3 ms·
I agree that a lot of "evolutionary arguments" that make their way as far as popular culture are indeed post-hoc "just-so stories". However... >Consider just
by dTal 11y ago
I agree that a lot of "evolutionary arguments" that make their way as far as popular culture are indeed post-hoc "just-so stories".
However...
>Consider just how much relative advantage with survival and replication any given feature must have in order to come to dominate ALL the other features that are competing in the population
Answer: very little! This is the advantage of sexual reproduction (or at least gene transfer) - it allows us to do our evolving "in parallel". A single "feature" might only convey a tiny advantage, and you'd think it'd be swamped by all the thousands of other features - but the "experiment" is repeated zillions of times, enough to bring it out of the statistical noise. It doesn't have to "make the difference" between reproductive success and failure in any particular instance. It also bears repeating that most "features" don't spring out fully formed - most "features" only convey a tiny advantage!
Sorry if this isn't a very good explanation. You've hit upon a key aspect of evolution, and I think you're right that there isn't a good, popular layperson's explanation of the mechanism that actually tackles the statistical aspect instead of glossing over it.
- EGreg 11y agoSorry if this isn't a very good explanation. You've hit upon a key aspect of evolution, and I think you're right that there isn't a good, popular layperson's explanation of the mechanism that actually tackles the statistical aspect instead of glossing over it. I want to reply in a very strongly worded way to this point. There is a huge disconnect between the assertions made by proponents (like Dawkins) of evolutionary explanations, that "evolution has been proven LIKE GRAVITY at this point" and the lack of widely accessible explanation of how the most obvious statistical questions are settled in favor of the theory actually working. I don't even mean comfortably working, like "it should have taken 3 trillion years but we got lucky". I mean like, how does a binary decision select for things that are not even correlated to survival or reproduction but merely comfort? And even more astonishingly, how is it able to take such long (1000s of generations) speculative paths, without any apparent benefit until the basic version of the thing is fully formed? Combine that with the contradictory empirical evidence of punctuated equilibria broken by genetic explosions and I'm not so sure the theory is correct. Mutation and natural selection seem insufficient to explain the features we see. But the disconnect between the dearth of actual answers (as available to someone with a mathematics background like me) with the insistence that evolution "is as sure as gravity" makes me skeptical. I find the situation very close to bullshit that is politically motivated and propagated through systematic bullying. I should point out that this is not for religious reasons but merely because the theory seems like one of those early simple theories (like the humors or luminiferous ether) that always felt off and were too simple. PS: just to be clear, I am not challenging the theory of common descent, but rather the proposed explanation for evolution as being completely a product of random mutation and natural selection -- evolution is a vague term which adds to the equivocation problem and is further evidence that there is strong political pressure in the scientific establishment to prop up the theory.
- sebastos 11y agoI find this an interesting line of argument, and I wouldn't be at all surprised to eventually find out that the current model is missing a lot of important "second-order" effects that contribute to the convergence towards good designs for life. I would be particularly interested to see if epigenetics play a larger role than we previously thought, because this would provide for a feedback mechanism. However, I wouldn't discount the importance of _sexual_ fitness being a part of the natural selection picture. In some sense, you have not just nature judging your genes, but an intelligent creature that can make judgments about all sorts of traits that are not critical for survival. Just by being very picky, we all contribute extreme selective pressure. I would also imagine there is somewhat of a runaway effects in this regard. If you confer a slightly crappy gene to your offspring, that will, on average, cause them to find a mate with slightly crappier genes themselves. Go a few generations down that road, and you might finally terminate. Just some food for thought. Obviously your central point that you would need some statistical backing to buy what I've written is well taken.
- marcosdumay 11y agoWell, not everything that is successfully modeled (sorry, but I won't go into arguing the meaning of "understood") can be described in a simple way. Obligatory xkcd: https://xkcd.com/1489/ https://xkcd.com/1489/ There are answer for people with a mathematical background. They aren't very simple, but they can be verified and simulated til you get tired. The fact is that from postulating a population where individuals die, with hereditary genetics, and a cross-over style sexual reproduction, and a changing landscape, Math goes to show that you'll have all those features you are uncomfortable with.
- Yen 11y ago> I mean like, how does a binary decision select for things that are not even correlated to survival or reproduction but merely comfort? If you're referring to > For example, lets say the human anorectal angle was specifically "evolved" for pooping while squatting. Is it a "just so" story or did the exact anorectal angle contribute SO MUCH to survival or reprosuction that it became the standard for bipedal humans? I don't think you need to assume that the particular angle and arrangement of organs there was evolved "for comfort", any more than we need to assume that fingers evolved for efficiently typing on keyboards. The simplest explanation is that the particular angle is just one that happened to work - and then, given the way our bodies work, we try to find the most comfortable posture to poop in. It could have easily been the case that any other angle would also have been the default, and maybe we'd be most comfortable pooping while standing, sitting, or some other posture.