2 ms·
It's fine for researchers to go look for other causes. It's not fine to expect that they will disregard what we already know. Well-supported scientific theories
by snowwrestler 11y ago
It's fine for researchers to go look for other causes. It's not fine to expect that they will disregard what we already know. Well-supported scientific theories should be used to constrain the search space when addressing new problems, otherwise we'll get stuck re-proving the same basic things over and over again.
If every epidemiological study causes us to question everything we thought we knew, it's going to be hard to make any progress on health improvements. This is certainly not the first study to find health correlations with cell phones, and it won't be the last.
- dekhn 11y ago"Well-supported scientific theories should be used to constrain the search space when addressing new problems, otherwise we'll get stuck re-proving the same basic things over and over again." I think QM showed this was pretty much not an acceptable position to take.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThe reason QM rejected existing classical theories is because various experiments were wildly inconsistent with classical theory. I.e., if you repeat photoelectric experiments enough times to rule out experimental error, you've pretty much refuted classical physics with p < exp(-N) (where N is O(# of particles)). This study has p < 0.02. It makes an highly unlikely hypothesis about 50x more likely, i.e. still extremely unlikely.
- snowwrestler 11y agoCould quantum mechanics be wrong? Yes. Are we going to discover that by surveying 100 infertile guys? No.