14 ms·
On Google's self-driving car acident rates
- zachwooddoughty 11y agoGoogle cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:9UNd6-lo4fwJ:ideas.4brad.com/google-releases-detailed-intervention-rates-and-real-unsolved-problem-robocars+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:9UNd6-l...
- Fuzzwah 11y agoI'm going to use this as a place to mention how ridiculous it seems to me that drupal displays the database details on the error page: > the username is drupal and the database server is localhost I'm sure this isn't a huge information leak, but it still seems kind of silly to me.
- Practicality 11y agoWhile I am not familiar personally with Drupal, this seems like a development feature that is supposed to be turned off in production.
- SomeCallMeTim 11y agoI used to use Drupal. At this point I never, ever recommend people use it. Pregenerating most of your pages a-la Jeckyll is just so much better that I don't know why anyone ever thought generating all of their pages with PHP was a good idea. I remember thinking it was a good idea, to be honest. But at this point I look back and see how mistaken I was.
- enzanki_ars 11y agoTo help people trying to Google/understand the parent comment, it is spelled Jekyll.
- SomeCallMeTim 11y agoFoo. Too late to edit. Thanks for the clarification.
- awqrre 11y agoIt's always a pain to link to Google also, they leak information in the address that you copy from the address bar...
- joe_the_user 11y agoHow safe does a self-driving car have to be before it is allowed on the road? I would say that's going to be a societal decision rather than an engineering decision. An interesting point is that the introduction of the private automobile itself was an imposition on the social space of that time which basically was wildly unsafe with automobile accidents still being on of the leading causes of death in this country. If it's determined that self-driving cars will be allowed, ordinary drivers will be forced to adjust to their presence and will have to learn their quirks. Certainly, cellular phones realistically are being used by a significant fraction of drivers today and if the accident rate has gone up at worst only slightly due to that (not enough to counter-weight other safety measure), it's because non-cell users have adapted to the presence of the cell-user, however annoying that might be.
- rhino369 11y ago>How safe does a self-driving car have to be before it is allowed on the road? I'd argue that self driving cars just don't have to be safer than average drivers. They should be safer than average drivers with computer driving assistance. It's already happening, but we can take the self driving programs and use them with human drivers. To get a best of both worlds scenario. Of course we'd have to mandate all new cars come with computer driving assistance. The counter argument is that we accept the risk of cars now, why not let self driving cars have the same level of risk. My answer is that the risk of cars is so great we either shouldn't be accepting it or are only accepting it because there isn't an easy alternative. A lot of Americans die on the roads.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt depends on the distribution of drivers that cause incidents. If the average (mean) driver is involved in an average number of incidents, then fine, base the safety estimation on them. If the average driver is involved in a below average number of incidents, the safety standard should be tuned to the drivers that are involved in incidents.
- melling 11y ago
- aresant 11y agoWhen it comes down to differentiation what do I care about if a robot is driving me around? Safety. Period. The equation to get to safety is sensors + computing + map / map geometry. The sensor differentiation will matter for a while, some OEMs will do very well, but ultimately it will just boil down to the software. So how is the future of this space not just "everybody licenses Google's platform"? If life/death safety is the differentiator (and measurable) I feel like the writing is on the wall. Google is going to dominate this. Maybe Musk sneaks in there with his brash approach of using his drivers as test subjects but his position as a competing auto manufacturer seems less compelling than supporting an "Android-like" effort from Google.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Maybe Musk sneaks in there with his brash approach of using his drivers as test subjects but his position as a competing auto manufacturer seems less compelling than supporting an "Android-like" effort from Google. I'd rather support Musk; this is core to his product. For Google, its just another moonshot. Tesla also has the advantage that Tesla owners drive 40 million miles/month. That's far and beyond what Google's autonomous vehicles are covering (<75K miles/month).
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoA big point in Tesla's favor is that they're putting it out incrementally. Cruise control is a very simple form of 'self-driving' that everyone is comfortable with the existence of. For the population to truly embrace this trend, it's going to be a long road of incremental steps. Lane assists have started to become commonplace, as have tools to automatically brake to prevent collisions. As these technologies become commonplace, people will accept them. Eventually, fully autonomous driving won't be much of a stretch.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoCompletely agree. It's not going to happen overnight. It'll happen piece by piece, until one day you wake up and you review your Tesla OTA update release notes and it lists "Level 4 Autonomous Mode" as one of the updated features. And none of us will be overly shocked.
- willvarfar 11y agoI can't wait for self driving cars. End of that discussion each time we eat out about who is going to drive us home...
- DanFeldman 11y agoThe CA dmv also publicly reports all accidents involving autonomous vehicles [1]. Most accidents are caused by drivers taking over control manually, or by other actors on the road driving erratically (or rear-ending the self-driving vehicles). The entries on the page report Google, Delphi, and Cruise automation as having incidents, though they're all minor damages, if there are any at all. [1](https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/vr/autonomous/autonomousveh_ol316 https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/vr/autonomous/auton...)
- huangc10 11y agoI live in Mountain View and I see Google self-driving cars around all the time (day and night). My personal feel is that they look "different" and my attention will deliberately focus on them (which may or may not affect my driving when I'm around them). Why not test with cars that look "normal" (think early 2000s Corolla). Wouldn't this further decrease the chance of possible accidents? I guess what I'm saying is, who's decision was it to make it look like a toy car and not just an actual regular car that doesn't divert my attention off the road? *edit for better readability
- hueving 11y agoMarketing. You want people to notice and think, "Hey, that's one of those self-driving cars, that's cool!"
- huangc10 11y agoI believe you're correct in that marketing did have a strong sway in the decision. But the fundamental principle behind Google has always been engineering and especially for something as crucial as safety, they should have stuck with something bland and nonchalant imo.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThe little Google cars (not the Lexus SUVs) were specifically designed for pedestrian safety in case of a collision, which can hardly be said about any other car, aside from Volvos.
- grillvogel 11y agopretty much every modern car is designed with pedestrian safety taken into account, that's why they all look so goofy now
- alanh 11y agoUnderstanding is that cars are designed for passenger safety, not so much pedestrian safety. What are you saying?
- epaga 11y ago*accident
- underbluewaters 11y agoI think it's pretty clear that the bar for safety must be much higher (10x) than human-level for these to be accepted by consumers. Auto accidents are very common, and the first time someone has an accident with a car like this everyone they know will hear about it. It will be terrifying. If these are only as safe on average as a human driver then nearly everyone is going to have at the very least a 2nd-hand negative experience. The emotional response to these accidents is not going to be entirely irrational either. If I have a minor accident with my traditional truck, I'm going to probably have a good understanding of what went wrong and how I can prevent future collisions. With an autonomous vehicle... software upgrade? I'd rather take responsibility for my own safety if that's the case.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThe idea that humans learn well from accidents stands contrary to all available evidence.
- ajkjk 11y agoWhat evidence? Certainly individual humans (anecdotally: like myself) do.
- tyre 11y agoLook at insurance premiums. Premiums go up after an accident because it is more likely that you are a poor driver and likely to have another accident.
- justinpombrio 11y agoThat doesn't mean that people don't become safer drivers after an accident! It just means that the variance between drivers is more significant than how much a single driver improves.
- snowwrestler 11y agoInsurance companies raise premiums after accidents because there is an excuse to do so. It has nothing do with your likelihood to have another accident, and everything to do with charging you more so that they can attract new customers with a lower price. Premiums go up even if the driver is found to be not at fault.
- bduerst 11y ago>How does that number compare with humans? Well, regular people in the USA have about 6 million accidents per year reported to the police, which means about once every 500,000 miles. Aren't accidents only reported to police if there is a hit & run, or some other criminal activity? Seems like the wrong metric for comparison, given the way they define the self-driving "accidents" and that the majority of human fender benders are not reported.
- cheald 11y agoNot necessarily. Major accidents will have the police involved, small fender benders might be handled with just an exchange of insurance information. If there's substantial damage though, the police will probably get involved since a police report makes collecting on insurance easier.
- HCIdivision17 11y agoIt's not uncommon to contact the police so that a quick statement can be made and the paperwork logged. It seems to help with the insurance stuff and getting a third-party's eye on the scene.
- dsp1234 11y agoIn some(most/all?) states, all accidents over a certain dollar amount or that caused injury to any party are required to be reported to the police. But the lack of police reports is why the article mentions that insurance companies believe the accident rate is higher than the 'official' number. Anecdotally, the number of times that someone has hit my car, and then asked me not to report it in exchange for cash is non-zero.
- iamleppert 11y agoAll of the brouhaha about self driving cars is moot until real user testing begins. I'm not talking about driving a google mobile around the streets of mountain view with an engineer in the driver's seat. These vehicles (I would hope) are designed to drive around people in different circumstances. They're software for use by people and until we have realistic tests with different kinds of people, ages, driving experience levels, etc. it's all academic. I'm somewhat wondering if all the self driving car stuff by Google and Tesla is primarily a vehicle (no pun intended) for marketing rather than actual tech that will yield a real product.
- bertil 11y agoIt seems, from previous reports by Google, that their ability to understand discrepancy between sensors relies on knowing the road very well, not just the map with nuances like “cars can go there, but it’s mainly a pedestrian street” but more local undocumented habits. They mentioned details that prove that they would have to drive a lot in new cities to learn enough and make their car safe. The one that I remember is that they have started driving in Austin and came across a very local species of vehicle with a unique habit: the hipster fixie rider with his stand-stop motion at red lights. Committed bikers do not have free wheels and stay standing in place not by putting their feet down but rocking back and forth; that motion was new and not interpreted clearly by the car, that hesitated to see it as a false start. It’s since been fixed. The article didn’t specify if the shirt pattern had any meaningful weight in the interpretation.
- abalone 11y agoWhat about manufacturer liability? That's the critical question here. It can't just be 2X or even 10X safer than humans if the manufacturer is liable for the accident. That would EXPLODE the cost of these cars and bankrupt companies -- even if just a small fraction of today's fatal accidents due to driver error became Google's liability. Consider that even single-vehicle accidents, which today might be the driver's fault, could result in a manufacturer lawsuit. This is why I think fully autonomous without any human to intervene is a pipe dream, because the safety level required for that is pretty close to perfectly bugfree in an almost infinitely complex world of roads and conditions. Just for liability reasons. These test cars of course have human copilots. But it remains to be seen if that really will grant manufacturers immunity for accidents. If the car is perfect 99.999% of the time, wouldn't that train the human to trust it and not pay as close attention? And then miss that 0.001% of the time when it hurts someone? Would a judge find it reasonable for a human to stay vigilant and responsible for that fatal corner case bug that cropped up after two years of perfect autonomous driving? Liability is The. Critical. Question.
- Animats 11y agoVolvo's CEO: "We are the suppliers of this technology and we are liable for everything the car is doing in autonomous mode. If you are not ready to make such a statement, you shouldn't try to develop an autonomous system." So there. At first, self-driving cars will probably be leased on operating leases, with maintenance and insurance bundled into the payments. Or maybe you own the vehicle, but there's a maintenance and insurance contract required to enable self-driving.
- danieltillett 11y agoIn theory this just shifts the insurance coverage from the driver to the manufacturer. The real unknown is if any insurance company will cover the manufacturer or not. I suspect that like the airline industry there will need to be a legislated cap on damages to make this work. Provided that there is insurance then there should not be any issue. More fundamentally we should not assume that the people working on this at Google are idiots. They already know all of this and I am sure they are working with insurance companies and governments to solve this problem. Compared to the technical difficulty of making a reliable and safe autonomous vehicle this is an easy problem.
- absherwin 11y agoMinor crashes are even more frequent than the article estimates. Thus, the real human accident rate is even higher. Probably between 1 in every 24000 and 87000 miles. The VTI driving study[1] equipped 100 cars with sensors and was therefore able to measure all crashes experienced. It directly measured 1 crash per 24000 miles. If we extrapolate based on the 17.4% police report rate, that suggests 1 per 87000 miles. [1]http://www.nhtsa.gov/DOT/NHTSA/NRD/Multimedia/PDFs/Crash%20Avoidance/Driver%20Distraction/100Car_ESV05summary.pdf http://www.nhtsa.gov/DOT/NHTSA/NRD/Multimedia/PDFs/Crash%20A...
- aetherson 11y agoThat's an interesting study. I'd be cautious at trying to create a one-line conclusion from it. It is, however, a fascinating full read, and not very long and not very technical, so I'd encourage people to read the whole thing. Note the narrow demographic data and geographic data.
- chad_strategic 11y agoNext time you pull up to a stop light, look to the left and then right. I'm willing to be the drivers on the left and or right are looking at their phone. It's getting worse... the phone, blue tooth, the dashboard computer, traffic, impatient drivers. etc... I for one can't wait these self driving cars, they have got to better than distracted drivers we have now.
- ams6110 11y agoI don't mind someone looking at their phone while they're waiting for a red light. I'm more worried about the ones who do it while in motion.
- Thirdegree 11y ago>Next time you pull up to a stop light, look to the left and then right. I'm willing to be the drivers on the left and or right are looking at their phone. And the dude between them is busy staring at his neighboring drivers rather than the road!
- fweespeech 11y agohttp://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:9UNd6-lo4fwJ:ideas.4brad.com/google-releases-detailed-intervention-rates-and-real-unsolved-problem-robocars&num=1&hl=en&gl=us&strip=1&vwsrc=0 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:9UNd6-l... Cache. Its down for me.
- VLM 11y agoWhy bother? In a world of massive un- and under- employment, mechanical turk and massive connectivity, increasing income inequality, and generationally declining standards of living, a handful of millionaires will sit in their unimaginably expensive self driving car, and five mechanical turk remote drivers will cooperate on a 3 of 5 vote basis to drive the millionaire. Most brainpower is underutilized, the quantity is increasing, and its manufactured by unskilled labor. There eventually comes a peak-automation point where its better and cheaper for the economy and culture to just hire a dude to do it. The world of the future is only ivy league grads will have real jobs and they'll have all the money, whats so inherently awful about someone in the favelas getting a job as a driver, especially if its cheaper and safer?
- oofabz 11y agoThe world unemployment rate is 8% according to the CIA World Factbook. What's going to make this increase so dramatically? We've had industrial automation, computers, and the internet for decades now, and people still have jobs. Also why would you want someone remote-controlling your car instead of sitting in the drivers seat? Wireless connectivity is way too flaky. Tunnels block the signal, rural areas have poor coverage, and equipment breaks and requires maintenance. It would be insanity to bet your life on a cellular signal.
- bertil 11y agoI am surprised that Google has not started having their software recording on cars that are driven by humans, to learn. They could increasingly have feedback to say “Our software would not drive that fast/that close to that curb” and progressively simulate a lot more dangerous situation and learn about tough situations than they currently can.
- occamrazor 11y agoThey have a vast number of human operated vehicles with extensive telemetry data: Street view cars.
- argonaut 11y agoThis is a harder problem than you think it is. This is a classic reinforcement learning problem, and it is incredibly difficult in the real world. It's easy in discrete state-space, perfect information, turn-based games like Go (the recent advance there). Very difficult in robotics.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIf the humans always take the wheel in dangerous situations, how do you know the cars are safe? The cases where they are most likely to get into trouble are the cases where the AI is not in operation!
- brianmcconnell 11y agoLicensed pilot here (learned to fly in 1987). People need to look at self-driving cars in the way pilots use an auto-pilot. Auto-pilot is most useful in two situations. 1) long cross country legs where there is not much flying to do (just maintain heading and altitude), so A/P frees the pilot up to manage other systems, enjoy the view, etc, and alleviates fatigue, 2) flying a precision instrument approach, reducing the risk that the pilot will succumb to spatial disorientation in the setup for (usually manual) landing. With cars, auto-drive capability will be useful in reducing accidents in two modes: 1) long duration highway driving where fatigue is a big issue, 2) intervening to prevent a distracted driver from causing an accident (rear end collision etc). I'd be perfectly happy with a car that can drive itself in cruise mode on the interstate, but requires an alert driver on local roads (with the added bonus that if I am about to slam into something, it will brake to avoid or lessen the impact). Something for the liability crowd to consider, self driving cars won't be able to avoid every potential mishap, but they will be able to reduce their severity. A car that can automatically brake to reduce its speed by 25% just before impact, will reduce its kinetic energy by roughly half, and the potential for injury by more still.
- crpatino 11y agoThis is a very insightful comment, from a person who has first hand user experience with self-navigation systems. Sadly, if you dare utter blafphemy against the Almighty God of Technology, bad karma will happen to you. This is even against the hacker spirit. We loathe IDEs and cherish emacs/vi close to our hearths because what we want from automation is augmentation of human capabilities, not self mutilation + prostaethics. How can people not accept that the same formula can work best for cars?
- pathsjs 11y agoThe fact is that auto-pilot cars, as you describe them, won't be nearly as revolutionary as self-diriving cars. The latter would allow people to put to good use the time to commute to work; they would improve car-sharing to the point that people would not need a personal car and parking could become a problem of the past; they would allow you to get back home safely after some drinks; eventually people would not need to learn to drive at all. The mere augmentation of human drivers, as useful as it would be, would not change much in our habits
- vonnik 11y agotypo in the headline. we need one more 'c' in accident.
- tjl 11y agoIs Google only testing in California? It seems that the data for accidents was given for the whole of the US, but it should be compared to California only. I don't know if it's noticeably different or not, but I'd think that snow and ice would increase the accident rate in some states. Snow and ice I think would provide a challenge for self-driving cars.
- illegalsmile 11y agoTurns out snow and ice provides challenges for cars driven by humans!
- tim333 11y ago>we have to figure out just how to test these vehicles so we can know when a safety goal has been met. We also have to figure out what the safety goal is. Or you can just crack ahead and try them with users like Tesla.
- f137 11y ago250,000 miles on average between accidents? Does anybody think this is unbelievably high number?
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoThe average human driver is consciously forgoing the option of driving in the hyper-conservative manner that the google cars do...