9 ms·
The problem here stems from two things: 1) Net metering means that the power company is required to buy electricity at retail rates from their customers instea
by jedberg 11y ago
The problem here stems from two things:
1) Net metering means that the power company is required to buy electricity at retail rates from their customers instead of wholesale rates, which puts quite a burden on them. Why should they have to buy at a higher rate?
2) Electric companies for decades have been rolling the cost of transmission into the variable rate portion of people's bills. This means that larger consumers (who tend to be richer) have been subsidizing the poorer customers. This is generally considered a good thing by most, since it allows poorer people to have electricity (because you don't want to live in a society where some people have electricity and some don't). The solution here is to raise the fixed portion of the bill to cover the true cost of transmission, and then place a tax on those who go "off grid" to straight out subsidize the poor, so it's more obvious that is what is happening (And presumably most people would still support).
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The solution here is to raise the fixed portion of the bill to cover the true cost of transmission, and then place a tax on those who go "off grid" to straight out subsidize the poor, so it's more obvious that is what is happening (And presumably most people would still support). Its going to be untenable to tax someone for no longer using the electric utility (I'm revolted by that idea personally, and am pretty far left bleeding liberal). You could possibly further subsidize low income electric consumers to have their own system installed using the federal general fund (solar installations receive a 30% tax credit; it might be possible to increase that credit to 50%-75% depending on your adjusted gross income, and have it be a rebate immediately applied at the time of system install).
- jedberg 11y ago> Its going to be untenable to tax someone for no longer using the electric utility (I'm revolted by that idea personally, and am pretty far left bleeding liberal). Which is amusing, because you already pay the tax in the form of variable rate usage pricing that is higher than it needs to be. This is the problem with making hidden subsidies explicit -- people suddenly don't like the subsidy anymore.
- jstanley 11y agoIf somebody is off-grid and not using the electric utility, they aren't paying any electric bill, so the variable rate is irrelevant?
- jedberg 11y agoThat's the problem they're trying to fix with this change. As the wealthy, higher consumption customers move off grid, they system as a whole is loosing the subsidies for the poor. Even if you have solar, they power company still have to maintain transmission lines to your house and to the houses of poor people, which was being subsidized by they rich's usage. So they are trying to stem the tide of the rich leaving by making them continue to bear the cost of subsidizing the poor. Instead of playing games with those on solar, they should just straight up call it what it is so it is more explicit.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- crdoconnor 11y ago>So they are trying to stem the tide of the rich leaving by making them continue to bear the cost of subsidizing the poor. No, they're trying to prevent competition. They run power plants too, and they'd rather you bought electricity from them rather than sold it to them. That's why none of the power companies are advocating just removing the implicit environmental subsidy and allowing power to be sold back to them at wholesale rate. They just want solar panels gone, period.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- prostoalex 11y agoHow would this work in practice? Let's say I have a piece of land with a shed / cabin / old RV on it that's currently not using electricity, so there's no ongoing relationship with the utility company. If I were to place a solar panel on top of (or a diesel generator, or some kind of car battery hookup), there's a sudden requirement to start sending monthly checks to some entity?
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>Its going to be untenable to tax someone for no longer using the electric utility (I'm revolted by that idea personally, and am pretty far left bleeding liberal). How is that worse than any other tax? You make a choice and the government charges you for making that choice.
- nostrademons 11y agoCustomers have had to buy electricity from power companies at retail rates rather than wholesale rates since forever. Why should they have to buy at a higher rate?
- jedberg 11y agoFor a couple of reasons. - They aren't transmitting it, which has a cost. They aren't providing value add like the power company. - They could pay wholesale if they figured out a way to get the electricity from the power plant to their house, which is the value add that the power company provides. - They have a choice in how much they buy, by turning things on and off. The power company, being a regulated utility, does not have that choice. They must buy as much as is demanded.
- vox_mollis 11y agoObviously because the utility provides the somewhat important role of actually transmitting and distributing the power in question. Magic faeries don't hand out rights-of-way, substations, 150kv switchyards, transformers, capacitors, conductors, pole provisioning, pylons, transfer switches, and the maintenance of all of the above for free. Net metering is stealing from those who provide the distribution infrastructure, full stop.
- prostoalex 11y agoNet metering involves buying and selling kWh. If there are fixed infrastructure costs involved, the companies involved should bill for those separately. I buy my car from company A and my gasoline from company B with clear prices for A and B. Why is the scenario where the car company provides my gasoline and then bills for both gasoline and the car in an opaque "single bill" manner, where I can never make out which is which preferable for the consumer?
- rhino369 11y agoNet metering is stealing from those who BUY from the providers of the distribution infrastructure, full stop. Net metering is a subsidy for upper middle class folks who own their houses and want solar panels because it's hip and cool. The costs get directly passed onto the other consumers. The poor and middle class.
- secabeen 11y agoThe history of net metering comes out of the fact that for many years, smart meters for electricity were very expensive, and not widely deployed. As such, net metering was a natural solution to the billing problem. A user who over-produced for their needs would just run the meter backwards during sunny days, and forwards at night, creating a net metering situation. It's only with Smart Meters that the utilities can accurately measure per-house production and consumption separately. It's certainly possible to create new billing plans that take advantage of the Smart Meters, but with the capital nature of solar investments, there's a lot of legacy installs to deal with, and those people get angry when they deal they signed up for is changed without grandfathering them into the old way.
- ju-st 11y agoNo, you can just connect two dumb meters. One counts the energy consumption and the other the production.
- rhino369 11y agoNet metering has always been a subsidy for distributed solar. That's what it's intended as. If you just wanted to account for peak pricing, you could just create a wholesale solar price that estimated average wholesale price for solar in a given area. You could get pretty damn close without having install smart meters.
- fmihaila 11y agoThe conventional wisdom is that rooftop solar stresses the grid, and therefore net metering at retail prices amounts to a subsidy extracted from non-solar customers to the benefit of rooftop solar owners. This, however, is a myth (reinforced at every turn by the incumbent monopolies). Rooftop solar tends to overproduce on the hottest days, which also happens to be the time when the grid is overloaded by air conditioners running at full throttle. In effect, rooftop solar is at maximum production exactly when the grid needs it the most, thus providing very valuable load smoothing. This greatly benefits utilities, since they don’t have to spend as much on peak-generation capacity. There is ample evidence that utilities underpay for these benefits [1], while their profits rapidly increase. Three major Nevada casino operators “have expressed vocal criticism of NV Energy for generating huge profits over the past years and not lowering rates for customers of Nevada Power. [...] NV Energy’s profits increased 27.7% in 2014, yet the supplier has not introduced any electricity rates breaks to its customers since it was acquired by Berkshire Hathaway.“ [2] Over the short term, the incumbents will get their way by flexing their political muscle, but this will only delay the inevitable. Electricity spot prices are at their highest during daytime, while people are at work and their solar generators put power into the grid. Utilities want to pay wholesale for this power, then turn around and sell it to non-solar consumers at the top rate. People return from work as their solar generators become inactive, so they will have to buy power at retail rates. For now, utilities will win both ways. But what this means is that as storage prices drop, it will be more economical to invest in storage capacity in order to capture the valuable power during the day and use it during the night. This will deny utilities the demand-smoothing services that they currently enjoy, so they will have to increase their capex for peak generation, leading to higher rates for everyone else, which in turn will encourage _more_ customers to install solar and storage, etc. Soon after, people will start disconnecting from the grid altogether; welcome to Uber Energy. Tectonic plates accumulate tension slowly, but they rearrange quickly. [1] http://cleantechnica.com/2015/09/01/review-of-net-metering-studies-finds-utilities-underpaying-for-solar-electricity/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/09/01/review-of-net-metering-s... [2] http://www.casinonewsdaily.com/2015/11/26/major-casino-operators-leave-nevadas-main-electric-utility/ http://www.casinonewsdaily.com/2015/11/26/major-casino-opera... [reposted from a previous discussion on the topic because the thread had dropped off the front page when the comment was written]
- dpierce9 11y agoOne reason net-metering is close to fair is that we are talking about delivered electricity. Every unit I send back to the grid is a unit that doesn't need to be delivered by the power company but the power company can sell it to my neighbor for retail price. A second reason net-metering is close to fair is because mid-day units of electricity are more valuable. Solar production peaks midday while household usage is U-shaped, so most production flows out to the grid during the high-price periods. Rates average peak and off-peak pricing so rate customers typically don't see that. In other words, solar production produces high-value kWhs the utility can sell to my neighbor for retail, even though they don't have to generate or deliver it themselves.
- tomp 11y agoI don't understand your logic for "more valuable" - there's more electricity at midday (because sun) and less usage (because sun and people are at work), so more supply & less demand => price drops, not rises!
- supercanuck 11y agoair conditioners in the desert
- dpierce9 11y agoWell in general demand peaks midday while household usage is u-shaped (morning and evening peaks). This makes sense, since when people go to work they are not at home and their work energy use tends to be higher than home energy use. But if you don't like that explanation, simply look at any price curve for any of the organized electricity markets (they are public) and you will see demand and price peaks mid-day.
- tomp 11y agoAha... so do you have a typo in your answer? > Solar production peaks midday should have been > Solar consumption peaks midday ?
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Net metering means that the power company is required to buy electricity at retail rates from their customers instead of wholesale rates, which puts quite a burden on them. Why should they have to buy at a higher rate? It always amuses me when people complain that we're not being "fair" to monopolies. The whole set up isn't fair. There's no market discipline on the transmission side, so there's no point in transmission being privatized at all. It's clearly not politically feasible (yet) to push for nationalization but there's no reason to indulge their whinging either.
- Gibbon1 11y agoOh yeah, low risk business where the government backstops any losses? By rights investors shouldn't expect very high returns. Also yes with power distribution you have long tail network effects that make charging for service using pure market mechanisms essentially impossible. Hint, when the US stopped subsidizing rail by things like land grants and turning a blind eye to graft, they all went bankrupt.
- prostoalex 11y ago> Electric companies for decades have been rolling the cost of transmission into the variable rate portion of people's bills. Perhaps this is the problem, both at ownership and billing level. Why does the utility get to own the power lines instead of the citizens (via local governments and municipalities)? How do you know if utility's claim of the cost of transmission is correct, when they still manage to pay out bonuses to themselves and produce dividends for shareholders? As a consumer you're supposed to blindly trust their statements on costs.
- strommen 11y agoThese are _potential_ problems. They will become real problems when a significant amount of electricity is generated from rooftop solar. That isn't happening yet - according to the article, Nevada has already capped rooftop solar at 3% of peak demand. Net metering needs to be phased out at some point in the future. Not ended abruptly today.
- LordKano 11y agoI think I'm missing something in your position. Why is the solution to tax people who go off grid?
- 7952 11y agoI may be naive, but it would seem more logical to charge consumers solely for the transmission and roll the price of production into that (rather than the other way around). So that the rate you pay per kWh would depend on your proximity to where power is actually being generated on an hourly basis. If you are connected to a substation that is exporting power you would pay less than one that is importing. If energy costs are so dependant on location and distance why don't we actually acknowledge that in the pricing? If your city is not generating energy why should it pay the same price as one that is?
- dpierce9 11y agoIn the US wholesale energy prices are locational and determined by three things: the cost of energy, congestion in the transmission network, and losses in delivery. Retail rates are also locational but principally determined by state-level organizations (Public Utility Commissions) who regulate the natural monopolies who control the distribution network in the state so they are unable to charge monopoly rents. Rate setting in most places is a very political process.