9 ms·
A battle over solar power in Nevada
- zrail 11y agoHaven't finished the article yet, but that animated gif of Warren vs Elon is... something special.
- tylersgordon 11y agoSkip the article, view the gif... http://www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-solar-power-buffett-vs-musk/img/buffett_vs_musk.gif http://www.bloomberg.com/features/2016-solar-power-buffett-v...
- dogma1138 11y agoOr don't unless you want this image for ever burned into your retinas....
- Dwolb 11y agoGosh, I'm surprised and impressed at how non-traditional Bloomberg's digital content is. I've never seen a big name increasingly take these kinds of liberties on a continuing basis.
- Rexxar 11y agoI wonder how they decide which article have such animation. Is it the journalists that ask for an animation or a graphic designer that looks at all articles and propose to add animations to some of them ?
- andrewtbham 11y agoThe long term question here is will solar be distributed or centralized? I think the answer is distributed like the model Elon and solar city are using. It just doesn't makes sense for the old power companies like Buffet's NV Energy to maintain all the transmission lines when the cost of batteries falls.
- fweespeech 11y agoWell, I think it really depends on the economics of grid storage and proximity. For instance, there was someone saying they pay $.10/kwh year round on a thread the other day and it was due to their proximity to grid storage. $.10 to .15/kwh is realistically the range battery technology will be in for the next 10-15 years, barring a major technological change. That simply is not going to be cost effective in many areas. EDIT: Since I can't post... http://www.computerworld.com/article/2977655/sustainable-it/as-energy-push-accelerates-battery-costs-set-to-plunge-60.html http://www.computerworld.com/article/2977655/sustainable-it/... > As energy push accelerates, battery costs set to plunge 60% > Lithium-ion (Li-on) batteries will drop from $550 per kilowatt hour (kWh) in 2014 to $200 per kWh by 2020; and flow battery prices will drop from $680 per kWh to $350 per kWh during the same time. A daily cycle, 5 year battery is still going to be ~$.11/kwh in 2020. You need generation + battery storage [combined] to get into the below $.15/kwh for it to make sense outside of peak June-Sept, 2-7pm times.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> $.10 to .15/kwh is realistically the range battery technology will be in for the next 10-15 years Forgive the lack of citation, but Goldman Sachs just put out a report on Tesla within the last few days, and they're estimating the cost of batteries dropping ~60% over 5 years due to the Gigafactory producing 35GW of storage each year. EDIT: Found it, http://evannex.com/blogs/news/75718469-goldman-sachs-bullish-on-electric-vehicles-tesla-gigafactory-leading-the-charge http://evannex.com/blogs/news/75718469-goldman-sachs-bullish... "Discussing electric vehicle batteries, Goldman reports that: "technological advances play a significant role, growing economies of scale are the key driver of cost reductions. Led by Tesla and Panasonic’s 35GW Gigafactory, battery manufacturers have committed to approximately triple current production capacity over the next five years [Exhibit 36].... Autos analysts forecast the battery range for lower performance EVs to increase by over 70%, while battery costs are expected to fall by more than 60% over the next five years [Exhibit 37].""
- epistasis 11y agoSolid pricing information for large quantities of batteries is hard to get, but GM recently disclosed their price to be $145/kWh, and apparently LG Chem's other customers are paying around ~$100 more/kWh [1]. Is your $0.11/kWh price just for the stored amount at $200/kWh? That conversion factor to kWh-stored prices is more favorable than I've been using, as I've been assuming about ~1000 cycles worth of storage, but then I don't really have a good number for that. Since not all energy will need to be stored, and much (most?) can be used right away, then it will increase the overall cost of energy only by the X% that needs to be stored. So if solar is $0.05/kWh, and 50% can be used right away, then the overall cost for solar + storage would be $0.105/kWh on the generation side. Which is quite competitive already. http://insideevs.com/lg-chem-ticked-gm-disclosing-145kwh-battery-cell-pricing-video/ http://insideevs.com/lg-chem-ticked-gm-disclosing-145kwh-bat...
- jedberg 11y agoThe problem here stems from two things: 1) Net metering means that the power company is required to buy electricity at retail rates from their customers instead of wholesale rates, which puts quite a burden on them. Why should they have to buy at a higher rate? 2) Electric companies for decades have been rolling the cost of transmission into the variable rate portion of people's bills. This means that larger consumers (who tend to be richer) have been subsidizing the poorer customers. This is generally considered a good thing by most, since it allows poorer people to have electricity (because you don't want to live in a society where some people have electricity and some don't). The solution here is to raise the fixed portion of the bill to cover the true cost of transmission, and then place a tax on those who go "off grid" to straight out subsidize the poor, so it's more obvious that is what is happening (And presumably most people would still support).
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The solution here is to raise the fixed portion of the bill to cover the true cost of transmission, and then place a tax on those who go "off grid" to straight out subsidize the poor, so it's more obvious that is what is happening (And presumably most people would still support). Its going to be untenable to tax someone for no longer using the electric utility (I'm revolted by that idea personally, and am pretty far left bleeding liberal). You could possibly further subsidize low income electric consumers to have their own system installed using the federal general fund (solar installations receive a 30% tax credit; it might be possible to increase that credit to 50%-75% depending on your adjusted gross income, and have it be a rebate immediately applied at the time of system install).
- jedberg 11y ago> Its going to be untenable to tax someone for no longer using the electric utility (I'm revolted by that idea personally, and am pretty far left bleeding liberal). Which is amusing, because you already pay the tax in the form of variable rate usage pricing that is higher than it needs to be. This is the problem with making hidden subsidies explicit -- people suddenly don't like the subsidy anymore.
- paulsutter 11y agoIn Germany, wholesale power prices can actually go negative on sunny afternoons. Conditions in the US are trending towards that. Why should actual generators get paid low (or negative) wholesale prices at the exact same moment that some consumer gets paid full retail rates? It doesn't make sense. Very practically, this is illustrated by California's duck curve. Also from Bloomberg: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-10-21/california-s-duck-curve-is-about-to-jolt-the-electricity-grid http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-10-21/california... It has nothing to do with Musk and Buffet. How do you price power, both wholesale and retail, in a way that recognizes that there's a need to provide power even when it has been overcast for three weeks? It's crazy to unfairly penalize power companies just because the public loves solar power. It's a complicated question.
- cbr 11y agoSpecifically: http://assets.bwbx.io/images/ilVXr6BF7iAU/v4/-1x-1.png http://assets.bwbx.io/images/ilVXr6BF7iAU/v4/-1x-1.png
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIt's a little weird that the article claims that the problem is worst in winter, when there is least sun. Also, that graph is unreadable? I'm already aware of what the duck curve is, and I can't make head nor tail of it.
- rhino369 11y agoI bet it's a problem in the winter due to A/C and electric heating. When it's sunny in summer, solar production goes up but it also makes people use A/C more. There is significant canceling out. In winter, solar production goes up, but people use less energy due to electric heaters not be as needed since it's warmer. Not a lot of the country uses electric heaters, but it's enough to add to the problem.
- skolos 11y agoYou are talking about spot market prices, not wholesale power prices. Most of the wholesale prices are established in forward markets (several months to a day ahead) and I don't remember ever seeing them negative. So following your logic it would be unfair that some power plants can run and earn positive income (when their production is sold forward) at the same time when other need to pay to run (when their production is sold on spot market). But there is nothing wrong in this - that's how balancing in power markets works. Also you mentioned that wholesale and retail power prices can be very different. There are multiple of reasons why this is the case, but the important result is that consumers do not understand how balancing market works and why prices can be one hour $1000 and the next negative. If we want to encourage solar power installations by retail customers the pricing should also be based on retail model. So I would disagree that your comment about negative prices is relevant to how prices should be set for power produced by home solar panels. But I do agree - it is quite complicated question as most questions concerning power grid.
- Rexxar 11y agoMeta comment : it's always surprising to see how different is the destiny of a submission based on timing and randomness. For example, my previous submission of this link got only one vote. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11052575 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11052575)
- jtlien1 11y agoIt reminds me of A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthurs Court after the Interdict came down and stopped all that progress. Our Interdict is the PUC, regulation, lobbyists and corrupt political decisions, then subsidies and more counter subsidies. No, rooftop solar is not a no brainer anywhere. Try to figure in the cost of energy storage which is still astronomical in price. Or jump into 100 years of utility regulation fights when all we need is power generation that should be just based on common law rights etc and competitive capitalism only.
- tlrobinson 11y ago"All this has enraged independent, free-market, and environmentally conscious Nevadans." ... "Nevada forces utilities to buy the excess energy at rates set by regulators" How was the government forcing utilities to buy excess energy at mandated rates "free market"?
- rwj 11y agoPlus there is the fact that utilities are state-regulated monopolies... Until you have competing utility providers, it isn't much of a market.
- rifung 11y ago> All this has enraged independent, free-market, and environmentally conscious Nevadans. I'm all for green energy, but how is leasing solar panels that are government subsidized and then having companies forced to buy back electricity at a set price considered part of a "free market"?
- landryraccoon 11y agoThey might be more upset about being forced to pay to not be connected to the grid. It's not free market if a customer can't refuse to be connected to the grid and refuse to pay for it.
- r00fus 11y agoIt's not. The energy production market is nowhere near a free market, thus these pricing absurdities for net metering.
- WaylonKenning 11y agoThis whole article is weird to me as a New Zealander, since most of the problems comes from weirdly, not letting the market set the buy-back rate of electricity. I worked for one of New Zealand's largest electricity generators and retailers, and we investigated a solar market. Here's how it works. Electricity is broken up into generation costs, distribution costs, retail costs, regulatory costs, and profit. Generation capacity goes up and down throughout the day, as does demand. In New Zealand an automated auction happens 30 minutes where generators bid in electricity at a price. The system operator then buys capacity required at any particular area at the cheapest price that is available. This sets the wholesale price of electricity. This then gets distributed by the system operator throughout the country to a local lines company. They maintain the power lines to your house, but also to that person in the middle of nowhere. The energy company figures out how much you've consumed, and bills you. Of course, when you have a problem, you call them, so there's a call centre always available as well. Finally, there are taxes and levies that the government applies. After all that, if there's anything left over between the retail price, and the sum of those costs, well, that's the profit. The weird bit is, where do you set the buyback rate for solar? The retail price? But there's so much expenses there, not all of which are the retailer's cost. The fair price of the market is the generating price, or wholesale price. But, there maybe political incentives to set a higher rate, as well as cap the number of people who can get that higher rate. But if you want it sustainable for everybody, then using the wholesale rate makes more sense.
- skolos 11y agoWhat you just said is that the buyback rate should be somewhere between wholesale rate and retail. There is no clear cut way to figure out what it should be so regulators and politicians get involved in setting the rate. "Sustainable for everybody" argument can be used on both sides - if rate is set too low, the solar panel owners subsidize the rest of the customers if it is set too high then other customers subsidize solar panel owners. So the argument is not as clear as you tried to make it sound.
- WaylonKenning 11y agoThere is a clear cut way - the wholesale rate. In New Zealand, an auction happens every 30 minutes where demand is tallied by the system operator (Transpower) at a Grid Extraction Point, and generators bid in what they think it's worth. The system operator then purchases the cheapest electricity available (taking into account demand is different throughout the network, and the network can't transfer all electricity to all parts of the grid because of line constraints). This is the cost of the 'raw materials' of the retail electricity price. A solar panel on your house really isn't any different that a little power station. You still have to transport that electricity somewhere, maintain those lines, maintain the voltage, run a power station when it gets dark, bill you, etc. It's not a big conspiracy, it's just that the cost of energy makes up about half the costs of the electricity system. If you set at a rate higher than the wholesale rate, then there must be other reasons to do so rather than pure financials. A good example would be if an Energy Utility wanted to attract solar customers, sell them solar systems, and put it on the bill to make them more sticky customers.
- dang 11y agoWe changed the title so it wouldn't be ludicrous linkbait. If anyone can suggest a better (more accurate and neutral) title, we're happy to change it again. Submitters: the HN guidelines ask you not to use the original title when it is linkbait or misleading. Please change it in such cases, preferably using a subtitle or representative phrase from the article. (I couldn't find one in this case, but if anyone else does, let us know.)
- chinathrow 11y ago"For years the state provided rebates for homeowners who wanted to go solar through a lottery system." What the heck...
- chinathrow 11y agoOn a second thought, the utilities should have never been privatised.
- cjensen 11y agoHere's the problem with Net Metering: suppose you have two neighbors with exactly the same sunlight conditions: 1. A person whose house is large, inefficient, and uses a lot of electricity 2. A person with a small efficient house. If both of these people buy the exact same solar panels and generate the exact same amount of electricity, then the utility has to pay #1 a lot more money than #2. (If you really want to ramp up the rhetoric, call #1 rich and #2 poor, and ask why the rich guy gets paid more for his solar power) How does this happen? In order to encourage conservation, we have different price tiers. The more electricity you use the higher the price per usage is. When the solar "rolls the meter backwards", it's rolling away the high-cost tier from the wasteful guy, and the low-cost tier from the conservationist. We want to encourage solar generation, so it makes sense that solar generators should be paid more per kWh. Net Metering is the Wrong Way to accomplish this goal.