8 ms·
> It is logical to require you to have a license to fill a cavity for safety reasons. It is not logical to require a license to cut hair. You mean there are no
by pdonis 11y ago
> It is logical to require you to have a license to fill a cavity for safety reasons. It is not logical to require a license to cut hair.
You mean there are no "safety reasons" involved in cutting hair? A person with sharp implements around your head and neck poses no safety risk?
Also, even if the "safety reasons" are more compelling for dentists than for barbers, that's still not a reason to have the government doing the safety checks by means of licensing. Private organizations could do the same safety checks--plus, they would have an incentive to do only the checks that actually added value, whereas government has an incentive to impose any requirements that have enough of a political constituency, whether or not they add value.
- krapp 11y ago>Private organizations could do the same safety checks--plus, they would have an incentive to do only the checks that actually added value, "value" wouldn't have to mean increased safety for the consumer, though. The incentive on the part of private enterprise could just as well be to impose any requirements that increase profits, whether or not they add value.
- pdonis 11y agoIf there is no government regulation to impose restrictions by force, then a requirement that doesn't add value can't increase profits, because customers won't accept it; there will always be some competitor who sees the potential to out-compete you by not having a requirement that customers don't want.
- notahacker 11y agoWhich is nice in theory, but absolute nonsense in practice, as evidenced by the number of no-value-add diploma mill accreditors and homeopathic regulatory bodies even under a regulatory regime where organizations can actually potentially be prosecuted for deliberately misleading people.
- pdonis 11y agoIn other words, the regulatory regime provides no actual benefit, yet we are paying for it with our tax dollars. Thank you for making my point for me.
- notahacker 11y agoYou honestly don't think that fewer people would get the medical treatment they needed if diploma-mill qualified charlatans were able to represent themselves as actual doctors or surgeons rather than having to go down the homeopathy/"alternative therapy" route?
- pdonis 11y agoNow you're talking about changing the current regulatory regime, not about getting rid of it--you're talking about diploma mills being able to give M.D. degrees that get recognized by things like state doctor accreditation boards. I agree that would be worse than what we have now, but it's hardly an absence of regulation; it's just making the regulations stupider than they already are. A true absence of regulation would mean that individual people would have to make their own judgments about who was reliable, in health care and everything else. Sure, anyone could call themselves a "doctor", but that term would mean nothing by itself; it certainly wouldn't confer any special privileges on the person using it. If you wanted to know if a "doctor" was qualfied, you would look at his actual qualifications: where he got his degree, if he has one (and was it a diploma mill or a real school), where did he do his internship and residency, what sorts of cases has he worked on, what is his success rate in treating various conditions, etc. (Many people already look at these things even in our current regulatory regime, as evidenced by the number of websites whose business model is to provide such information.) Would some people make bad decisions in such a regime? Of course. But people make bad decisions now. The question is which regime do you think produces worse decisions: a regime where everyone knows they are individually responsible for making good decisions, not just about what health care to get but about who to get it from, or the regime we have now, where people are encouraged to just accept particular credentials (M.D. degree, "board certified", on the list of preferred providers for their health insurance) as sufficient and not look any further.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoYou seem to assume that all customers are both rational and well informed. They are not. That's why your models break down in the real world.
- pdonis 11y agoYou seem to assume that governments will magically do a better job than customers of regulating the behavior of market participants. They won't. That's why your models do worse in the real world than mine.
- nommm-nommm 11y ago>That's why your models do worse in the real world than mine. Laughable. There was days without regulations, they didn't come out of nowhere cause someone was feeling bored. I don't want to go back to that time. How do you explain the supplement industry then?
- pdonis 11y ago> There was days without regulations, they didn't come out of nowhere cause someone was feeling bored. I don't want to go back to that time. What time, exactly? > How do you explain the supplement industry then? They are responding to market demand. If people are willing to buy supplements without having any information about whether they are safe and effective, then someone will be willing to sell them. My solution to this "problem" would be to remind people that they will have to bear the consequences of their decisions, and then let them decide--and bear the consequences. That means people who make bad decisions will have bad things happen to them. But at least everybody is aware that it's up to them to not be one of those people. Your solution is to have the government do the evaluation of whether the supplement is safe and effective--or at least be willing to prosecute sellers who mislead their customers. In other words, you think the government can somehow prevent bad things from happening to people who make bad decisions--or would, if they were allowed to make their own decisions instead of having the government decide for them. But, as someone else pointed out upthread, the government doesn't actually do that--even with all this government regulation, we still have industries like the supplement industry full of hustlers trying to sell people bogus products, and they don't get stopped by regulators and they don't get prosecuted when they deliberately mislead customers. So bad things still happen to people--but now it's worse, because people think the government regulations are protecting them, so they don't think they need to take any other precautions, but the protection they think is there isn't there.
- zo1 11y agoPeople are overly distrustful of private entities. Likewise, they're also overly trustful of public entities. It's implicit in almost every argument you will have when advocating free-market solutions over state-monopoly and state-regulation type solutions. And this applies to practically any problem. Unfortunately, no one wants to see the elephant in the room. Both types of entities will do (or at least have the risk-of doing) what is in their own best interest. But only one can have a violence-backed monopoly advantage.
- dsr_ 11y agoA government which is tightly constrained in the use of violence by laws and social custom is vastly preferable to a free market in violence.
- brbsix 11y agoYou've posed a false dichotomy. No one is talking about a free market in violence. A free market is tightly constrained by social custom, ostracism, and economic forces that are often more powerful than law. Lack of regulation does not make violence any more tolerable.
- ricardobeat 11y agoA free market is only constrained by the morality of individuals, which as everybody knows can quickly detour from the social custom. Ostracism is never a concern if you have power and/or money. A lack of regulation doesn't make violence more tolerable, but makes it more appealing.
- skylan_q 11y agoA free market is only constrained by the morality of individuals There is no one who advocates for free markets who advocates against laws. Killing people is murder, hurting them is causing injury, etc... It's constrained by laws, ethics, and economic forces.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y ago>Private organizations could do the same safety checks--plus, they would have an incentive to do only the checks that actually added value, Private organisations have an incentive to increase profit, even if it means a loss of public safety. Accountability only provides economic leverage when legal remedies for tort and malpractice are cheap and easily available. If they aren't, private organisations have no incentive at all to act responsibility. Often they don't. I think hairdressing may be a special case because salons serve a local area, and it's a very social profession, so bad word of mouth can do a lot of damage. But that's not true of most businesses. In fact of the drivers of the corporation as a business model is exactly the freedom it provides from personal and social responsibility. Instead of being personally accountable to customers, larger corporations operate at a level where local reputation is meaningless, and only governments, class actions, and the occasional PR disaster can punish bad faith operation. (Of all of those, PR disasters are often the least damaging.) There are licensing requirements for corporations trading in specific fields and for specific products. But there's no such thing as a valuable and reassuring general certificate of corporate professionalism and responsibility - which is perhaps a strange thing considering the power and influence corporations have.
- zanny 11y ago> If they aren't, private organisations have no incentive at all to act responsibility. Often they don't. So the dentist in the license-free world have no ecnomic motivation to not just rip peoples teeth out with a pair of pliers? People can self-regulate for risk and safety when they have complete information about the business. That would not have been available decades ago, but today we have the Internet and can easily move to interconnect everyone with common protocols to discern reviews and criticism of business to give consumers a more informed choice when choosing potentially dangerous trades, without crippling innovation and entrepreneurship within their domains.
- mcguire 11y agoHow much information do you have about the safe and effective practice of dentistry? How much information does the average American have about the safety and effectiveness of vaccines?
- zzalpha 11y agoPrivate organizations could do the same safety checks Someone didn't learn anything from the 2008 crash and the issue of private ratings agencies... Privatize safety checks and businesses will shop around to get a certification. Believe it or not, capitalism doesn't solve every problem.
- skylan_q 11y agoSo what you're saying is: It doesn't solve the problem of the combination of gov't corruption and private sector corruption, so private safety regulators/inspectors would never be able to keep anything safe.
- nsxwolf 11y agoAnd some ratings agencies would compete to be the one with the best reputation, which would lower the value of shopping around for substandard ones.
- Spooky23 11y agoWhy? The customer isn't the consumer of bonds, it's the underwriters and borrowers. By stamping shit debt as AAA, they were providing a wonderful level of service for their customers -- the bankers.
- pessimizer 11y agoOnly in the fantasy world where people have the time and expertise to evaluate the relative merits of hairdresser ratings agencies.
- ad_hominem 11y agoSomeone didn't learn about the de facto monopoly the SEC (federal gov't) gave the Big Three (Moody's, S&P, Fitch) at the time of the meltdown through its NRSRO status: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nationally_recognized_statistical_rating_organization#Subprime_mortgages.2C_CDOs.2C_and_the_financial_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nationally_recognized_statisti... The whole banking and financial system at that level has its tendrils wrapped so firmly around the gov't (and vice versa) that a failure there is hardly an indictment of free market principles.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoA person with sharp implements around your head and neck carries a modest health and safety risk and it might be good to subject barbershops to modest regulation. Will the regulation actually be modest? A person braiding your hair (uncommon among the white middle-class American community but quite common in African-American communities) poses a trivial health risk, and there are many cases of where the relevant occupational licensing required thousands of hours of (substantially unrelated) cosmetology training: http://ij.org/case/washington-african-hair-braiding/ http://ij.org/case/washington-african-hair-braiding/ http://ij.org/case/missouri-hair-braiding/ http://ij.org/case/missouri-hair-braiding/ http://ij.org/case/txbraiding/ http://ij.org/case/txbraiding/ http://ij.org/case/utah-hairbraiding/ http://ij.org/case/utah-hairbraiding/ http://ij.org/case/taalib-din-abdul-uqdah-v-district-of-columbia-2/ http://ij.org/case/taalib-din-abdul-uqdah-v-district-of-colu... http://ij.org/case/cornwell-v-california-board-of-barbering-and-cosmetology/ http://ij.org/case/cornwell-v-california-board-of-barbering-... http://ij.org/case/armstrong-v-lunsford/ http://ij.org/case/armstrong-v-lunsford/ The stories are pretty much the same. "They used to require 1000+ hours of unrelated cosmetology training. Now they require posting basic sanitation standards, a written test, and a $25 fee. Thousands have entered the business." And these are just some of the cases that one nonprofit has taken and won. You can bet there's plenty more out there in many, many fields. Of course, if we want to be fully ridiculous, note that Louisiana once required occupational licensing to arrange flowers: http://ij.org/case/meadows-v-odom/ http://ij.org/case/meadows-v-odom/ http://ij.org/case/chauvin-v-strain/ http://ij.org/case/chauvin-v-strain/ ... or look up the cases on interior design... or the sale of headstones...
- prawn 11y ago"Private organizations could do the same safety checks--plus, they would have an incentive to do only the checks that actually added value" I was thinking that this example of rent-seeking would come from non-governmental associations trying to justify their existence. If all safety checks were unnecessary, would that entity really phase them out or try to find more checks and initiatives to remain relevant?
- pdonis 11y agoIf the organization doing the safety checks doesn't have government force on its side, it only has an incentive to do safety checks that its customers will pay for. It can always try to think up new checks and try to convince customers that they're worth paying for; private businesses do that now. But it's still the customer's choice. If the checks are mandated by the government, then the customer doesn't have a choice, and the organization making the checks now doesn't have to convince customers; it only has to convince the government, which experience suggests is much easier.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoI most certainly don't want all safety regulations limited to "what customers will pay for!"
- pdonis 11y agoWho else do you think will pay for them? We are all customers; we all end up paying for them one way or another. The question is whether you want to pay for the regulations that actually benefit you, or the regulations that rent-seeking organizations can convince the government to use your tax dollars to pay for.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoYou missed the point completely.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThere are no safety precautions beyond everyday activity. The threshold is not "zero", nothing is ever ever zero.
- amag 11y ago> You mean there are no "safety reasons" involved in cutting hair? Ah, but this isn't really for "safety reasons", it's for "legal reasons". Sweden is widely regarded as one of the (if not the) most safety concerned countries, after all we "gave"(1) the world Volvo and Autoliv (among others). Yet the idea of regulating barbershops for safety reasons is totally alien here. We tend to trust that people have a common sense. This seems not to be the case in the US. This is mostly because of the legal system, whereas in Sweden you cannot sue someone else because you lack (or pretend to lack) common sense. In fact, the idea would never even occur to most people here. (1) No, we're not giving away Volvos, you need to buy one yourself.
- pluma 11y agoNice theory, but it's also a regulated occupation in Germany.
- amag 11y agoGermany != Sweden
- pluma 11y agoYes, but > This is mostly because of the legal system [..]. [T]he idea would never even occur to most people here. As far as I understand it, your argument was that the US regulates hairdressers because of its legal system. Germany also regulates hairdressers but doesn't have the US's legal system (in fact, it's closer to Sweden's with regard to suing over common sense). So as far as I can tell, Germany invalidates your assessment.
- amag 11y agoAh, but it doesn't. That would be a logical fallacy. Germany could have another reason for regulating barbers. My original comment wasn't about the regulation of barbers in general, it was about regulating them in the US (which was what the article was about). Having been to the US a couple of times, I have experienced first hand that you are commonly deprived of your own choices in the name of safety, when really, it's in the name of "not wanting to be sued".