5 ms·
Like many people, you're starting from assumption of the mechanism (ionization) and ignoring the fact that there are many other known physical mechanisms that a
by dekhn 11y ago
Like many people, you're starting from assumption of the mechanism (ionization) and ignoring the fact that there are many other known physical mechanisms that are plausible.
Also, if people detect a reliable signal without a plausible physical mechanism, best thing to do is determine what the cause of the signal is- rather than just assuming it's impossible.
In grad school we were taught to do "back of the envelope" calculations to rule out improbably hypotheses, but I often found the physics people convinced (I think they used the term "proved impossible") themselves things wouldn't work, then after 5-7 years of grad school, managed to come up with actual physical data that showed they had made a false assumption.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoWhat are the other plausible mechanisms? The effect of low intensity RF fields on chemistry is essentially negligible. For the most part, folks doing chemistry with non-ionizing radiation need intense lasers or microwave resonating cavities. The main exceptions (which in reality also mostly require intense radiation) are highly engineered scenarios where you finely tune a radiation source to excite an electron to a specific level that's far from the continuous spectrum, but useful for some other chemical to interact with. To detect low frequency radiation, these usually require very specific materials with nearly continuous energy bands (think carefully doped semiconductors or possibly photoreceptor proteins). These are also highly unlikely to occur - again, unless you've engineered it to happen, 10^{-5} is probably an extreme overestimate on the probability. But if you know a plausible mechanism, I'd love to hear it. Feel free to provide references or go into physical detail.
- maxerickson 11y agoMaybe people with low sperm concentrations tend to sit around using their cell phone while it is plugged in? The abstract doesn't really propose a mechanism, it just notes the correlation. Pushing people with certain usage patterns to get screening for low t (or whatever) can still be a useful outcome of the further research. Not that I think they really need to get funding to pursue it, but you are imputing the proposal of a causative radiation mechanism.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoRight - I'm charitably assuming that their study supported causality with p=0.02. In reality it doesn't.
- maxerickson 11y agoMy statement above but you are imputing the proposal of a causative radiation mechanism. is poorly phrased. A better way to put what I was getting at is that they are not claiming that radiation effects are the only possible causative mechanism. They found some observation in some data and published it, probably in the service of a future grant proposal. Saying they didn't prove anything for this publication is like saying water is wet. Should hn spend much time discussing the result (or really, observation)? Absolutely not. Should they get grant funding for this? I dunno, I hope there are better proposals out there, but really have no idea.
- dekhn 11y agoAgain, you're making a ton of assumptions about mechanisms. Saying low intensity RF has a negligible effect on chemistry belies the fact that cell receptors can be exquisitely sensitive and those receptors can cause large changes in cells via DNA transcription. The current most plausible mechanism is localized cell heating. We already know that RF can cause cell heating. There are a number of physical responses to cell heating (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_shock_protein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_shock_protein) which can have large effects on cell morphology. I am not claiming that is the mechanism. But I've seen enough epidemilogical studies that have been conducted carefully enough to suggest there is some mechanism by which negative health effects may be occurring, and I think that alone makes it worth being a bit more creative than trying to disprove the observed evidence by claiming one of the plausible mechanisms isn't. (I have a PhD in Biophysics; I've worked up and down the molecular stack, and if there's one thing I've learned, it's that if the epidemiologists carry out a good study, and the meta-analysts confirm the effect, it's always a good idea to be open minded about the cause).
- yummyfajitas 11y agoOf course I'm making assumptions - the biggest one is that quantum chemistry works. If you are now retreating to thermal effects, they a) can be easily measured and b) are vastly smaller than effects like wearing tighty whities or walking past a radiator in winter. Is your sole claim that using a cell phone might have an effect 1/100th as large as blow drying one's balls after a shower? Let me reason by analogy, to explain the probabilitistic intuition here. Study: we threw golf balls at aircraft carriers and cargo vessels, and concluded that they are an effective naval weapon. The probability of observing this result by random chance, assuming golf balls don't sink aircraft carriers, is 2%. Would you draw the conclusion that golf balls are likely to sink aircraft carriers from such a study?
- dekhn 11y agoNo, my sole claim is not that using a cell phone would have 1/100th the effect of blow drying ones testicles after a shower (why????) After all, the phone stays around a lot longer (temporal effect) and I have certainly noticed that when the phone is using lots of bandwidth it stays warm for hours at a time. Many effects in biology can occur from extended exposure (cumulative dosage effects) when they don't have an effect from acute exposure. And vice versa, of course. Anyway, reasoning from probabilistic intuition here is probably a mistake: the epi studies show stuff that doesn't agree with our intuition (this is common) and that leads theorists and experimentalists to go search for other causes. In the history of science, we have a long list of things that weren't intuitive but ultimately were figured out. Finally falling back on "I assume QC works" isn't really informative in this case. I assume QC works to and I don't see why that negates the possibility that cell phones can have negative health effects caused by physical mechanisms.
- sageikosa 11y agoWarm battery in front pocket? Testicles are outside the body to help control temperature.
- 50CNT 11y agoThis is probably silly speculation, but I'm neither good at testicle models nor the more squishy sciences. So sperm virility is correlated with temperature. My phone gets very warm if I leave an app running. I keep my phone close to my testicles. The wikipedia page on "Semen quality" is now in my browser history. I mean it's spurious, but I wouldn't be surprised if a running cellphone heats up the inside of your pants just enough for you to take a minor hit to semen quality. There's also a blood vessel that leads to the testicles that sits fairly close to where my phone sometimes goes. My browser history now contains anatomical diagrams of scrota. This could interfere with the thermoregulation of the testicle. That or the tails act as tiny antenna. I'm sure glad that I'm nowhere near the field of Biology, and I'm sure Biology is glad too.
- dlsx 11y agoAre you a fuckongfucking retardeded???
- Retric 11y agoIndirect, People carry cellphones in there pants pockets. Said pants are going to be tighter which hampers sperm production. Posture, people that sit differently during a phone conversation which may be constricting airflow / blood flow / heating. Direct heating, phones get fairly hot during charging which may cause other issues. Related behaviors, people that use there phone a lot may also use-laptops in there lap which case heat issues. PS: Sure, the study may just be random statistical noise. But, your better off investigating things that don't seem reasonable than assuming your world view covers everything.
- snowwrestler 11y agoWhen it comes to weird results in human epidemiology and public health, my bet is always on hidden/unknown 3rd factors. You're right that the signal might be real, but it might have nothing at all to do with cell phones. Rather, cell phones might be independently correlated with whatever the real causes of the sperm problems are. Put in plain English: a group of men with similar cell phone habits probably have many other things in common.
- dekhn 11y agoyes, I think it's always key to look at epi studies like this and make absolutely sure everybody agrees the protocol is designed to address bias. I'd say only about 10% of the studies I read do this adequately (it's one of the things that helped convince me Ionnides is right that nearly all studies are Just Wrong).
- snowwrestler 11y agoIt is impossible for an epidemiology study to elimate hidden factors, no matter how many statistical tests they run. Hidden factors are hidden, which means the statistics can't tell you about them. Information not available to the researchers cannot be evaluated by the researchers. This is why the concept of a mechanism is important in science--it provides a framework for simplified experiments that exclude hidden factors by their design. For example if the hypothesis is that cell phone radiation causes sperm problems by damaging human cells, then human cells can be directly exposed to that type of radiation to see what happens.
- dekhn 11y agoLike I said, a carefully designed study can eliminate many biases. I didn't claim it could eliminate hidden factors. Anyway the problem with finding something in an epi study then trying to reproduce it in a minimal environment (isolated cells exposed directly to radiation) is unlikely to uncover any complex mechanism. Cells on their own don't behave like tissue, and tissue on its own doesn't behave like an organism.
- digikata 11y agoAssume some model, and do calculations within that model to tell you what the probability of some event is under that model. What is just about impossible to calculate is what the probability is that the model captures only way for X event to occur. I find people sometimes confuse the reliability of calculations within the model as a defense of the model itself - usually unintentionally, but sometimes intentionally (with industries defending the safety of some practice...).