3 ms·
The problem is that sometimes it is vital for cities to be able to control which (and how many) businesses open up in an area. Just look at what has hit HN tod
by mschuster91 11y ago
The problem is that sometimes it is vital for cities to be able to control which (and how many) businesses open up in an area.
Just look at what has hit HN today - an article about Walmart closing down and leaving entire regions without a less-than-3-hours drive to the next grocery store.
It is vital for a city to be able to prevent big chains from entering a market, destroying the competition by price dumping (made possible by sheer scale) and then packing up - leaving a stripped down town in the process.
Oh the other side, it's unfortunate that these laws and regulations more often than not get abused for clientel politics.
- jimbokun 11y agoWhat does that have to do with requiring two years of training to get a barber's license?
- mschuster91 11y agoI don't have a problem with that. Anything with healthcare or safety (electricians, plumbers, gas installers, builders, car mechanics) must be regulated in order to protect the public. 90% of the skill required in many jobs can be learned in a week or a month. It's the 10% you only learn over the course of education that are safety critical, though. Not to mention practicing in a safe environment instead on your customers or their homes. Let's take your barber as an example, and only the stuff that comes to my non-professional mind: - highly aggressive chemicals that will ruin your health if you're not taking proper safety precautions - the fact that you're meddling with a deadly sharp knife at the necks of your customers - health hazards for the customers: lice, other transmittable diseases, improperly disinfected equipment - health hazards for yourself that can be carried by your customers and you can pick them up (e.g. you cut the customer by accident, he's HIV+ and you have an open wound on one of your fingers while not wearing gloves - something I rarely see barbers do) The fact that the IT industry largely consists of self-educated people might be pretty cool but on the other side, how many security incidents could have been avoided by proper education? Even for BASIC security like not doing echo $_GET["name"]? Take a look at https://blog.setec.io/articles/2016/01/07/software-kill.html https://blog.setec.io/articles/2016/01/07/software-kill.html or literally hundreds of similar articles.
- jimbokun 11y agoThat's a great, detailed answer. Thanks.
- zanny 11y agoI'd argue corporate welfare in large part enables Walmart to push out local businesses so easily. A lot of Walmart locations have gotten subsidized building permits because counties think they attract a lot of business and grow the economy. They do - in the short term - just due to scale, until every other business withers and dies. You get a slight boost from cheaper prices before you realize rather than having an internal money cycle between small businesses you now have minimum wage workers at Walmart making the Walton's rich off your communities wealth which is rapidly going away. But Walmarts core business depends on the ability to use state aid to subsidize their employees - pay them barely above minimum wage, give them all the welfare pamphlets to get medicaid coverage, food stamps, electric subsidies, etc - and that lets them outcompete everyone since they don't have to assume any burden as a multinational business operating in a local market where their economies of scale and corporate efficiency mean nobody else can compete with them on goods pricing. Their employees make unnaturally high relative wages because they spend so much effort hooking them up with state programs to subsidize their starvation wages. And a large part of why these cities are in crisis is because archaic and overzealous zoning and building codes, and an immense amount of property-as-an-investment movements in the economy for the ultrarich since 2008 put up immense barriers to natural business growth. When you have all these regulations in your way it becomes way too much of an opportunity cost to try, especially when regulations are often intentionally written to be impossible to interpret for a non-lawyer, and even remain nebulous intentionally by the corporate sponsors who had them enacted as a means to stifle competition. Most of us here are in software - why? What keeps the software industry growing so much compared to almost any other business? Part of it certainly is innovation and utility, but there is no way that tech valuations are realistic or that the frequency of unicorn startups is reflected at all in almost any other industry today. And I would certainly postulate that is in huge part due to the incredibly low barriers of entry to developing and distributing software as a product. Everything else has huge physical opportunity costs and often magnitudes more logistical and legal hurdles that make competition impossible, so it should surprise no one major entrepreneurial growth is disproportionately coming from software.