6 ms·
"It also alleges that women were treated better by managers in the media group. While men were immediately terminated after receiving low employee scores, women
by trhway 11y ago
"It also alleges that women were treated better by managers in the media group. While men were immediately terminated after receiving low employee scores, women were allowed to appeal their ratings, the suit says."
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIts hard to rectify gender bias without somebody crying foul.
- trhway 11y agoi'd say there are 2 schools of thought here - one is zero-sum game and another is that you can't make somebody more free or equal by increasing oppression or inequality toward somebody else.
- zorpner 11y agoRectifying inequality will always reduce the advantages of the privileged -- those advantages are the inequality. Whether they choose to pretend that they are now being oppressed or acknowledge that the status quo was unacceptable is up to them.
- jm_l 11y agoThat's true in the sense that if A has 50 resource points and B has 40, A has an advantage that is lost when, in rectifying inequality, we redistribute the resource points to 45-45. What is being suggested here, however, is that perhaps it is possible to find 10 extra resource points in the budget and give them to B so that we finish with 50-50.
- zorpner 11y agois that perhaps it is possible to find 10 extra resource points in the budget and give them to B so that we finish with 50-50. The point is that A will very often perceive this as a negative outcome.
- kelukelugames 11y agoLoss of privilege is often perceived as oppression. On the other hand, the creator of Dilbert just shrugged it off and started a new job each time his employer said they couldn't promote another white male.
- thatcat 11y agoequality requires not a loss of privilege, but an equal distribution of privilege. This means hiring/firing should give an equal consideration to both genders. A 50/50 m/f ratio is not a statistical "proof of equality".
- Chris2048 11y agoYeah, Rosa Parks shoulda shrugged it off and waited for another bus! Seriously though, 'often' is just a weasel word if you don't specify the context. This might qualify as a mechanism for dismissing valid complaints...
- kelukelugames 11y agoAre you comparing discrimination against black people in the 50s to what may have happened to a man? A lot of civil rights activists wanted affirmative action too. Often is most of the time. People perceive relative changes as terrible. That's why they arrested Parks instead of agreeing with her.
- Chris2048 11y agoWhy? It's an analogy, the relevant parts match; There's no rule that says discrimination has to reach a certain level before it should be resisted . Stop derailing my point with irrelevancies. "A lot of civil rights activist" - which ones and why? Maybe their reasoning is sensitive to their particular interest. I understand what 'often' means, I don't agree with it as a generality. Even 'People perceive relative changes as terrible' isn't always true.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThat may have been what was happening in the OP?
- epx 11y agoTrying to do that creates strong non-linearities and the end result is unlikely to create a healthy equilibrium.
- DannyBee 11y agoErr, why not let everyone appeal their rating? (I understand, percentage wise, due to bias or whatever, it's likely a higher percent of things would be overturned for women, but it's not like the error rate for non-women was 0 anyway, so why not just make a process that nobody is going to complain about?)
- shawn-furyan 11y agoIn my reading, the description of the process running in this manner is an allegation, not an established fact. So it's not really clear that Yahoo has anything to answer for on this point.
- DannyBee 11y agoSure, i understand. I meant my parent is complaining that clearly the women can appeal because of gender bias issues affecting them more heavily than men, as if that magically would make it okay. Instead, the thing that seems "okay" on that point would be "let the men appeal too" (IE my parent is wrong no matter what!)
- codeonfire 11y agoWhat would be the result of that? You appeal and find, oh management really did make a mistake and is incompetent of it's primary purpose of evaluating employee performance correctly. AND, management did in fact discriminate and now has proven it for any and all future and current lawsuits. There is literally no reason for management to allow ratings appeals.
- knughit 11y agoThat's like saying there is no reason for a single party government to investigate claims of corruption. Management is not a monolith.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoNatural Justice is one - in the UK not having a proper appeal procedure and applying it is normally an automatic "unfair dismissal" And if your a big company and take the piss in court you get the book thrown at you by the Triibuneral see Imarsat a few years ago.
- walshemj 11y agoYou don't do it by running a discriminatory discipline regime.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- munchbunny 11y agoSpeaking from experience, statements like this are often cases where the actual story was more benign than the perception, and the statement here is the perception, not the actual story. If this is true, then there's a huge problem, but I'm willing to believe (pending more information) that the policy isn't this blatantly sexist, and that the truth is somewhat more nuanced.
- piker 11y agoIt's also a lawyer trying to make a prima facie complaint to avoid summary dismissal of a lawsuit. As long as there's a good-faith belief that this could be true, including such an allegation in the complaint will expand the plaintiff's pre-trial discovery breadth. That costs Yahoo more money to defend, increases the likelihood of uncovering a smoking gun and puts the plaintiff in a better settlement negotiation posture.
- kelukelugames 11y agoThis is how lawsuits works. Employee has one valid complaint. Lawyer tacks on a dozen more complaints and hope the company settles.
- munchbunny 11y agoYeah, it's a pity that the system we put in place to make victims whole first asks us to say the worst about everybody involved, victim included. Not that I have a better idea, but I think there's a cruel irony to it.
- pc86 11y agoIt's the same in criminal law as well. You allegedly violated a law? Well here are four more that say the same thing in a slightly different way. Oh, you were within 100' of a school? Possibly longer jail time? It was a construction zone, too? Here's another three offenses that open you up to civil litigation as well.
- jonesb6 11y ago