5 ms·
I hope one day in the future the idea of a work permit will be considered just as crazy as the idea that only men should be allowed to vote. It strikes me as r
by lordnacho 11y ago
I hope one day in the future the idea of a work permit will be considered just as crazy as the idea that only men should be allowed to vote.
It strikes me as ridiculous that it could be illegal for someone to work simply because they were not born near where their employer is based.
- petter_byoa 11y agoYou think labour migration has absolutely no downsides at all? No impact on the stability on society at all?
- erispoe 11y agoWe have no scientific evidence of the contrary. There are some studies pointing to mass migration being (slightly) detrimental to the wages of low-income natives, but that's pretty much it. You will find a lot of opinions though.
- petter_byoa 11y agoIf you could literally sign an order right now to completely remove any control on who could come and work in your state (setting aside criminal records, diseases etc), would you do that? I think you would probably not, because you know it would be a war zone within weeks, with the poorest and most desperate people from all around the world swarming to your small part of the world, bringing with them huge social issues.
- jgh 11y agoDoes that happen now? There are plenty of poor, desperate people all over America, do they "swarm" the more affluent areas? Do we have poor people from rural Pennsylvania coming to Los Angeles and undercutting hard-working Californians?
- erispoe 11y agoI would. With background checks for criminal records. People who have the wherewithal to move across the globe are not "the poorest and most desperate people from all around the world", they are the ones with the means to pay thousands of dollars to mafias because we have no better system to bring them in.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>There are some studies pointing to mass migration being (slightly) detrimental to the wages of low-income natives, but that's pretty much it. Why is "mass migration beats down the working class" not bad enough to warrant restricting it?
- erispoe 11y agoBeing slightly detrimental is not exactly synonym for beating down.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoSo-called "slight" decreases to wages add up to quite a lot of money over whole careers. I don't see any reason to deliberately institute a policy that helps advantage capital over labor, when it is already so very advantaged.
- erispoe 11y agoBecause overall immigration does way more good than harm to a country, and that drawback effect on low wages can be countered by policy measures.
- turar 11y agoThat would actually put labor on the same footing with capital, since capital can already move freely across borders, while labor cannot.
- winfred 11y agoHmmm I can invest my capital in 30 countries easily with a carefully selected index fund. If I could move across borders freely, it would be hard (if not impossible) to do the same thing. So I'd say it isn't the same footing that applies.
- lordnacho 11y agoLetting women vote had downsides for certain people too. That didn't make it less right. As for stability, you need to consider the benefits of having the best people from around the world in the jobs where their comparative advantage is greatest.
- swozey 11y agoYou're combining work permits with citizenship. They're vastly different. Do you want neither to be a requirement? How ethical is it to allow someone to work in a country where they have zero civic participation in its government? Or do you immediately get participation rights because you work for a company based in XYZ? Then you vote for things that affect the future, you move, and you're no longer affected by the votes you put in. Where do your loyalties lie?
- dorfsmay 11y ago> How ethical is it to allow someone to work in a country where they have zero civic participation in its government? And yet it happens all the time under NAFTA with contractors and "service" companies.
- maxerickson 11y agoA lot of municipal debt is a result of people who voted for things that affected the future and then left. It's not just a hypothetical problem. (Basically, pensions. They were offered to make municipal employment more attractive, which made the cities nicer places to live. They were not totally funded at the time the services were provided, even though the benefits of offering the pensions were largely consumed at that time.)
- crdoconnor 11y agoThere's no point in having municipal bonds in the first place. The federal government can borrow at zero percent to bomb little brown children or subsidize wall street bonuses. Flint can't borrow at zero percent to pay teachers or fix its water mains. What confuses me is why people like you are personally are more concerned with cutting teacher pensions than cutting war budgets when it's fairly plain which one we actually want more (assuming you don't want to live in a country full of dumb people that is...).
- maxerickson 11y agoI'm not in favor of cutting pensions. I'm in favor of fully funding them at the time of employment. I guess I would agree that fully funded pensions might not be as large as promised pensions, but it's not like promised pensions have a perfect record of getting delivered.
- tosseraccount 11y agoCountries looking out for their citizens' welfare is not crazy. H1-B is subsidy for the already rich. These billionaires can afford to train Americans. Civil rights leader Professor Norm Matloff has a good summary of the issues : http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/h1b.html http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/h1b.html
- gaius 11y agoCountries looking out for their citizens' welfare is not crazy Indeed, it is what a country is for.
- lordnacho 11y agoWhat about people who aren't citizens but happen to live there? Their lot can just be ignored? Is it just to enact rules that harm their interest in favor of citizens?
- gaius 11y agoTo be brutally honest: yes, that is how it is in the real world right now. Non-voters are invisible to democratic governments, apart from how they influence voters.
- IndianAstronaut 11y ago>H1-B is subsidy for the already rich My small 55 person company is survivng thanks to H1Bs. We struggled to find a dba and a critical dev for years, and found a couple of good H1B candidates. Saying that this program only benefits billionaires is a bit absurd.
- ones_and_zeros 11y agoYou struggled because you couldn't afford the talent you needed, the talent that I'm sure already existed in the country. It's not a talent shortage, it's a cost issue.
- thyrsus 11y agoI favor minimal restriction on immigration: let in anyone who has a job or who has immediate family with a job. As a result, there's lots of young people paying into Social Security. Unlike the federal government, the states currently spend more per immigrant than they get in taxes from them, so the states need to raise their taxes, or the feds need to share the revenue.
- tosseraccount 11y agoUse immigration policy to fund government programs?
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoYour idea is bad for many reasons, but on the other hand I'm sure it'd be nice for a lot of Americans with underemployment and liberal arts degrees to be able to move around the Anglosphere.
- omegaworks 11y agoOnce the wage and labor protections are roughly equivalent around the world, then I'll happily take this position. That is not the world we live in today. If you can get dissappeared[0] by capital in your country for standing up for your right to a decent wage, sorry, I don't want to give capital in my country that kind of leverage. 0. http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/30731-why-did-mexican-police-make-43-student-teachers-disappear http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/30731-why-did-mexican-pol...
- lgieron 11y agoI've seen an estimate that allowing everyone to come to work in the US would result in about 1 billion people moving to States within very short timeframe. I think it could very well be the end of the country (as even the army + the police could have trouble handling the resulting riots and general chaos).