of nefarious bias because s/he didn't cite an incident that lines up with your political leanings. The parent is clearly in Oregon, so it's not exactly super duper weird that they mentioned a recent, relevant action in their own back yard.
- humanrebar 11y agoIt's odd that you went straight for "nefarious". I didn't actually think that at all. I assumed cognitive dissonance, actually. Mostly because everyone experiences it, myself included. I think I was mostly vindicated. We tend to assign more importance to events that are both recent and geographically close to ourselves. The events in Ferguson or the shooting at the clinic in Colorado probably had more of an affect on the collective American psyche.
- double0jimb0 11y agoI wonder why "Bathed in pervasive, inescapable advertising scientifically tuned to elicit feelings of inadequacy while being bombarded by fear-driven news/politics" didn't make this list?
- jschwartzi 11y agoPresumably because inadequacy and fear are so fundamental to our identity now that few people question it's source.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hcho 11y agoKnee jerk reaction? The main target of that page is the UK, where BBC do not display any ads.
- tedks 11y agoThe article is still a listicle. It's tuned for clickbait and for short attention spans.
- baldfat 11y agoI find BBC to be low on the click bait usage. I do find it crazy how angry my fellow Americans feel. I seriously think 1/3 of my friends think Obama is going to declare martial law and stop all elections so he can be in power for longer. I explain he can't wait to be done with this mess.
- onion2k 11y agoThat wouldn't be unique to Americans.
- uhtred 11y agoThis. I moved to the US recently, and I must say advertising is on another level here. Also the news, especially local channels, is so over the top. They had a report on a car that drove off a bridge (it didn't hit any pedestrians), and they then had a "passer by" saying she was now too scared to walk outside.
- onetwotree 11y agoThe really shocking bit of data is near the end -- many Americans would be deeply upset if their child were to marry someone of the opposite political party. This is making politics way too personal! I'm not sure how the country is going to recover from this state of polarization. The media isn't helping, and none of the current crop of political candidates seem to be addressing the need to rebuild the American consensus held in past generations, although this might change once the primaries are over.
- hnal943 11y agoThe only way out I can see is to make government small enough (or homogeneous enough) that one's opinion doesn't matter much. That's the way it was in America for much of the 20th century - there wasn't much difference between the major political parties. When people are trying to remake society through the political process, is it any wonder that is polarizing?
- randcraw 11y agoSo how should people remake their country if not through the political process? Through armed rebellion? I'd say that's rather polarizing too. I think the solution goes back to an old civic ideal that's central to a successful democracy. Duty. If Americans dutifully studied the issues, civilly discussed the alternative policies (knowing there must be tradeoffs and delays as different solutions are tested and refined), and participated constructively in the process as if their children's future depended on it, we wouldn't have time to bitch and moan. And we'd rightly shame those who do for being childish and useless.
- humanrebar 11y ago> there wasn't much difference between the major political parties That's not my understanding of 20th century politics at all. You'll need to elaborate on what qualifies as "much difference". Roe V. Wade, for example, happened right in the middle of the 20th century.
- Trill-I-Am 11y ago
- mturmon 11y agoFear. Fear of being left behind by the economy, fear of being encroached on by immigrants, fear of terrorist attack. Not all fears are justified and proportional, but it's easy to turn them to anger.
- arethuza 11y agoI'm sure I read a study a while back that found that people who have "right wing" views are more afraid - and this certainly agrees with my experiences in the UK (particularly Daily Mail readers). The US is rather more "right wing" than places like the UK so perhaps that leads to more fear? And as the wee green beastie said: "Fear leads to anger, anger leads to hate, hate.. to suffering ..." Edit: I think this is it: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2014/07/biology-ideology-john-hibbing-negativity-bias http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2014/07/biology-ideology... "political conservatives have a "negativity bias," meaning that they are physiologically more attuned to negative (threatening, disgusting) stimuli in their environments."
- andyjohnson0 11y ago"A number of studies have found that biology may be linked with political orientation. This means that biology is a possible factor in political orientation, but may also mean that the ideology a person identifies with changes a person's ability to perform certain tasks." [1] How cognitive biases affect our interpretation of political messages [2] "There is considerable evidence that people presented with balanced arguments place weight on those they already agree with, exhibiting what is termed confirmation bias." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biology_and_political_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biology_and_political_orientat... [2] http://users.ox.ac.uk/~chri3110/Details/P460%20Cognitive%20biases%20BMJ.pdf http://users.ox.ac.uk/~chri3110/Details/P460%20Cognitive%20b...
- flubert 11y agoYou may also enjoy: http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2008/09/either_conservatives_are_cowar.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2008/09/either_conservatives_...
- 11y ago
- russnewcomer 11y agoMaybe I'm just too skeptical of these types of stories coming from generic polling, but I will say that I don't have a high degree of confidence in polling done by random phone calls (the CNN/ORC poll listed says that on page 14 [1]). My wife frequently answers the political poll questions when people call, in part because she feels sorry for the poller. Answering those calls can take 15-30 minutes. So you're depending on the results of people who have 15-30 minutes to answer 35 questions about the government. I feel like there's a selection bias at work there already, and you're assuming that people will give thoughtful answers to the questions, that the order of questions doesn't affect responses, etc, etc, etc. You're depending on 1018 people who actually may not be statistically relevant, since America is a big, big country, to drive your thinking on that country. Plus, would the responses to the surveys be different if the word 'disappointed' was used instead of angry? And would the perception of the responses be different? Secondarily, and this is far more anecdotal, but I am friends with a fairly wide swath of people via social media, from conservatives to libertarians to liberals to progressives. The key takeaway that I have from watching all of their posting and all of their interactions is that people are angry at others. And people have always been easily angered by others, it's just that the modern American landscape allows for a) easier access to others and b) easier access to well-written, rational condemnation of others than can be easily shared. But reading through my feed, Maybe Americans aren't actually angry, but since it's easier to construct understandable stories using language like anger, Americans feel like they should be angry? [1]http://edition.cnn.com/2015/12/29/politics/cnn-orc-poll-full-results-obama-approval/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2015/12/29/politics/cnn-orc-poll-full...
- ksk 11y agoIts nice to have healthy skepticism for these kinds of things, but I don't think we as laypeople know more about polling than the polling organizations whose job it is to eliminate biases with regards to the verbiage of questions and sampling. A lot of this stuff is based on well established models and prior theories.
- russnewcomer 11y agoWell, I am personally skeptical that those well-established models and prior theories are a) being followed and b) as effective as thought. More a) than b). But my greater skepticism comes from basing policy or expectations of a country on simplifications. Again, I wonder if they asked the same number of people if the same questions and subbed out disappointed for angry if they would get a significantly different response?
- buckbova 11y agoRidiculous hit piece based on dubious poll results. There's a lot of angry people in this world. I remember quite a bit rioting in France, revolting in Syria, revolting in the Ukraine, etc. > When asked if they trust the government, 89% of Republicans and 72% of Democrats say "only sometimes" or "never" . . . I'm in the never group and for obvious reasons. Governments abuse the power we give them. And that doesn't make me angry, but smart.
- wvenable 11y agoIt's part of American heritage to not trust their government but I think that leads to a spiral of terrible government. It's a self-fulfilling prophesy. In other countries, people actually demand their government be effective and useful. In the US, it's just expected that it won't be.
- tedks 11y agoPart of the American heritage going back to Nixon, maybe.
- DanBC 11y agoYou might want to compare other indicators of anger. US has high murder rate, for example.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- buckbova 11y agoDoesn't look to be anywhere near the highest. South America and Africa seem pretty darn angry. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate#By_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention...
- rrauenza 11y agoBecause it's the narrative the media can use to generate interest and clicks --> https://medium.com/@parkermolloy/5-things-the-media-does-to-manufacture-outrage-ba79125e1262#.53cm4mmsk https://medium.com/@parkermolloy/5-things-the-media-does-to-...
- bbarn 11y agoThey left off the number one reason I think people are angry - the feeling of being powerless to change any of the examples given.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoThe article does a good job hitting several 'topics' in the conversation, which is a reasonable place to start. As a collective emotional response, "anger" in the US population likely has a lot to do with rapidly changing social adaptations, acceptance, and transition which is frequently in direct conflict with traditional identity values - thus, a pretty understandable survey answer. Start broadening the perspective to include economic conditions (inequality, labor force participation) and it's not really a pleasing long-term outlook on an intellectual level. For some reason, I can't quite shake the mental image of a cornered rat - its survival instinct response might be classified as 'anger' but the context and conditions are relevant in the grand scheme of things.
- rms_returns 11y agoAs a non-US citizen who just casually observes US news like an outsider, I can think of the below reasons: 1. The technology industry and EFF is very upset because of the ongoing patent-trolls issue. Only recently, a technoloy company was extracted of $625 million by the East Texas jury. Similarly, Oracle is trolling over its Java patent on a matter as trivial as the Java API. These two incidents are enough for the technology community to lose faith in POTUS/SCOTUS. 2. The second group which is not happy is the entire populace who like an open market and free competition. Power users who understand it know that Net-neutrality is harming it a lot. Again, POTUS/SCOTUS is not listening to this problem, but has turned a blind eye to it. As an outsider, my assessment could very well be observed, but I do think that these issues have enough potential to cause a feeling of anger and distrust in a lot of Americans (if not all). Ignorance or inactivity on part of POTUS/SCOTUS is only going to aggravate it.
- golergka 11y ago> The second group which is not happy is the entire populace who like an open market and free competition. What? Since when did US blue collar workers liked open markets and free competition with their 3rd world counterparts?
- Zikes 11y agoThis list is rather incomplete. As an American, I'm angry because: 1. I'm 31 years old and not even halfway through paying off my student loans. 2. I can have anything taken away from me at any time with little to no legal recourse. 3. My constitutional right to privacy and to refuse unreasonable searches no longer exists. 4. If I am ever charged with a crime, I will face a justice system that is entirely stacked against me, and regardless of the crime or my guilt I will be coerced into agreeing to a plea bargain. 5. A cop could shoot me in the back in broad daylight, on film, with witnesses, and most likely only wind up with a paid vacation as punishment. 6. If I ever become suspect in a crime of national security I will likely be tortured, physically and psychologically, for years at a time. 7. My government is torturing people right now, and the most I can ever hope to do about it is to eventually elect someone that will put a stop to it. 8. My government is supporting the monopolization of internet services and suppressing initiatives to make internet service fair and reasonably priced. 9. Every new copyright law is designed to further suppress fair use. 10. Institutionalized bribery and corruption at every level of government means that without money, my voice will likely never be heard.
- dev1n 11y agoThis is a nicely written summary of what I feel most of HN understands is wrong with America. However I have never seen it written in such a succinct manner before. And all in one place!
- kenshi 11y agoCurious why this has been downvoted? It is clearly someone expressing their opinion/reasons why they are angry. Whether or not you agree with all the listed items is another matter?
- winkle 11y agoLet's all agree to be happy instead of angry. You can only control your own actions and emotions. Be grateful what you have instead of focusing on what you don't.
- draw_down 11y agoThe way our country works, it becomes harder and harder for normal people to get by. Some Americans think this is the fault of immigrants. Some have other ideas.
- jqm 11y agoWeren't Americans (or at least their ancestors) generally dissatisfied with their lot in the first place and that's why they became Americans? I don't know that dissatisfaction and mistrust is genetic but I'm guessing it probably gets passed on culturally, at least to some extent.
- tedks 11y agoWeren't British (or at least their ancestors) generally dissatisfied with their lot in the first place and that's why they wrote the Magna Carta? I don't know that dissatisfaction and mistrust is genetic but I'm guessing it probably gets passed on culturally, at least to some extent.
- GizaDog 11y agoThe common rule is that "no one thinks the same thing" unless there is a traumatic mind altering event that aligns people for a short period of time. Media, government, corporations, friends and family are all competing for attention to some degree. Puppet masters know this all to well.
- tosseraccount 11y agoC'mon. The number one point was stagnant median income for last 35 years. Do all the projection of your ideological biases and deconstruct the article to fit your views that you want to. Bottom line is change hasn't helped the middle class wallet. It's no wonder people are backing Trump and Sanders. The establishment just doesn't get it.
- newobj 11y agoOh god, let the HN theorycrafting begin.
- ohitsdom 11y agoWE'RE NOT
- mjevans 11y agoOne point that the BBC article doesn't cover is where exactly the 'middle ground' is. The language is still framed from an entirely American Politics perspective of there being two parties and no other reference points. Lost is the fact that both American parties are fairly far to the right. Also lost among the message of anger is the point that they glossed past. The 'Washington' (DC) insiders /are/ the political parties.
- arca_vorago 11y agoThey partially answer their own question, with... "seems to only be working for the insiders with money and power, like those on Wall Street or in Washington," They key point they are missing out on though is that because the corruption and cronyism is more blatant, more Americans are starting to realize how pervasive it has become and that justice isn't being served on behalf of the people. 08 crash and libor scandals are a perfect example. People should have been in jail, companies nationalized, assets frozen and investigated for frauds, the SEC pumped up, and a AG and various DA's should have gone into frenzy attack mode... but they didn't, because they were part of the insider group! By undermining justice, and hence, our Constitution, the public will increasingly become agitated because without justice there can be no peace. Here is the danger though (warning, put your tinfoil on), I think that what is being done is a systematic corruption of our countries constitution in order to pave the way for the global governance model. When things get worse, and puppets for the elite will start talking about how America is a young country and had it's chance and it's model is failing and therefor it should just join a EU model supranational government structure, thats when you will know that the state of our country is only half due to incompetence, hubris, or apathy, and that the it is a deliberate strategy being employed by the AngloSaxon dominance group who honestly I don't think ever forgave America for the revolution. Britain isn't the ally we think she is, mark my words.
- IanDrake 11y agoI hate to see how race (as percentage of population) gets mentioned under the topic of immigration, as if the two are inextricably linked or represent our general anger. I live in New England where (IMO) race tends to matter little, however culture still matters a great deal. In fact, I'd say that we have a major cultural battle going on in the US. The media has seen fit to assign cultures to races, but that's just for convenience at great cost to the rest of us. Even worse, I fear that many of the cultures at war want the exact same thing, but don't agree how to achieve it. In any event, the media is doing a fine job of radicalizing people based on race and income, neither of which represent cultural beliefs. For example, I think we need to teach everyone how to speak English properly and you may think that's aimed at Hispanics. But it's not. It's aimed at people who speak gangster, girls and boys who can stop saying "like" every other word, and yes, all manner of other people who can't speak proper English. Just like the Internet has common communication protocols, so must citizens for our nation to succeed. We all want our nation to be healthy, which is our common cause, and this is one thing I think would help. When framed in this way, it's not about "those Mexican immigrants speaking Spanish" it's about everyone who can't participate in our economy because they're communication skills are lacking.
- ycombo500 11y agoMiddle class america is in a reverse depression - every other class is doing quite well.
- ycombo500 11y agoMiddle class america is in a reverse depression - every other class is doing quite well.
- dawnbreez 11y agoMy two cents: One, we are terrible at handling relationships, and emotions in general. A lot of psychological research is basically ignored, and we're talking basic stuff--things like how depression happens, how to handle anger, what a bad relationship looks like. Second, we're in the unusual position of believing that we're economically and socially mobile--that the poor can become rich--and also being constantly given examples of how hard it still is. We chase an American Dream of being the self-made, self-sustaining free human being, but are constantly reminded that failure sits just behind us and that even the best of friends can trip you up. On that note, we're also terrible at coping with failure.
- aaroninsf 11y agoThere is only one two word answer on the national scale: income inequality. The dysfunction of current capital accumulation is driving roiling discontent: witness the 'unlikely' (not) success of Trump and Sanders. Prediction: it's going to get worse before it gets better. The drama IMHO this go around is that last time we had a populist backlash (100 yeas ago), it was not actively monitored and suppressed by a comprehensive suite of behavior analysis and sentiment management professionals. I predict the existence of those things now is going to keep the lid on the pot a lot longer than previously. When it does blow off, it might be a lot more destructive. Where we once had a boiling pot, now we have a pressure cooker. As with other systemic ills (e.g. climate change), the individual players are trapped in the necessity of maximizing for their perceived local best outcome... unable, even when very aware of it, to accept short term or proactive losses in the service of avoiding a catastrophic systemic failure... Interesting times, etc. :(