4 ms·
Scientists Debate Signatures of Alien Life
- EwanG 11y agoFor those who are wondering before reading - article looks at the issue of what is considered a "highly likely" indication in an alien planet's atmosphere that would indicate life. Oxygen used to be considered that, but other processes have been found that can lead to significant O2 without life.
- EngineerBetter 11y agoThanks for the TL;DR. I find these magazine-style articles that start with waffle instead of the conclusion very frustrating!
- lutusp 11y ago> I find these magazine-style articles that start with waffle instead of the conclusion very frustrating! Imagine there was a rule that popular-press science articles were required to have an abstract that candidly summarized the article: Title: "Is there life elsewhere in the universe?" Abstract: "We have no idea, and this article doesn't change the status quo."
- rogeryu 11y agoHow about life without oxygen? I always wonder why alien life or any other life cannot happen without it.
- themartorana 11y agoI think this is finally being considered. Just because we're carbon based doesn't mean all life must be.
- ekianjo 11y agoThere a good reasons for organic chemistry being the main one. Carbon is abundant and can be combined in numerous ways to make complex molecules and stable ones at that. There are very few other elements in the periodic table that can hope to offer similar properties. So carbon based life is not just a guess, its a high probability.
- jerf 11y agoI don't know where this myth comes from that scientists have some sort of strong belief that no other form of life is possible, but it's not true. What we have is a lot of ignorance, so many scientists will often concentrate only on those forms of life (plural) we know exist because we share a planet with them, because those are the forms of life we can actually discuss with confidence, but I doubt you can find a serious scientist who will confidently proclaim no alternatives are possible. There are good reasons to believe that ours is quite likely and good reason to be skeptical of alternatives, in the proper scientific sense, but certainly not disproved or something.
- delazeur 11y ago> I doubt you can find a serious scientist who will confidently proclaim no alternatives are possible. Undoubtedly. The problem is that very few people, even among the well-educated and technically proficient, actually form their views about the state of science by talking to scientists.
- amelius 11y agoWell eventually, oxygen et al will just be catalysts to silicon based life :)
- ekianjo 11y agoThere is already life on earth without oxygen. Deep sea bacteria lives on sulphur and carbon dioxide.
- lutusp 11y ago> How about life without oxygen? It's thought that life began here in the absence of oxygen, and only over time did oxygen begin to play a part in cellular life. As another poster points out, there are still some cellular organisms here that do without oxygen, indeed they would find it toxic. > I always wonder why alien life or any other life cannot happen without it. But that's not true, not even here. Oxygen is regarded as a sign of life, but its absence doesn't suggest the absence of life, only the kind of life that requires it.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> How about life without oxygen? I always wonder why alien life or any other life cannot happen without it. If by oxygen you mean molecular oxygen, O2 -- rather than atomic oxygen as part of some other compound -- we know life can happen without it, since there is life on earth that lives without it. And, IIRC, we have strong reason to believe that life that could live without O2 predates life that needs O2, and, in fact, it is life that made free O2 available, not free O2 that made life possible.
- mrec 11y ago> And, IIRC, we have strong reason to believe that life that could live without O2 predates life that needs O2, and, in fact, it is life that made free O2 available, not free O2 that made life possible. Yes, early life on Earth was all anaerobic. That started around 4.1 Gya (billion years ago)[1]. The Great Oxygenation Event[2] happened around 2.3 Gya - that wasn't the first appearance of photosynthesis, but it was the point at which it changed the atmosphere enough to wipe out most of the other life on Earth at the time. Obligate aerobes - organisms that need oxygen to survive - were later still. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_evolutionary_history_of_life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_evolutionary_h... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
- hodwik 11y agoIt's sad "scientists" are wasting their time on this close-proximity alien fantasy when they could be working on real problems.
- gndjcjndnd 11y agoSad? I don't see anyone crying. It's not as if the entire scientific community is just dropping whatever they're doing to work on this. The value of an endeavor is its likelihood of success times its potential reward. So while the probability that these people will succeed is very, very low, the potentially incalculable rewards of discovering alien life offset that.
- hodwik 11y ago> Sad? I don't see anyone crying. Most of the world is crying -- we're dying of a thousand different wounds, and science, what was supposed to be our greatest hope, has become a sort of masturbatory worship of safe data. It's lost direction. Rather than working on real, hard problems they're arguing about escapist nonsense. The only way the Drake equation gives high answers for our chances of contacting aliens is if you put in absurdly high values for ne through L. Sure, there are aliens, but they are tens of millions of lightyears away. FTL travel and communication will only ever be fantasy. You will not meet them, get over it.
- EC1 11y agoThis is no different than my Father coming home every night without food telling us the same thing, that when he wins big we'll have all the bread in the world. He never won, then he died. People wasting time on things that have an extremely low probability is still a waste of time at the expense of everyone else currently living on the planet. If anything, discovering alien life will probably end us.
- lazypenguin 11y agoHow short-sighted and small minded. In the pursuit of answering these questions the people involved develop new techniques and new knowledge that ultimately aid in our overall scientific progress.
- dave_sullivan 11y agoAny time I see this discussed, I feel compelled to post the transcension hypothesis: http://accelerating.org/articles/Smart-2011-TranscensionHypothesis-ActaAstronautica(Author%27sReformat).pdf http://accelerating.org/articles/Smart-2011-TranscensionHypo... In short: Life is common in the universe, black holes are better than Dyson spheres, and eventually everyone uploads their brains to computers. Far fetched or not, really interesting reading!
- jerf 11y agoA lot of people seem to be so ready to read a different article that they aren't noticing what this one is about. This is not an article about "If a given planet holds life, how could we detect it?" This article is about "If a given signal is detected from a planet, what characteristics of the signal would allow us to conclude it could only be from life?" It's a completely different question. It's not about avoiding false negatives, it's about avoiding false positives. It is obvious that a planet could hold life, and we could fail to detect it; we're still arguing about whether Mars has or had life, after all! And we've actually landed probes on it.