15 ms·
AI That Annoys Telemarketers
- ADRIANFR 11y agoHere is what I have done many times when a telemarketer calls I listen to what he wants to sell, the I say: “Yes, I think I’ll be interested in this, can you hold on just a bit?” Then I put down the phone and let him wait. Many times, the caller was still waiting 5 minutes later.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI believe that some call center forbid, or heavily penalize, the workers for hanging up on a potential lead.
- randycupertino 11y agoMy old company wouldn't even let the reps hang up if the customer became verbally abusive. One poor woman had to listen to some sicko try to have phone sex with her for 45 minutes. He was actually masturbating to her on the phone. I only found out because I found her out back crying because she sat there and listened to it because she didn't want to get penalized for disconnecting him. I felt so bad for some of our reps that I just said fuck this and taught them all a way to deliberately bugsplat their systems which would force the software to hang up and they wouldn't get penalized for looking like they disconnected the call. I know people in this thread are like "fuck these people for calling me" but they have no idea of how much abuse the reps have to take- from both their employers AND the people on the other end of the phone. No one should have to sit there and listen to the verbal abuse that these reps constantly put up with every day. It's a truly shitty job.
- randycupertino 11y agoSome of them are paid/incentivized for their talk time, so the reps will be perfectly happy, in fact GLAD, to be put on endless hold, because they can mute their headset, kick back and talk to their friends while all the time their metrics look good and it looks like they're working. Some of our reps at my old company would purposely change our AI to dial places like Medicare or social security so they could purposely get put on endless hold.
- erokar 11y agoGood job on making things worse for underpaid workers who in all probability also hate what they do.
- tunesmith 11y agoI agree, this is pretty mean and funny at the same time. I think where it turns from mean to funny is about where we imagine ourselves a certain distance away from them. But I do remember a certain time where I got mad at a customer service rep and made some comments that were... a little too cutting, and I remember experiencing her react in a way that showed she was hurt and upset. It hit me hard and I haven't done that since.
- Nutmog 11y agoBut if you had only been polite, would you have gone away feeling frustrated or ripped off? There's a reason people are rude to customer service staff - it's to vent their frustrations at the company that's causing them grief, and thus feel more relieved themselves. The job of the rep is to represent the company and that includes receiving gratitude as well as criticism, "I love you" as well as "you f*". Perhaps the problem is that there are people desperate enough to suffer abuse in exchange for money. We already solved similar issues protecting people from their own desperation with minimum wage and workplace safety laws so maybe we need a legally required "maximum personal abuse" requirement on employers to protect workers from this.
- tamana 11y agoTunesmith said some hurtful personal remarks to the agent (I could imagine something like "are you so stupid and your whole family so completely worthless, and you probably apat our several kids by several deadbeats to boot, that the only way you can scratch out a miserable existence is by trying to scamming people? You are going to die destitute and your children will always be homeless!", not complaints about the company
- tunesmith 11y ago
- gruez 11y agoIs there a self-hosted version of this for those of us without 3-way calling or long distance plans?
- jobu 11y agoHe's had enough interest in the project that he decided to run a Kickstarter for it : https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/202664225/the-jolly-roger-telephone-co https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/202664225/the-jolly-rog... Unfortunately a self-hosted option doesn't appear to be in the works, but maybe with enough feedback he'll add that.
- dsr_ 11y agoOr a sip endpoint so that we can use a little cheap net bandwidth rather than expensive minutes.
- gruez 11y agoThere's a dummer implementation of this idea that does use a sip endpoint. https://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/ https://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/. Too bad it frequently goes down (due to abuse) and isn't as sophisticated as the OP.
- metasean 11y agoAnd he gets to run a Turing test on his AI for each call, sorta like training AI through CAPTCHAS.
- jonbaer 11y agoTo me this (somewhat) passes the Turing test no? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test ... if only it had prerecorded context bits that could be recognized ...
- Nutmog 11y agoNo because the human doesn't expect that he might be talking to a machine. If he knew there was a 50% chance it was a machine then he'd find ways to recognize it - like its inability to follow the conversation at all.
- metasean 11y ago>Should the interrogator know about the computer? [1] > ...he states only that player A is to be replaced with a machine, not that player C is to be made aware of this replacement. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test#Should_the_interrogator_know_about_the_computer.3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test#Should_the_interro...
- stcredzero 11y agoHow about a service that uses a Siri-like voice recognition service to do one very limited context task: Screen your calls against telemarketers? A lot of telemarketer outfits with trashy setups are already at a disadvantage: Their predictive dialers leave a huge gap of silence at the beginning of an answered call because they don't properly time their dialing with available operators. Such a service could learn the vocal characteristics of your family and friends and would probably do a great job with recognizing cues telemarketers produce unconsciously.
- cballard 11y agoYou don't really need something that complex. You can either: 1. Just don't answer any call if it's not in your address book, as I do if I'm not at a computer. 2. Do a Google search for the number, if your doctor, tailor, or dry cleaner doesn't come up, don't answer. Add these to your Address Book for the future. Usually http://800notes.com/ http://800notes.com/ or similar sites will come up for telemarketers, with many notes. If implementing #2 in software, it would make sense to go the other way, validating that a number probably is a telemarketer, instead of validating that it's something relevant to you (which would be harder).
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI always pick up the phone, because I don't want to miss a call from a friend or a family member calling from jail, or a hospital, or a stranger's phone after they got in a wreck. It's less of a concern now that nearly everyone has cellphones, but I'd rather not risk missing a call like that :/
- hoodoof 11y agoAren't telemarketers people who are just trying to get their bills paid? Seems like bullying behaviour to be unkind to them. A quick "no thanks" and hang up is enough.
- hardwaresofton 11y agoSomeone made a similar comment and was severely down-voted -- be an adult, say no thanks, and hang up the phone. If you're being called extremely consistently at the same inconvenient time, then your case is extraordinary, take some measures to make sure the company doesn't call you again (no call list, whatever else) -- don't take your frustration out on the person who's turn it is to call you. I stated this before, but if you think about it, telemarketers are just sales people who work over the phone. Even when they're being overbearing, no one treats sales people this shitty in person.
- hoodoof 11y agoTelemarketers started off with blocked phone numbers, which I don't pick up anymore. Now that they reveal their numbers I immediately block that number on my phone after I hang up the call.
- dllthomas 11y agoI find they call from a new number every time.
- slantyyz 11y ago>> no one treats sales people this shitty in person. We have "door knockers" where I live (Ontario, Canada) who present themselves as representatives of gas and energy companies (and some have even gone so far as to say they work for the government) who try and get you to show them your energy bill and/or try to get into your basement to give you a "free inspection" and then get you to sign up for something you don't want. In my experience, saying "no thanks, not interested" (in person) just makes them more aggressive in their claims with the same scripted retorts- i.e. they're there in an official capacity (they're not), all the other neighbors let them sign up (probably not), they have a photo id (that anyone with computer skills can reproduce) and that they're there to save you money (doubtful). They show up in my neighborhood every couple of months, and after a while, you sorta get worn out by the routine and find that being rude/abrupt is the easiest (and sometimes only) way to get rid of them.
- gherkin0 11y ago> It can even detect when a telemarketer is getting suspicious, triggering a completely inane response that usually convinces them otherwise. How does it do that? Does it have some sophisticated voice recognition that can pick up on emotional reactions? Or does it just jump into them on a schedule that's calibrated to when someone would likely start to be annoyed? The "yeah uh-huh" stuff seemed pretty straightforward: it sounds like just shoots them off whenever there was enough silence to imply the telemarketer was waiting for a response.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoWhere's the cruelty? This robot isn't calling them names; it's not insulting them. The worst you could say about it is that it's wasting their time. But it's not even wasting their time as much as they're wasting mine. Never - not once - has a telemarketer call been something I would remotely be interested in. But they get paid for their time, while mine evaporates into the aether. That's even assuming the best case scenario - that they're cold-calling me for a product I may conceivably benefit from. What about all the scammers? What about those who call up the elderly, and continue to try to sell them hard, even if it's obvious that the person on the other end should not be making financial decisions? Maybe we should turn off spam filters to stop wasting the time of those who write the poorly worded viagra and aluminum siding ads.
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoInthe end, it's all about money - and wasting the time of the person being paid to call you is wasting the money of the person paying them. Turning off spam filters will have no effect on the time of the person writing them. Thanks to the magic of computers, when the message is written once, it can be sent as many times as necessary, with a much smaller incremental cost than a human on a phone. The cost to a spammer to send a message that bounces off a spam filter is actually higher (due to the need to buy/find open/vulnerable STMP relays when their reputation falls or they're blacklisted) than to send mail that is delivered, so keep those spam filters on!
- username223 11y agoCan you go into more detail? For my personal mail, my default approach is to toss spam client-side (via automatic filters or otherwise), so the spammer gets no signal about whether or not it is delivered. Does reducing the reputation of their relays hurt them much more? If so, which mail hosts support doing this?
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoI am not sure about what level you have to reach to get the mail rejected at source relays, but I know that on my Rackspace email system we forward spam mail back to appspam@rackspace.com to add it to Cloudmark, a distributed anti-spam system. Something similar happens with gmail. Dropping mail client-side doesn't inform any of the major relays, and it doesn't spread the workload - you're on your own.
- bcheung 11y agoThis could be dangerous depending on what the telemarketer is saying. TM: Would you to know more? Bot: Yes. TM: Do we have your permissions to record this conversation. Bot: Uh huh. TM: Do you agree to the charge of $123.45? Bot: Yes, sounds good.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoWho would the telemarketer charge? I don't think you can initiate a charge to a phone number unless the number itself calls someone, can you?
- zo1 11y agoIf it's from your provider, yes, they absolutely can. Because on their side, the number links to a "specific person/account", and they will charge to that, or add the service to that.
- vinceguidry 11y agoThey can't actually charge you unless they have payment information. Which you obviously wouldn't give to the bot.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoI will pay $20 for this iPhone app. Take my damned money.
- wstrange 11y agoThis would be perfect for the "This is Microsoft Windows calling" scams. You know the one - a dude with a very thick Indian accent who wants you to install some program to "fix" your PC.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoEven better, rather than an AI you outsource the talking to someone who has nothing better to do with their time and a mobile phone. Pay them a graduated scale depending on how long they kept the caller on the phone.
- dave2000 11y agoI used to pass the phone to my daughter and told her to mimic his accent, ask silly questions like "where's my pizza" etc. It's the little things that make life worthwhile, isn't it?
- wstrange 11y agoThese scammers called my 88 year old father, and managed to talk him in to attempting to install some malware. He isn't terribly computer literate, and Windows confuses the heck out of him (switched him to Chromebooks - so much better, but I digress). Anyhow, after spending almost an hour with him, they hung up in frustration - as he could not follow their directions to get the malware installed. So Windows is secure after all.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoAnyhow, after spending almost an hour with him, they hung up in frustration - as he could not follow their directions to get the malware installed. So Windows is secure after all. Thank you for the laughter!
- dhimes 11y agoI first heard of Tom Mabe on the radio when the morning show ("Kirk, Mark and Lopez") out of Baltimore played some of his bits on the air. He would prank the telemarketers ("Hey, I'm glad you called. (Darkly:) You wouldn't know how to get blood out of a carpet, would you? I've got a lot of blood here..."). He had some of them going quite a while- in a really quite funny way.
- gregmac 11y agoThis is very similar to 'Lenny', a script someone developed for Asterisk systems. It looks like the original website is down, but there's still a FreePBX module[1], a youtube channel with many, many call recordings[2], as well as several other forums posts/etc I won't bother to link. There used to be a hosted service you could forward calls to as well. The Lenny script's brilliance was its simplicity. Basically, it just waited for silence, then played back one of several clever lines recorded by a confusing-sounding old man. He'd ask the caller to repeat because he couldn't hear, divert questions by asking "Sorry, who did you say you were calling from again?" and tell long stories about his daughters then say "oh sorry, what was your question again?". Note, I appreciate the cleverness and social engineering aspect of this, but I don't use it myself. I do have a blacklist on my home phone, but it only goes to a 'not in service' tone, and I've only ever added 4 numbers to it (one in particular was some guy that told me wife to "f* off" when she said she wasn't interested). [1] https://github.com/lgaetz/freepbx-Its_Lenny https://github.com/lgaetz/freepbx-Its_Lenny [2] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLduL71_GKzHHk4hLga0nOGWrXlhl-i_3g https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLduL71_GKzHHk4hLga0nO...
- thaddeusmt 11y agoOn the topic of Lenny, "who" is great, if you want to just listen to one recorded Lenny call to get a sense for how it plays out (and have a laugh too), in this particular one a car crashes into the building where the telemarketer is working, adding to the strangeness. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lL870ixdsY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lL870ixdsY
- nchelluri 11y agothis is exactly what i thought of when i read this article. just heard this lenny convo ~last week as i saw it posted on reddit. told my coworkers about it as well :) edit: here's a great link about the video, with the bonus of giving subreddit info: https://np.reddit.com/r/itslenny/comments/40ul71/telemarkter_figures_out_lenny_is_a_recording_then/cyx7mlw?context=3 https://np.reddit.com/r/itslenny/comments/40ul71/telemarkter...
- randycupertino 11y ago
- brokentone 11y agoI've been getting so many calls lately, I've been playing music for them lately, trying to waste their time, hoping that they will take my number off whatever list it's on... I really wish there was a way to waste more of their time. Thus far, all I've determined is that they don't like Ace of Base.
- randycupertino 11y agoThey might actually start calling you more because the reps get incentivized by talk time, so getting a chance to chill and listen to music instead of actually having to talk to people and try to sell scam things people don't want to buy is a refreshing change for them. Realize those reps hate their lives, hate their jobs and are probably getting $11 an hour in some crappy hell hole trying to make $$ to feed their kids... it's not a job anyone WANTS to be doing and they really don't WANT to be bothering you, they are just forced to by their employers. If you don't want the calls, just say, "Please put me on your do not call list, thank you and have a nice day" and then hang up. Asking for the DNC is crucial- the words "DO NOT CALL" is the magic phrase that will get them to put your # into the blocked list of the autodialer. Some scammier telefirms won't actually add you to their DNC list if you say "stop calling me" it has to be the phrase "add me to your do not call list." Also if you just hang up on them without saying anything, the software will automatically add your number back into the queue to reattempt you again and again sometimes within days. Our outbound autodialer software used to recall people who didn't answer and also everyone who sent the reps straight to voicemail. The autodialer basically throws everyone back in to get endless calls in perpetuity until you pick up and the rep talks to you. And in a big shop where you've got 500 reps making 200-250 outbound calls per day, they can try you 1x a week forever. So if you really don't want ANY more telemarketing calls ever, stay on the line until the rep comes on, then say "please add this number to your do not call list, thank you, goodbye."
- tomjen3 11y agoIf they call back can you sue them?
- 11y ago
- js2 11y agoI use Anveo as my VoIP provider. They have a neat web-based call flow tool. My line is setup so that if you're not ona white list, you get a recording asking you to press a digit, else the call goes to voice mail. This has gotten rid of all telemarketing calls. Maybe 1 in 10 even make it to voice mail (most hang up first). But anyway, Anveo has had a "robotalk" feature for years, though I dunno how much AI it has.
- pfista 11y agoThe calls I get usually start by the telemarketer asking to speak to the owner. I say she isn't available and they always hang up right after that.
- anotherevan 11y agoTelemarketers I tend to just say, "No thanks" and hang up on them. They are in a crap job, probably forced into it my circumstance, so the compassionate side of me doesn't want to abuse them. The argument that wasting their time will ultimately make it uneconomical for those who employ telemarketers is an interesting one, although I doubt we'd get enough critical mass to make a difference. Implementing a basic income so people don't _have_ to work as telemarketers would be better for society as a whole. On the other hand, the calls from, "Microsoft Security" are actively trying to harm me, so I'll waste their time all I can, delaying their opportunity with the next person.
- joezydeco 11y agoHaving worked a telemarketing job back in my high-school days, I was grateful for the hang ups. We had quotas on calls completed and sales made, so letting us move on to the next household was a good thing.
- curiousGambler 11y agoAs someone who worked as a telemarketer during college to pay for his degree so he could understand things like AI... Thank you! Being a telemarketer sucks. The work environment is often toxically focused on metrics, turnover is high, and nobody wants to bother people at home! Sadly it paid much better than most other jobs available to me at the time, especially once I got half decent at it and starting earning commission, so I don't think things this will ever make it uneconomical for employers.
- bufordsharkley 11y agoI worked doing telephone surveys for a summer. It could really wear on you when people weren't polite. (And simply saying "No thanks" and hanging up was polite enough.) People who hung up right off, workers tended to say (to the disconnected line), "I'm sorry, I believe the call got cut off. I'll set you up for auto-reply every five minutes..."
- stevewillows 11y agoInstead of annoying these poor telemarketers, I'd rather have some software play a decent stand-up routine before declining the invitation to participate in whatever their service is. I can only assume that the telemarketer's day sucks enough without this type of software in play.
- noname123 11y agoRe:how a comedian (Seinfeld) responds to telemarketer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hllDWSbuDsQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hllDWSbuDsQ
- BWStearns 11y agoLove this! Almost fell off my chair laughing. Reading through the comments I saw some tender souls among us feel that Jolly Roger's kindly enticement to go on speaking is cruel, and wondered if there was a more humane way. I kept seeing the issue of the "What company is this? .... click" scenario. Given that there's a fairly high likelihood that the line callers for these guys are fairly gullible and/or cheaply greedy, as well as unlikely to be long term employees, I'm wondering if you could get one to flip on their bosses and provide a real location/target for the promise of $[500-1000?] to a PayPal account (of course it wouldn't be paid, fuck 'em they're scammers). I'm trying it next time one of them calls. Granted it doesn't accomplish the initial goal of being more humane, but good intentions and all that. Edit: You can apparently be awarded $1500 in private action against an entity calling you if you're on the DNC list. For social engineering purposes maybe promise to split it with the representative and suggest that s/he might be personally on the hook for money if they don't help?
- tamana 11y agoYou wonder why you can't convince a scammer to give you valuable info in exchange for a fake promise to pay? You can noodle that out.
- BWStearns 11y agoClose but not really what I said. I speculated that it is possible to do so, I didn't wonder why one couldn't. Think about who is calling you. The people working those phones aren't and never will be Kevin Mitnick. They're poorly educated, morally apathetic, have no real options, are unlikely to be employed at the same place in a few weeks anyways, and may in fact be being scammed by the people running the operation as well. People fitting that profile are prone to believing that they've gotten/will get lucky despite the evidence, see lotteries. They're basically indistinguishable from their ideal marks. Also, yeah supervisors might be listening to the call/the call is recorded, but it would be uneconomical to monitor them all live all the time. Any attempt to turn them would hinge on their expectation that their remaining time at the gig is going to earn less than what they expect to get from you. If you can convince them that they could make $1500 now, that's a month's salary for them. If they expect to be fired tomorrow then even a chance that you're telling the truth starts looking worth it.
- MrQuincle 11y agoForgive my ignorance, but has telemarketing always been going on in the States? Does it depend on the State? Why does the register not work? Is there no organisation that hands out fines? What's going on that you can not protect yourself against intrusion in your own home/life?
- mirimir 11y agoVoIP that's very hard to trace is the problem. And it's not unique to the US.
- sdfin 11y agoI thought the same. Where I live there's a register where you can suscribe, and if telemarketers call you then the company can be fined. Isn't there in USA such a thing? Even if somebody calls using VoIP, they will mention their products, so I don't know why that would be an obstacle to identifying them.
- pandaman 11y ago"Telemarketer" nowadays means just anybody making annoying calls. I don't remember when was last time somebody who actually wanted to sell something has called. All the calls I am getting now are either asking for donations (which are exempt from do-not-call law, being a "charity"), doing a "survey" (also exempt) or are from criminals helping with my "credit card debt" , from "Windows security", from "IRS" etc. I imagine the criminals, already breaking more serious laws, would ensure they are not vulnerable to the do-not-call.
- goodcanadian 11y agoTelemarketing has existed a long time in the States. There is a national do not call list, and it works pretty well. However, scammers don't respect it, so you'll still occasionally get calls. Also, businesses with a "previous relationship" can call you. I once had to threaten a car dealer with legal action to get them to stop calling (I had test driven a car). A related problem I had was that I got a phone number that formerly belonged to a deadbeat. There were constant calls from debt collectors. It took about two years to convince them that they had the wrong number. Well, actually, most of them were pretty good because they can get in a lot of legal trouble if they harass the wrong person, but then the company would sell the debt to another company, and the calls would start again.
- fishnchips 11y agoThis is inhumane. I don't like being cold-called but I really feel sorry for the lads and lasses doing it. I've been extremely lucky to have had the privilege in life that allowed me to receive good education, land a sequence of ever better jobs and build up skills that allow me do things I enjoy and get paid infinitely more than I deserve. Trolling folks that due to no fault of theirs were much less lucky in their lives is as ambitious as trolling my two year old son but way, way more cruel.
- frik 11y agoHave you even read the article and watched the videos? Hint: watch the videos and read the intro text...
- lispm 11y agoIn what way is 'AI' involved?
- DoctorBit 11y agoReminds me of the "Telecrapper 2000" from a long time ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QlK_zHisT_A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QlK_zHisT_A http://myplace.frontier.com/~pumamanor/ http://myplace.frontier.com/~pumamanor/
- petegrif 11y agoI have a solution to telemarketers that I have found to be extremely effective. No matter what they say you reply "That's very interesting, please tell me more." Ideally you should do this in a flat monotone. They rarely make it past 3 or 4 opening gambits.
- mangeletti 11y agoI called the robot's number, added a second call to the robot's number, then merged the calls and muted myself. It was pretty hilarious.
- mavdi 11y agoHaha this is genius, now add a premium rate number to that and profit.
- delinka 11y ago"It’s absolutely brilliant when it works flawlessly." Ain't it the truth? This is said of my own software creations. Though, to be honest, they seldom work flawlessly.
- jpatokal 11y agoI've always liked the telemarketing counterscript: http://egbg.home.xs4all.nl/counterscript.html http://egbg.home.xs4all.nl/counterscript.html