8 ms·
Men Are Better at Maps Until Women Take This Course
- joefarish 11y agoWhat if men also take the course?
- krisoft 11y agoDescribed in the article. It improves their score on spatial tests too, but has no effect on long term retention.
- IshKebab 11y agoThe article said it had a smaller effect. Not none.
- thesz 11y agosmall effect on retention, not the "no effect". Also it is interesting how "small" effect is, is it absolutely or relatively small? Anyway, my small experiment had told me that even girly girls who participate in more or less manly sport activity (namely, karate) would score quite high in the tests from article. I actually tested several girls from karate group with the test like that, they were better than boys (though boys were older than girls).
- _monster_ 11y agoThere are massive differences between male/female brains. Chess world, STEM, imageboard demographics, this forum--90% men, etc show this. People always forget: Its one thing to invent/develop a system (eg calculus) and a totally other thing to learn an existing system (ie you are given all the answers and mostly are just understanding/memorizing). Men do all the inventing--eg there is no female Issac Newton.
- hueving 11y ago>no female Issac Newton That's because Isaac Newton was a man. Duh
- maho 11y agoEmmy Noether.
- kefka 11y agoThat's because all women from prior generations were "men": or that's what their pen names and ghostwriters were! http://www.webdesignschoolsguide.com/library/10-famous-females-who-used-male-pen-names.html http://www.webdesignschoolsguide.com/library/10-famous-femal... http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2013/13/130519-women-scientists-overlooked-dna-history-science/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2013/13/130519-women... Or better yet, find a man if you want to get published: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-30/academic-journal-tells-female-scientists-work-with-a-man-if-you-want-to-get-published http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-30/academic-j...
- panic 11y agoThere are massive differences between male/female brains. Chess world, STEM, imageboard demographics, this forum--90% men, etc show this. As far as I know, we are very far away from understanding how brain biology affects imageboard demographics. Are you a neurobiology expert? Have you considered any alternative hypotheses? Have you listened to women talk or write about why they avoid the kinds of places you mention?
- mafribe 11y agowe are very far away from understanding how brain biology affects That is very true and can't be repeated often enough. But it cuts both ways. There is nothing in our current state of understanding of neuroscience that categorically rules out biologically based differences in higher cognitive abilities between men and women.
- marklgr 11y agoBy that logic, there is no black Isaac Newton as well. Do you stand by it?
- kriro 11y agoI wonder if playing (mono colored) tangram[1] a lot as a kid helped my abilities. My sisters also liked the game and didn't find the typical rotational tasks on IQ tests harder than any of the other tasks. It's only 2d though, I'd be interested if solving 2d puzzles helps with understanding the 3d questions (like folding cubes). I'd like to see them compare their course to other tasks that might seem intuitively helpful. Folding origami with instructions is one thing that immediately comes to mind. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tangram https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tangram
- pstrateman 11y agoSure.. now what happens when men are given the same course?
- rdl 11y agoI'm really interested in which "intelligence" metrics can't be trained/learned. It seems obvious to me that playing with the specific blocks or diagrams used in an IQ test helps; and that practicing with one set seems to make me better able to do well with another only indirectly related set.
- tinco 11y agoI'm not an expert, but I researched this once. You can train any particular question that's asked at an IQ test, but someone can always think of new IQ test questions that you will fail if you're not smart enough (i.e. your brain adapts to new problems fast enough). There is a training program (I forgot the name) that trains you at solving IQ test problems sort of in general but it's unclear if it just trains people at solving the sort of questions that IQ test people tend to think of. The way I understand it the most reliable way of training for plasticity if it is possible at all is to learn as many different things as you can. That means: Learn to program, learn a language with a different root (Chinese), learn to dance, learn woodworking, learn to practice law, learn to do team sport, etc.. Basically have as many hobbies as you can. (Switching every X months) making sure they have as little in common as possible. Here's a talk on how long it takes to become 'good enough' at anything: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MgBikgcWnY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MgBikgcWnY Have fun ;)
- yamaneko 11y agoSuch a great advice! Thank you. Do you engage yourself on different hobbies such as you suggested? When do you stop one hobbie and move to another one?
- threatofrain 11y agoYou can develop your own IQ tests if you want, but chances are any IQ test you create will have a high concordance correlation with other IQ tests, and chances are the predictions you make from your new test will match the predictions of other IQ tests. In other words, it will probably validate the suspected construct behind IQ tests. The construct behind the IQ test is known as g, or general mental ability, as opposed to domain-specific ability. While it's true that repeated practice with a specific IQ test will boost performance, it won't boost it that much, and it won't generalize very well -- that kind of domain-specific improvement is not that interesting. One interesting IQ test you might want to peek at would be Raven's matrices. Raven's matrices involve a 2-dimensional grid of figures which progressively change due to some hidden factors. The goal is to rapidly generate hypotheses as to what factors might be controlling for the figures, and to make a prediction as to what comes next. On an aside, I think that the golden objective of AI is to develop a general thinking machine. Such a machine, when bounded by a goal, would be able to develop its own hardware drivers or make software better than itself. It would be able to tackle a game like Go without fine-tuning by expert Google employees, and that same machine would be able to look at scientific data and develop its own causal theories -- as opposed to a domain-specific Go machine, or a domain-specific Chess machine.
- IsaacL 11y agoCan any deep learning experts answer a related question I have? What's the state of the art in recognising rotated 3d objects? I know that deep learning systems can recognise, e.g., different animal toys held in the hand, at different distances from the camera. How about shapes which are rotated? (I assume shapes rotated with the same face showing the camera are fairly trivial to recognise, I mean the other two rotations - 'pitch' and 'yaw'). I have a hunch that humans have a ton of perceptual hardware devoted to precisely this task, and that deep neural nets are going to have a hard time cracking it. Is my hunch accurate?
- DanBC 11y agoYou may be interested in the "four mountains test" - a test for early diagnosis of dementia. Audio: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p03h7htk http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p03h7htk
- SeanDav 11y ago> "helped boost retention rates for female engineering students by 20 to 30 percent." Actually they do themselves a disservice with these numbers. while it is true that out of 100 students, 20-30 more will graduate, the pass (retention) rate goes up by 40-60%.
- qb45 11y ago> “If it was only cultural, it should be different in some cultures. It has to be some kind of biological factor, whether it’s hormones or evolution,” says Sorby. By this logic, the use of fire for cooking is "some kind of hormones or evolution thing", not culture. (Or are there any cultures that never cook?)
- masklinn 11y ago> By this logic, the use of fire for cooking is "some kind of hormones or evolution thing", not culture. That's not impossible at this point: humans don't fare that well on completely raw diet with studies of raw vegan diets show increases in amenorrhoea, underweightness, dental erosion and lower bone densities (raw non-vegan diet being possibly even riskier due to high concerns of food poisoning and food-borne diseases). Richard Wrangham has argued that modern humans are in fact obligate cooks (though he's also argued that modern human evolution was triggered by cooking, I know most anthropologists disagree with the latter, not sure about the former, could be an interesting question to ask in /r/askscience)
- qb45 11y agoOK, but if you raise a group of people somewhere in the middle of nowhere on 100% raw food, I'd hazard the guess that they'll sooner die of malnutrition or diseases than instinctively approach some fire and start cooking. And if this isn't culture then I don't know what is.
- ndonnellan 11y agoI can't help but think VR will make for some amazing "hands-on" experiences when it comes to teaching spatial concepts or abstract ones that have good analogs. Being able to poke and prod literally infinite shapes, from the real world or not, will probably make science and engineering more fun for everybody. However, I may be a bit biased. I did back the Oculus kickstarter.
- blakesterz 11y agoSo how do we apply this? I have a daughter struggling in math and I'd love to help her, if this is a magic bullet where do I find it. I only see mention of a "15 hour course" in this article.
- thesz 11y agoThe family of Sofia Kovalevskaya was so poor they used pages from math book as wallpaper. I have to note that my father did that trick too (made a poster with algebraic defs, etc and put it above my study table). I am relatively good at math.
- reacweb 11y agoIMHO, there is a statistical bias. A woman would not take this course if she struggle with the other mandatory courses or if she is not very motivated in studies.
- dawnbreez 11y agoThis is a dupe, but I can't find the original or my comment on it. I suspect the original was deleted. My comment was something along the lines of this: You can learn new skills by taking classes on them. In other news, scientists identify fluffy white object in sky as a 'cloud'.
- dang 11y agoIt wasn't deleted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11001091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11001091. On HN, though, please don't make snarky, shallow dismissals of new work. (It's far from obvious that you can learn any new skill by taking a class on it, and there's other interesting stuff in this article.)
- tokenadult 11y agoI saw comments asking for links to some of the program materials mentioned in the article, and while searching for those, I found a site[1] that appears to link to a wealth of information about spatial reasoning and training programs to improve spatial reasoning. Enjoy. [1] http://www.iwitts.org/proven-practices/retention-sub-topics/spatial-reasoning http://www.iwitts.org/proven-practices/retention-sub-topics/...
- douche 11y agoFrom the title, I was expecting this to be about navigation and map-reading, more than these classic spatial rotation problems. I'm not sure what it is, but I've certainly noticed that my mother, my sister, my aunts, all of my girlfriends, virtually everyone I've ever taken a roadtrip with with double X chromosomes, have struggled mightily with what I'll call "locational awareness" - tracking where they are vs where they have been vs where they are trying to go. Some of these have been brilliant people, but their brains just don't seem to work that way. I don't know if the ubiquity of GPS is helping or hurting this phenomenon.